4 ms·
Well, in a nutshell, it's not a Ponzi scheme, which is not just a random slur you can fire at anything that vaguely seems like fraud, but a specific scheme that
by jerf 9y ago
Well, in a nutshell, it's not a Ponzi scheme, which is not just a random slur you can fire at anything that vaguely seems like fraud, but a specific scheme that works in a specific way.
In particular, it isn't clear to me how you can have a "decentralized" Ponzi scheme without making it something fundamentally different from a Ponzi scheme.
To the extent that BitCoin may be fraudulent or people may be engaging in illegal behavior, it's going to be other things. Perhaps somewhere someone's even running an actual Ponzi scheme using BitCoin. But BitCoin itself is not a Ponzi scheme.
- bandrami 9y agoCurrent bitcoin holders can only see gain if new "investment" (I find that term funny since it's a "security" with no fundamentals) comes in. That's pretty much the definition of a Ponzi scheme. Perhaps somewhere someone's even running an actual Ponzi scheme using BitCoin. Sure, but that's a different question. I'm talking about new investment in a security being the only source of increased value in that security. Which is what a Ponzi scheme is.
- Phil987 9y agoBitcoin is an alternative currency, really the only thing going up is the exchange rate.
- wickawic 9y agoBut what makes something a currency? If in an alternate universe Bernie Madoff printed MadoffBucks and made agreements that you could use these as currency in some online stores and Pizza Hut, does that make it a real currency? Unfortunately I think the only way something becomes a currency is when a government calls it one.
- nicky0 9y agoIt may not be a currency, depending how you choose to define that word, but it is certainly a fungible asset and a means of exchange. It acts both as a store of value and as method of transferring value from one party to another.
- canoebuilder 9y agoI've not done a quantitative analysis, but it seems to have been more frequently ruled as some sort of asset or commodity https://www.google.com/search?q=bitcoin+ruled https://www.google.com/search?q=bitcoin+ruled Exchange rate, also known as 'cost,' is a form of value.
- ianferrel 9y ago>Current bitcoin holders can only see gain if new "investment" (I find that term funny since it's a "security" with no fundamentals) comes in. That's pretty much the definition of a Ponzi scheme. Equally true of most other commodities and currencies, right? If you have a gold bar, or a stack of 10 Euro notes, the only way you make money off of it is if enough more people want to buy gold/Euros that the price goes up. Neither asset does anything on its own. A critical ingredient of a Ponzi scheme is fraud.
- bandrami 9y agoEqually true of most other commodities and currencies, right? No; if I hold a stock I receive a dividend from the company and a vote in their governance; if I hold a bond I receive interest payments; if I hold bauxite I can use it to make whatever you make with bauxite.
- kobeya 9y agoA stock or bond is neither a commodity nor a currency.
- pbh101 9y agoThe price of a traded item can go up, even with no investment: people do not have to trade for the price to increase or decrease. Sometimes price movements coincide with lots of actual trades occurring, and sometimes they coincide with very few/no trades occurring. The latter happens once in awhile. Taken to the extreme to illustrate: if everyone together today instantly decided each bitcoin was worth $1b, then in that first instant, nobody would sell and no trades would occur, but the price would be very different.
- muti 9y agoIf the price is determined by how much someone is willing to buy or sell for, how do you determine the price when there are no trades being made? How does simply deciding 1 bitcoin is worth $1b effect the value of bitcoin if no one is willing to buy at that price?
- kaffeemitsahne 9y agoThe definition of ponzi scheme is a scheme where dividends to early investors are paid using the investments of later investors. That's a significant difference from simply an appreciation in value. By your logic, precious metals could also be ponzi schemes.
- bandrami 9y agoPrecious metals have absolutely been operated as Ponzi schemes before (remember the dude who pump & dumped the silver market in the 70s?)
- guardiangod 9y agoAre you saying the silver market behaved as a Ponzi scheme? No. A person was using the silver market as a ponzi scheme vehicle, it doesn't mean the silver market itself was a ponzi scheme. Same as Bitcoin here. A devious actor could use Bitcoin as the product for a ponzi scheme, that doesn't mean bitcoin is a ponzi scheme as much as the tulip bulb market itself is a ponzi scheme.
- tetrep 9y ago> Current bitcoin holders can only see gain if new "investment" (I find that term funny since it's a "security" with no fundamentals) comes in. That's pretty much the definition of a Ponzi scheme. That's 1/2 a Ponzi scheme, the other 1/2 is an entity promising you a return. I think you'd need to commit some fraud along the way too. If someone said "For every 5 dollars given to me, I will provide a share, and dispense 1/(2*N) dollars to all other shareholders, where N is the number of other shareholders (N=0 for the first donation, 1 for the second, etc)." Would that be a Ponzi scheme? There's no fraud, so I don't think it would be, despite having identical mechanics.
- jerf 9y ago"I'm talking about new investment in a security being the only source of increased value in that security. Which is what a Ponzi scheme is." That is not a Ponzi scheme. A Ponzi scheme is giving someone payouts on their investment funded solely from people putting the money in, while fraudulently telling them that the money is coming from real investment. You can't have a Ponzi scheme when on average both sides of the transaction are (generally) aware of the situation and aware of how the value is flowing, because you lack the fraudulent aspect. Also, for any given transaction, value is flowing instantaneously; when someone sells their bitcoin, they aren't getting paid in funds being fraudulently kept aside from somebody else's previous purchases. It's an instant commodity exchange. Again, in a nutshell, the reason why this doesn't fall afoul of laws against Ponzi schemes is that it simply isn't one.
- foepys 9y ago> Well, in a nutshell, it's not a Ponzi scheme, which is not just a random slur you can fire at anything that vaguely seems like fraud, but a specific scheme that works in a specific way. Please explain. How is Bitcoin not a Ponzi scheme? It checks all boxes: - No immediate value, nothing in Bitcoin has worth outside of it. No IP, no machines, no added value to society - Old investors get paid exclusively by new investors (buy at $500, sell at $3,000) - Heavy marketing by old investors through promises of extreme gains ("if you bought in 2011, you'd have made 10,000% gains right now!")
- SippinLean 9y ago> Old investors get paid exclusively by new investors They absolutely do not, no dividends are paid in Bitcoin by any entity. Bitcoin's value may rise based on many factors, of which new buyers are only one (not the "exclusive" factor as you claim).
- jerf 9y ago"Please explain." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15020232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15020232 , up or down thread a bit.
- slg 9y agoPeople often get confused between Ponzi schemes and pyramid schemes. Bitcoin could be described as a pyramid scheme in that it relies on new money constantly coming in so that people who previously committed money can cash out. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyramid_scheme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyramid_scheme
- SippinLean 9y agoExcept in Bitcoin you are sold a product, unlike a Pyramid scheme
- slg 9y agoFrom the Wikipedia link... >Pyramid schemes however "may purport to sell a product, but they often simply use the product to hide their pyramid structure".
- SippinLean 9y agoThey "may," Bitcoin doesn't. From the source of that quote: >They promise consumers or investors large profits based primarily on recruiting others to join their program, not based on profits from any real investment or real sale of goods to the public By contrast Bitcoin profits are based on the real investment in Bitcoins, which are really sold to the public. They go on: >little or no product moves to market Obviously very different than Bitcoin https://www.ftc.gov/public-statements/1998/05/pyramid-schemes https://www.ftc.gov/public-statements/1998/05/pyramid-scheme...
- slg 9y agoThat full section. >Pyramid schemes now come in so many forms that they may be difficult to recognize immediately. However, they all share one overriding characteristic. They promise consumers or investors large profits based primarily on recruiting others to join their program, not based on profits from any real investment or real sale of goods to the public. Some schemes may purport to sell a product, but they often simply use the product to hide their pyramid structure. There are two tell-tale signs that a product is simply being used to disguise a pyramid scheme: inventory loading and a lack of retail sales. Inventory loading occurs when a company's incentive program forces recruits to buy more products than they could ever sell, often at inflated prices. If this occurs throughout the company's distribution system, the people at the top of the pyramid reap substantial profits, even though little or no product moves to market. The people at the bottom make excessive payments for inventory that simply accumulates in their basements. A lack of retail sales is also a red flag that a pyramid exists. Many pyramid schemes will claim that their product is selling like hot cakes. However, on closer examination, the sales occur only between people inside the pyramid structure or to new recruits joining the structure, not to consumers out in the general public. It notes "lack of retail sales is also a red flag that a pyramid exist". What percentage of Bitcoin sales involve actual transactions of goods or services and not just a speculative investment? The price of Bitcoin has gone up some 2000% in the last two years when it simultaneously seems harder to spend when companies like Dell have stopped accepting it. It certainly seems like Bitcoin shows a lack of retail transactions.