3 ms·
Ridiculous: Mines’s definition of a civil war is large-scale violence that includes a rejection of traditional political authority and requires the Natio
by wahern 9y ago
Ridiculous:
Mines’s definition of a civil war is large-scale violence
that includes a rejection of traditional political authority
and requires the National Guard to deal with it.
By that definition the U.S. has experienced civil war, episodically, for a significant part of it's existence.
- mjevans 9y agoTo put things in perspective, I think by "Mines"'s definition, the post Rodney King riots would still be 'medium scale'.
- zekevermillion 9y agoAlso not useful to talk about such risks as a "percentage" chance. What does that mean -- given a significant sample of normally distributed parallel universes, the current situation would result in civil war? And, if it does, the impact is huge so perhaps even a 1% chance is something to worry about. Overall, not a useful way to think about political futures.
- Waterluvian 9y agoIt's an interesting thought. Civil war was obvious because it was total war. It became the focus of the entire nation. But the U.S. has become increasingly effective at going to war without it being total war. I wonder if it can do the same with itself?
- handedness 9y agoThat the US can wage small wars abroad without impacting its domestic capital production and labor bases much at all is due largely to asymmetry of forces, economies, and of course distance. Another American civil war that isn't just brief and minor discretionary intervention by the Nat'l Guard (as in the LA riots or Katrina)–which is an awfully poor definition of civil war–but rather is more like 1861-1865, would significantly impact domestic quality of life. In fact, I'd wager the American middle-ground between the small regional events it's experienced in recent history and total chaos is small, if it exists at all. Which is probably what will keep it from happening, so long as most people are reasonably prosperous, which is likely to be the case, assuming it deals gracefully with the rapidly dwindling lower middle class and the rapid consolidation of production (a non-trivial assumption).
- dragonwriter 9y agoWhile the National Guard (and even occasionally the federal mikitary) has been periodically called up for disturbances, very few of them involved rejection of traditional political authority. (And while here have been numerous movements rejecting traditional political authority, they have rarely been met with the National Guard.) It's true that the standard has been met more than just in the 1860s, but it has not been met “for a significant part of [the US's] existence.”
- wahern 9y agoJust a few examples: * 1914 Ludlow Massacres: National Guard trained machine guns on a tent city with women and children -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludlow_Massacre * 1979 Greensboro Massacre: National Guard deployed after shootout between Communist Workers' Party and Ku Klux Kklan. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greensboro_massacre * 1970 Kent State Shootings -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kent_State_shootings * Great Railroad Strike of 1877: National Guard deployments across the country. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Railroad_Strike_of_1877 * 1892 Homestead Massacre: National Guard deployed after Pinkertons shoot on strikers. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_Strike * 1894 Pullman Strike: Nationwide strike. National Guard shoots into crowd of civilians in Illinois. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pullman_Strike * 1903-1904 Colorado Labor Wars: National Guard one of several antagonists in violent dispute between miners and mine owners. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colorado_Labor_Wars * 1957 Little Rock, Arkansas: National Guard deployed by Arkansas Governor to _prevent_ black students from entering school. I could go on and on. And that's just famous instances where the National Guard showed up. Many times they were deliberately and even maliciously _not_ deployed. I'm also ignoring the decades before and after the Civil War where there was all kinds of unrest, as well as the post-Revolutionary period, such as the famous 1791 Whiskey Rebellion.
- dragonwriter 9y agoMost of those deployments are not against forces rejecting traditional political authority.