3 ms·
> Is it people who support Nazis who downvote this There are certainly a lot of people on here who are very keen to point out that the Nazis aren't that bad be
by zimpenfish 9y ago
> Is it people who support Nazis who downvote this
There are certainly a lot of people on here who are very keen to point out that the Nazis aren't that bad because [bullshit reasons], yes.
- nl 9y agoAre there? I mean, I see lots of false equivalence arguments and (possibly fair, possibly not) criticisms of political violence from left-leaning groups. But surely no one is arguing "Nazis aren't bad" on HN?
- viridian 9y ago>I see lots of false equivalence arguments and (possibly fair, possibly not) If they are fair then it's just equivalence, not false equivalence. I feel like this has become the new vogue term thrown around since Charlottesville happened, and it's seeing a lot of misuse. Most people don't even bother to explain why the equivalence is false, thus attempting to shut down the conversation in the manner of the fallacy fallacy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_fallacy
- nl 9y ago>> I see lots of false equivalence arguments and (possibly fair, possibly not) criticisms of political violence from left-leaning groups > If they are fair then it's just equivalence, not false equivalence. I think you are misparsing my statement. The "and" separates two sub-statements: 1) I see lots of false equivalence arguments, and, additionally 2) I see lots of (possibly fair, possibly not) criticisms of political violence from left-leaning groups
- AnotXOR 9y agoWhat is true and fair is that Obama failed to condemn numerous left-wing violent acts and so far Trump has condemned all of the ones that the media attributes to the right, and the left for that matter but that's probably a negative to many posters here.
- ceejayoz 9y ago> But surely no one is arguing "Nazis aren't bad" on HN? Not so openly. Plenty of dog whistles, though.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> But surely no one is arguing "Nazis aren't bad" on HN? If your first instinct is to minimise the Nazis (historical or new) by way of comparison to [anything else], then yeah, I would say they're arguing exactly that.
- freehunter 9y agoThey’re not saying “Nazis aren’t bad”, they’re saying “these guys with swastikas and Nazi symbols holding guns and shouting Nazi slogans are actually political moderates and true Americans”.