2 ms·
The current body of medical literature is at best ambivalent about the risk of long-term exposure. That's not an appeal to authority, that's just checking on th
by KirinDave 19y ago
The current body of medical literature is at best ambivalent about the risk of long-term exposure. That's not an appeal to authority, that's just checking on the state of the literature.
Science is always open to revision, and so I don't think it's impossible that this is true (indeed, I use a handsfree religiously to minimize my potential risk). But there isn't any hard evidence, and one study does should not a panic take, especially given the profound and subjectively positive social implications of mobile computing and mobile communication.
The article has nothing new for me, except sensationalist rhetoric and carefully worded (and carelessly paraphrased) "Mobile Operator Association points to these studies", when really that's the gross body of the current medical literature. It's not cherry-picked literature, the bulk of the literature suggests it is not true. That's not a conflict of interest, that's just pointing to the independently funded science.
As for the story about the top floor of the tower, why would only their heads be getting cancer if they're being universally exposed? The plural of anecdote is anecdotes, not data.
Whenever we have a somewhat difficult to reproduce condition with less-than-certain explanation in terms of the physical method, I demand more solid evidence before taking drastic action. I also think that news outlets like the register should take more responsibility and demand more evidence before pulling out the dramatic horn kicks and warming up a headline like this one.
People have been expressing fear over EMF for a long time now, and in general these fears have been dismissed and unsupported by scientific examination. Until I see some hard evidence, I consider a cellphone is about as harmful as a microwave. That is to say, there are small potential risks (particularly with damaged units), but I'm more likely to be struck by a car while commuting to work.