5 ms·
Jumping Ship from iPhone to Android: A Switcher's Guide
- kgrin 16y agoFWIW, a few of the items seem to be specific to Sense UI; the unlock swipe, for instance, is L > R on my Nexus One, not top-down.
- Aaronontheweb 16y agoI've been considering doing this myself, not because of the virtues of either device platform per-say, but because of the exorbitant rates I pay for AT&T's spotty service. Edit: in other words, if I switch to an Android phone it'll be because of a better carrier like Verizon.
- cmelbye 16y agoThis seems a little inaccurate. Voice capabilities are available as an API usable in any app, and there is a Google app and a Bing app if you need voice searching. "Instant Web" didn't make much sense either. The iPhone has built in e-mail, calendar, contacts, etc. If you need it to sync over-the-air, Mobile Me and Microsoft Exchange are included as well, and Google's services work with Microsoft Exchange.
- commandar 16y agoLifehacker is still recommending task killer apps? Those things are almost entirely regarded a Bad Idea™ among the Android crowd.
- roboneal 16y agoI count myself among the "Android crowd" and Advanced Task Killer has nearly tripled the battery life on my T-Mobile MyTouch slide post-installation. I can't cite a single negative side-effect of using it for the past 3 months.
- joeyo 16y agoWhich apps are you "killing" that are putatively improving your battery life?
- roboneal 16y agoT-mobile has built in apps deployed with their "skin" like "My Account" and "Genius Button" - that will always "hang around" if not killed. Your mileage may vary from phone to phone.
- ergo98 16y agoHanging around = doing absolutely nothing, sitting in memory that is unused. The paradox is that people using task killers often force the system to keep restarting apps it wouldn't have had to restart. This is the same nonsensical behavior that has people clearing their file system cache because it's "leaking memory". My other post has been modded down, so I'll save the niceties: Most of the people who swear by ATK do so because they are ignorant, either knowingly or because they've been misled by others.
- roboneal 16y agoNice crusade you are on here - I guess you can put me in your somewhat implausible "knowingly ignorant" group. Maybe you were modded down for being in the "knowingly troll-ish" group.
- jrockway 16y agoYou're being downmodded because you're wrong. If you want T-Mobile's stuff to go away, install a ROM that doesn't have those things. Moving my stock myTouch3G to CM was the best thing I ever did; T-Mobile's image is massively out of date and sucks. Install up-to-date software, and the phone works much better. Yeah, I know "average users" don't want to root their phone and install custom firmwares, but you aren't an average user. Use your intelligence to solve the problem instead of convincing yourself you're working around it.
- rogermugs 16y agoits not the apps, its the multitasking-killing-the-battery i still don't understand. a phone that needs to be charged even once (let along 3 times) in the middle of the day is simply not usable. end of story. i dont get it.
- jrockway 16y agoIndeed. The problem is that the original Android devices (Dream/Sapphire/Hero) were shitty hardware with barely any RAM. So the GC algorithm killed peoples' homescreens when they loaded a big app, and they assumed that background tasks were causing that. They killed something like "Maps", switched to a tiny app, and noticed that their homescreen didn't get killed anymore, so clearly Task Managers are necessary. Oh well, sometimes a feeling of control is enough to make you feel less bad about having shitty hardware, so I guess task killers are good for that reason.
- commandar 16y agoI honestly believe that's the only reason task killers are as popular as they are. That and memory management is so complicated that most people don't really understand it. See also: NT6.
- jpcx01 16y agoThere's advantages and disadvantages to switching. However Verizon has been the saving factor. In my area, the 3g of Verizon is 2 to 3 times as fast as it was on my old ATT plan. Also, its very nice to be free of some of the stupid iphone limitations (like not being able to download podcasts to the phone automatically). It's also very nice to have a a couple extra spare couple batteries that I can swap in (motorola droid) to extend the battery life.
- maxharris 16y agoCan you do the battery swap without restarting the phone and without plugging it in? If you can't, it's not a worthwhile feature for me. If I need to carry a power adapter, I might as well just plug the phone in to recharge it. By making the battery non-removable, Apple can put a bigger battery in, which is something I can use. It also makes the phone itself lighter and stronger, too.
- cageface 16y agoThat SlideScreen app they reference right up front uses an Autechre track for the demo video: http://slidescreenhome.com/ http://slidescreenhome.com/ Did they get permission? Has Ae been used in a commercial before?
- mattmanser 16y agoNothing compelling to switch from the iPhone. A slightly more advanced navigation app? Woohoo. Tight integration with google apps? There's a big surprise, Google trying to take over your life is an ever increasing threat/normality that is rapidly pushing it into Microsoft levels of people hating it. Most of the rest of it is actually negative points, bad touch screens, poorly monitored app store allowing spyware through (who'd have thought it? defending the app store, wow), low default storage capacity (but extendable, wow, ever think I just want it to work?), bizzare button implementations. He doesn't sound convinced himself that android is even worth it. As a Brit who doesn't have to put up with AT&T, all this did was reinforce my belief that the iPhone is so, so much better.
- jdietrich 16y agoThey don't mention Google Accounts integration, which seems a bit odd - it's my absolute favourite feature of Android. The integration of Mail, Contacts and Calendar feels incredibly 'cloudy', for want of a better word - it's the incredible lightness of not having to worry about where your data is.
- jwcooper 16y agoI haven't used an android phone, but the iPhone can use the cloud features of Google Accounts as well (maybe not as slick though?). Using Google Sync works pretty well on the iPhone for the calendar, contacts, and mail.
- vetinari 16y agoIt not just "using cloud features of Google Accounts". On Android, you _don't sync_. You just add new contact to your phone and in few seconds, it is in the cloud. Or add contact through web interface and in few seconds, it is in your phone. When you start using it, you stop worrying about where did you put your contact and whether you synced it. It is just everywhere applicable, automatically.
- astine 16y agoYes they do. It's one of the first things they mention.
- extension 16y agoThe darker side to this is that you don't get any choice where your data is, at least with the address book. It's gmail or bust.
- natrius 16y agoI'm pretty sure any app can use those hooks to function as a contact source or sink. For example, I think the Yahoo apps do this, but I've never used them. http://ymobileblog.com/blog/2010/06/30/yahoo-brings-its-world-class-communications-experiences-to-your-android-phone-plus-introduces-the-all-new-html5-mobile-web-mail/ http://ymobileblog.com/blog/2010/06/30/yahoo-brings-its-worl...
- theBobMcCormick 16y agoDear god can we please stop with the iPhone vs. Android crap around here? I can see where posts about revenue in the App Store or the Market are Hacker News. I can even see where posts about the relative sales volume and/or growth trends are Hacker News, but this?