4 ms·
My question would be, has Julian lied about sources before, and would he deviate from that if he didn't? His claim is that the source is not Russia --people wh
by mc32 9y ago
My question would be, has Julian lied about sources before, and would he deviate from that if he didn't?
His claim is that the source is not Russia --people who were happy to see Julian leak things (and believe his leaks) while Bush was president are now calling him a puppet of Putin. I have no idea if Putin has goods on him. Or whether Julian is just a medium. It is, however, interesting to see people shift along political axes though.
If there was a Russian angle, I think their aim was to cause uncertainty regardless of winner. Be it Trump or Hillary, whoever the winner was, the voters of the opposition would question the results --despite there being no actual election hacking (altering the vote count).
One interesting thing though is that since the media writ large expected Hillary to win, had she won, this same evidence would have been "page 6" news and would have been rather quickly forgotten but for a few "sore losers".
- wnevets 9y ago>His claim is that the source is not Russia --people who were happy to see Julian leak things (and believe his leaks) while Bush was president are now calling him a puppet of Putin. I have no idea if Putin has goods on him. Or whether Julian is just a medium. It is, however, interesting to see people shift along political axes though. Wikileaks was actively campaigning for trump. Wikileaks came out and said they had "proof" clinton was a witch for christ's sake.
- mc32 9y ago>Wikileaks was actively campaigning for trump. Wikileaks came out and said they had "proof" clinton was a witch for christ's sake I have not seen that. What I've read is that one of Podesta's leaked emails reference something along the lines of "spirit cooking" or whatever (and whatever that was code for) and some people outside WikiLeaks (obviously conspiracy theorists on the right) ran with that as evidence she (not even Podesta) was some kind of witch.
- tyingq 9y agoRegarding the spirit cooking: https://www.conservativereview.com/articles/wtf-is-spirit-cooking-and-why-is-it-trending https://www.conservativereview.com/articles/wtf-is-spirit-co... So, weird, but not witchcraft. Just the typical sort of performance art that I never understand. And the context of the email is there. Nobody was seeking out a "spirit cooking" experience. Just an invitation from an eccentric artist.
- mc32 9y agoHa! Well, thanks to Jane's Addiction, I think I know that better referenced as santaria.
- wnevets 9y agoWikileak's twitter [1] literally linked to a website that says clinton is a satan worshipping witch. [1] https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/794450623404113920?lang=en https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/794450623404113920?lang...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- paulie_a 9y agoWhile I wouldn't go that far, but Wikileaks essentially consists of Julian at this point. And in my opinion he is a media whore so he will increasingly do whatever it takes to get that attention he craves. On the spectrum he is in the category of "Chaotic Me Me ME"
- imron 9y ago> but Wikileaks essentially consists of Julian at this point It does not, which is how Wikileaks was able to keep publishing when the Ecuadorian embassy took away his internet access.
- blackrose 9y agoFrom the intelligence community assessment [0]: > The Kremlin’s principal international propaganda outlet RT (formerly Russia Today) has actively collaborated with WikiLeaks. RT’s editor-in-chief visited WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange at the Ecuadorian Embassy in London in August 2013, where they discussed renewing his broadcast contract with RT, according to Russian and Western media. Russian media subsequently announced that RT had become "the only Russian media company" to partner with WikiLeaks and had received access to "new leaks of secret information." RT routinely gives Assange sympathetic coverage and provides him a platform to denounce the United States. [0] https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/ICA_2017_01.pdf https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/ICA_2017_01.pdf
- mc32 9y agoWL also worked with the NYT and The Guardian and no one was calling him a puppet of the US or the UK. Sure, it's possible he's FSB (or whatever) secret unit and he's their Trojan horse --but no one was saying that during the Bush years (or even Obama minus '16). Only now do they say, oh, he's such a puppet. It's hard to take the allegation seriously when previously many of the same people had no problem with him.
- blackrose 9y agoPeople in the intelligence community consider Snowden a Russian asset now. Russia could've flipped or co-opted Assange since the Bush years, or maybe it's only now coming out. Either way much of this stuff is classified, so we can't really know details one way or the other. But if you keep up with folks in the IC and look into how Russia does warfare, you see they've been doing this forever, and they're pros at it.
- PeterisP 9y agoThere's a big difference between NYT/Guardian, which de facto are somewhat independent private media (and not quite aligned with Trump and May), and RT, which is a fully controlled instrument of the state, implementing only state policy.
- nl 9y agoThis is speculation and personal opinion, unlike the stuff I wrote above. I suspect what happened is that the hacking groups gave Wikileaks the dump via a cut-out. It's entirely possible that cut-out isn't aware how the data was obtained. I don't think Assange is a Russian agent (even though he receives money from RT etc). I think he has his own motives. At the time this was more anti-Clinton that pro-Trump specifically. More recently his Tweets have become more supportive of Trump personally (although interestingly not really his agendas necessarily). My uncharitable suspicion is that he's hoping for a presidential pardon. this same evidence would have been "page 6" news and would have been rather quickly forgotten but for a few "sore losers". Of course. There's plenty of similar evidence that the Russians also supported the Green party and Sanders campaigns in various forms. No one talks about them because they ended up not mattering.
- mc32 9y agoI'm willing to go along with that. I too would not be surprised if he favors Trump via omission rather than commission. Julian likely is severely allergic to establishment politicians because he rightfully sees them as two sides of the same coin who like Hillary see him as a US enemy, while Trump seems more pragmatic about it.
- yters 9y agoIsn't it most plausible Russia is in every party and branch as much as possible, so whoever wins they win? We need Russia out of our government all together and not make it a partisan issue.
- mc32 9y agoIf you want Russia to pull back, you have to pull back too (ala Bill Clinton detente) Pull back on the sanctions, pull back on hovering over and picking up pieces in their former sphere of influence (former central Asia soviet reps). We might be able to influence N Korea with these tactics, but Russia has a lot of natural resources, people and materiel. It's a diff game. You have had (some) people on the left defending Kim Jun-un's actions as predictable (he's being bullied, etc). Putin's are predictable too, given what he has to work with. I think we'd be better off reluctantly working with him (in the ME, for ex.) than blocking them every corner. It sets them back into a cold-war mentality. We (the world) need the biggest powers, US, CN, RU, to get along, if not be friends. We don't see eye to eye in many things (human rights wise, ex, pollution, ex) but we can work toward a more stable planet.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoHe doesn't know the source. The source claims not to be Russia, and Assange believes it because he's a useful idiot.
- wahern 9y agoAssange hardly seems like an idiot. Spiteful interloper who carefully chooses his words, relishing his part in the political upheaval of a nation-state which has effectively imprisoned him in a London embassy? Maybe.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoHow's that working out for him? Trump is no more in his court than Clinton was, Ecuador has cut off his Internet access, and he's squandered any support he had by helping elect an even bigger idiot.
- mc32 9y agoOn the other hand, he hasn't joked about extrajudicially "droning him". So there is that. On the other hand, most of DC saw Hillary as a war hawk.
- lern_too_spel 9y agoThe source of that purported joke is "sources in the State Department" that talked to TruePundit. If you believe TruePundit had sources in Clinton's State Department, you might believe that Seth Rich leaked the DNC emails to WikiLeaks after participating in child sex trafficking in the basement of a basement-less pizza parlor.
- mc32 9y agoYeah I dunno. TYT[1] (not a Trump mouthpiece) seem to agree her non denial as likely admission that it was said. "[Clinton] probably said it as a [frustrated] joke". [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ErH29hrpqvg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ErH29hrpqvg
- microwavecamera 9y agoPutin's goal is to do whatever benefits him. Sowing dissent and confusion in the US works to his benefit. I'm sure Russian intelligence had a hand in things, either directly or by proxy, but like any intelligence operation, creating distractions, promoting false leads and casting dispersion is part of the game. Putin was a KGB counter-intelligence officer. His administration is packed with ex KGB and FSB personnel. He knows what's he doing and Russia is playing our political divisions against us and manipulating us.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- int_19h 9y agoIt should be noted that the entirety of the material leaked by Assange would be consistent with "Russian agent" theory (including variations along the lines of him not being directly in service, but getting backing because of being useful, even if he has his own reasons). It might not be very obvious from inside US, but the whole mess with Iraq and Afghan wars, and especially everything that Wikileaks exposed about them, is one of the biggest providers of source material for Russian "whataboutism" (see also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_negroes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_negroes). In early 00s, it was mainly useful to justify the way Russia handled Chechnya. But from 2008 on, it became more and more important - South Ossetia, Crimea, Donbass, Syria. With that in mind, leaks about any American administration serve those goals. Bush was certainly fair game. As do any leaks that concern any Western countries, their allies, and affiliated countries. Which happens to be exactly what Wikileaks has been focusing on. Now, this doesn't mean that those leaks don't have any further value, in particular, to citizens of the affected countries. This part of it is where you generally see a lot of partisanship when judging said value.
- hackinthebochs 9y agoI don't get why people are so trustful of Assagne's assurances the source wasn't Russian. Unless he hacked it himself or was looking over the shoulder of the guy who hacked it, he simply cannot know who the ultimate source of the material is. The person he got it from may very well not have been Russian. But who did that person get it from? It's no different than a Tor exit node delivering information it receives: it simply isn't in a position to know the true origin.
- gamgeegogee 9y agoThe fact that Assange has come out very hard trying to imply it was Seth Rich and not Russians is itself the most suspicious thing. 1. He can't possibly know if Russia is the true source. 2. Seth Rich is a classic KGB style conspiracy theory with literally not one shred of evidence, at all. So he's doing two very odd things here that he's never done. He's saying Russia is NOT the source AND Seth Rich IS the source. It's typical for someone with good intentions to find themselves owned by a spy agency. Assange is most likely in so deep he can't fix it. It's a fact he's taken money from Russia and the theory of him being compromised by them goes back years before the election. He's the one that arranged for Snowden to go to Russia. So he's compromised and a tool now. It doesn't matter if he was once free or not at this point.
- hackinthebochs 9y agoI don't get why people are so trustful of Assagne's assurances the source wasn't Russian. Unless he hacked it himself or was looking over the shoulder of the guy who hacked it, he simply cannot know who the ultimate source of the material is. The person he got it from may very well not have been Russian. But who did that person get it from?