5 ms·
I don't understand the claim that moderates have no voice in the United States. I'm not American, but have spent quite a lot of time in the country. From my po
by pavlov 9y ago
I don't understand the claim that moderates have no voice in the United States.
I'm not American, but have spent quite a lot of time in the country. From my point of view, most of the media is moderate left -- and they have a very loud voice indeed. The extreme left exists but has very little visibility compared to France, for example. (That is convenient for right-wing press like Breitbart, because it lets them paint boogeymen inside the outlines of shapeless outrage-based movements like Black Lives Matter.)
American moderate right is a strange group. Polls suggest they have a lot of support, but their leaders seem to have decided not to use their voice. It's not like they're being silenced -- more like they're afraid to speak up. A few people like Senator Jeff Flake are a counterexample that shows what the American right could be, if they decided to stop pandering to an incompatible mishmash of base instincts at the fringe of their party.
- humanrebar 9y ago> A few people like Senator Jeff Flake are a counterexample that shows what the American right could be... I think you're understating how much of the American right dislikes Trump. Actual conservatives supported Cruz and Rubio (both of whom have been very consistently critical of Trump's shenanigans). Ben Sasse and Rand Paul are also very vocal. In print, National Review, The Federalist, Commentary, and similar news organizations have been against Trump since the Republican primary, not in small part to his playing footsie with racists.
- op00to 9y agoWhat's the point of "disliking" Trump if they don't get rid of him?
- humanrebar 9y agoWell, Cruz didn't exactly throw in the towel and become a fan. And there's always next time.
- hsod 9y agohttp://www.cnn.com/2016/09/23/politics/ted-cruz-endorses-donald-trump/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2016/09/23/politics/ted-cruz-endorses-don...
- croon 9y agoYou are correct. The problem is that the current president and the non-quiet part of the GOP wants to paint the factual moderate news media (or "MSM") as a liberal conspiracy.
- humanrebar 9y ago> the factual moderate news media It's not a conspiracy. You can have emergent bias as much as planned bias. That's basically the position of various HR departments who offer unconscious bias training. At any rate, every study I've seen has confirmed that most media orgs at least lean left. Have you seen any that disagree?
- pavlov 9y agoThe fundamental bias here is not the media, but the definition of "left". If you transplanted CNN into France or Germany, their editorial position would be on the mainstream center-right. For example, I've noticed that a lot of Americans think of Angela Merkel as a leftist. But she's a right-wing conservative from a party called "Christian Democratic Union"! In a way, the American media has been successfully gerrymandered: the extreme right has been pulling the left/right demarcation line towards them for decades.
- humanrebar 9y agoThere's not enough space here to get into it in too much detail, but for historical reason, the American right isn't (*) the same thing as the European right. Hundreds of years ago, the U.S. was a constitutional republic with working federalism and a limited national government. Hundreds of years ago, Europe was a lot of things, but often there were monarchs and dictators. So things that seem rather moderate to a European (nationalising some industry) is a brand new thing in the American context. There are also complexities in that America doesn't really have a clearly defined racial, religious, or ethnic identity. The common identity in America mostly centers around ideas and individual rights, so the American right has much more interest in liberty, relatively, compared to the European right.
- PhoneRemote 9y ago> Polls suggest they have a lot of support, but their leaders seem to have decided not to use their voice. Is that really true? Just off the top of my head, Lindsey Graham has been pretty vocal the last few months. I would paint him as a poster boy of the American moderate right (holding fairly conservative positions but clearly opposed to the more extreme American right). If you mean the actual leadership, e.g. Paul Ryan, well I think it's obvious why they've stayed silent. I think those moderate voices are just being drowned out.
- specialist 9y agoThere are a few significant factors at play: #1 Gerrymandering has enabled polarization. Previously, some competition in the general election ("left" vs "right") moderated the candidates. Now the real election is in party primaries ("right" vs "more right"), which are low turnout events of mostly "the base". Result elected officials have become more extreme. #2 The money game changed. Tom DeLay and others took control of the campaign contributions funnel. At the same time, cost of running campaigns continues to rapidly increase. So any one who wants to hold office has to kiss the ring. #3 The resulting polarization has made legislating far more difficult. Best explanation I've read so far is Unorthodox Lawmaking, Rulemaking http://columbialawreview.org/content/unorthodox-lawmaking-unorthodox-rulemaking/ http://columbialawreview.org/content/unorthodox-lawmaking-un... -- How do we fix this? Biggest step is independent redistricting commissions, with citizen oversight (approval). Gerrymandering is mostly incumbent protection schemes. Citizens (voters) hate the result. Support for independent commissions is something like 80/20 (no-brainer). Next biggest step would be to eliminate the two party system by replacing our winner takes all (FPTP) form of elections with Approval Voting. Cite Duverger's Law. Some people advocate other systems, like proportional representation. Great idea; I think Approval Voting is an easier sell. Reduce the costs of campaigning. So much we can do here. Restore fairness doctrine, time box campaigning, better GOTV/voter education efforts, unify & simplify voter registration (eg automatic, universal), etc.