4 ms·
This is an interesting article, but it's more about the changing landscape of academic publishing than it is about random number generators. [EDIT] The actual
by lisper 9y ago
This is an interesting article, but it's more about the changing landscape of academic publishing than it is about random number generators.
[EDIT] The actual paper is here: http://www.pcg-random.org/pdf/hmc-cs-2014-0905.pdf http://www.pcg-random.org/pdf/hmc-cs-2014-0905.pdf
- pedrocr 9y agoOnly if it turns out the work is actually good. If not this is exactly what should happen in peer review.
- lisper 9y agoYou don't think the peer review process ever produces false negatives?
- tptacek 9y agoYou didn't ask me, but I'll confirm that it definitely does.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dsacco 9y agoThe peer review process absolutely produces false negatives, but that doesn't really change the fact that this paper doesn't need to be nearly 60 pages, doesn't sufficiently analyze one of its central premises (6.2.2 Security Considerations) and in general focuses on treatise and levity rather than rigor.
- User23 9y agoPeer review is basically just proof-reading, and taking 60 pages to present 10 pages of findings is exactly the kind of thing a proof-reader should catch.
- CalChris 9y agoThat is exactly what peer review should do, to determine whether the idea has merit. But that isn't what has happened. Peer review which is a cornerstone to the academic/scientific community stumbled on style and didn't get to merit.
- dsacco 9y agoI disagree, I think the peer review functioned exactly as it was supposed to. Her paper doesn't pass the sniff test for me whatsoever when it comes to security analysis. She spent close to no time analyzing the primitives she introduced (and with no proofs or rigor!), meanwhile the thing is 58 pages because she takes the time to explain what "determinism" and "seeds" are to her audience. "Exposition" is, in my opinion, a fully valid reason to reject a paper. I'm not going to sit and read your 60 page paper that could have been compressed to 10 pages if you just got to the point and assumed your audience understood the field well enough to assess your results. Rewrite it and send it back without the assumption that your audience needs to be reminded of everything they'd need to learn just to properly assess your result. It's not as though they rejected the paper on empirical grounds without a meritocratic review; they rejected it because they have a finite amount of time and (speaking as someone in the field) it's sort of annoying to read after page 10. I think academia frequently gets lost in the ivory tower and loses touch with what an accessible paper looks like; this is not an answer to that, it's a swing in the other direction, where papers with truly novel results will suddenly be hundreds of pages and tens of pages of setup.
- CalChris 9y agoIf you don't like it then don't read it or don't publish it. But sniff test and exposition are style. Ding it for not analyzing her primitives but don't then call that security analysis. Do the security analysis. In patents there's the concept of enablement: did the inventor enable/teach the idea? Yes she did. Did she flesh out every idea? No she didn't. This was rejected on style grounds. Ignoring it then on 'security analysis' is not improving matters; it certainly isn't helping security. Do the security analysis.
- 9y ago