10 ms·
> The greatest hurdle for drivers is the time commitment to keeping their cars fully charged. For a large percentage of common use cases this is not an issue.
by danans 9y ago
> The greatest hurdle for drivers is the time commitment to keeping their cars fully charged.
For a large percentage of common use cases this is not an issue. EV drivers by and large do other valuable things while their vehicles charge, like work and sleep.
> Current electric cars need convenient locations built for charging ports.
This is only true for apartment dwellers (for now). People who live in houses typically charge at home.
> Designing and building enough of these recharging stations requires massive infrastructure development, which means the energy distribution and storage system is being rebuilt at tremendous cost to accommodate the need for continual local battery recharge
> Users would be able to drop off the spent electrolytes at gas stations, which would then be sent in bulk to solar farms, wind turbine installations or hydroelectric plants for reconstitution or re-charging into the viable electrolyte and reused many times.
How is this fueling and distribution system cheaper or more efficient than the grid plus a bunch of 240v/60a outlets, most of which are already available in home garages. If instant refueling is a really a dire need for someone, they can just get a plugin hybrid (i.e. Chevy Volt) and no new infrastructure needed at all.
Edit: removed snarky words
- kuschku 9y ago> This is only true for apartment dwellers (for now). People who live in houses typically charge at home. In Germany, over 65% of people rent. So, the supermajority would be affected by this. EDIT: I meant "live in rented apartments". "Miete" implies renting an apartment here, usually.
- chrisseaton 9y agoWhy can't you charge in a house that you rent instead of own?
- mikestew 9y agoBecause the landlord might take issue with you installing a 220V charger in the house. Why, I would have no idea, since it would seem to add (a minuscule) value to the house. Wait a minute, it's Germany, don't y'all already have 220V/240V/whatever it takes? In which case, yeah, I guess you could just plug into an outlet and charge just as quickly as I do in my American garage with its special charger because our outlets are 110V.
- chrisseaton 9y agoI heard that's why Americans don't have electric kettles either - takes too long to boil on 110 v.
- 35bge57dtjku 9y agoIt takes 2 1/2 minutes to microwave a coffee cup full of water to hotter than I need it.
- derefr 9y agoCanada has 110v and electric kettles. America apparently just doesn't care for tea (and/or have much of the subpopulations from areas of the world that got big into boiling their drinking water before chlorinated public water came about, and so who see drinking even clean unboiled tap water as gross.)
- kuschku 9y agoActually, in Europe drinking water is unchlorinated. Chlorinated water is something I'd consider as gross, by default.
- ucaetano 9y agoThat isn't true: http://www.lenntech.com/processes/disinfection/regulation-eu/eu-water-disinfection-regulation.htm http://www.lenntech.com/processes/disinfection/regulation-eu... While some countries moved away from permanent chlorination, it is still widely used, either as a permanent (all the way to the faucet) or punctual (just in the treatment facility) water disinfection solution. The UK, for example, uses permanent chlorination. So depending where you live, maybe its time to find all tap water gross.
- kuschku 9y agoOh, that's interesting. Everywhere I've been – be it Austria, Denmark, Germany, Netherlands – I’ve never seen chlorinated water.
- kuschku 9y agoSorry, 65% of Germans live in rented apartments was what I meant.
- oxryly1 9y agoIn my case there's no outlet in my carport. And many others in my building only have street parking.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 9y agoI don't get what you mean. If there's no off street parking then it doesn't matter if you are renting or owning you still have the same problem.
- concede_pluto 9y agoIf you buy an electric vehicle, you're committed to always having a private garage, which severely limits your rental options in the future.
- greglindahl 9y agoSome places already have on-street chargers, and who knows what the future will bring? My apartment complex has a shared charger in the garage, and new construction in my city is required to have that.
- neonhomer 9y ago> This is only true for apartment dwellers (for now). People who live in houses typically charge at home. What about people who only have street parking without a driveway or garage?
- mikestew 9y agoIn American English usage, the word "typically" indicates that there are exceptions such as those you point out.
- Others 9y agoIn American etiquette, not being rude and pedantic is encouraged ;)
- greglindahl 9y ago... there are chargers for on-street parking, they just aren't common. For example, they can be built into light poles.
- notlob 9y agoWhat does the typical circuit for a city street light pole look like, i.e., what voltage is it, what wire gauge, etc.?
- ridgeguy 9y agoAlthough quick fueling is a selling point, I think the real advantage lies in use of an existing distribution system for energy in liquid form. This would facilitate widespread adoption of electric vehicles without requiring new purpose-built grid infrastructure. If I understand correctly, this technology is a (perhaps better/more robust) flow battery into which one pumps fresh electrolyte after removing "discharged" electrolyte. We now pump and convey by ship, rail and truck, liquid fossil fuels. Fresh electrolyte would be handled likewise. The return loop for used electrolyte is already there. Gas trucks now return empty for refill. In many cases, an empty ship or train returns to a fuel source for refill. These could bring electrolyte back to recharging facilities. Whether these are powered by renewable or nuclear or other energy wouldn't impact the distribution system much. Repurposing the existing fuel distribution to handle electrolytes doesn't seem prohibitive. It's something I hadn't considered, as I'm not used to thinking of electrical energy as a liquid I could deliver in a truck.
- jcranmer 9y ago> We now pump and convey by ship, rail and truck, liquid fossil fuels. Fresh electrolyte would be handled likewise. A lot of refined petroleum is shipped by pipeline. If you live in, say, the DC area, then your gasoline is coming from crude oil refined somewhere in Texas or Louisiana and shipped by pipeline to a distribution terminal. The refuelling trucks are only traveling from the distribution terminal, maybe 20 miles or so, not all the way to the refineries. According to <https://www.rita.dot.gov/bts/sites/rita.dot.gov.bts/files/publications/national_transportation_statistics/html/table_01_61.html> https://www.rita.dot.gov/bts/sites/rita.dot.gov.bts/files/pu..., pipelines carried 63.3% of refined petroleum products in 2009, and an even higher share of (79.8%) of raw crude oil. The numbers for crude are likely to be rather different for today thanks to the Bakken oil field (which happens to not be in a conducive place for the existing pipeline network), but I don't think that refined petroleum products are likely to be very different.
- danans 9y agoYou would have to build a new parallel distribution infrastructure, even if it utilized the same kind of components. New tanker trucks and pipelines for moving the product. Local fueling stations would need new underground tanks to store it. New pumps at the fueling station. Charging EVs via the grid involves minimal new distribution infrastructure. The grid already supports high loads like the kind that EVs impose and the nightly pattern of EV charging actually complement wind as an energy source. Flow batteries seem much more promising as utility scale storage for intermittent renewables.
- DamnInteresting 9y agoYeah, I bought a Chevy Bolt EV a few months back, and I treat it like my phone. I plug it in every night, and it's typically topped off by morning.
- Baeocystin 9y agoHey, how do you like the Bolt? I've been waffling about getting a Leaf for a while, but the Bolt's range sure seems attractive. How is it to drive?
- DamnInteresting 9y agoIt is great fun to drive. It's quick, and it feels even quicker than it really is owing to the instant response (no downshifting required), and silent acceleration. The heavy raft of batteries on the bottom gives it a low center of gravity, so it doesn't lean back much when you punch it. I also really enjoy the one-pedal-driving enabled by the "L" mode, which tells the car not to mimic an automatic, rather to use regenerative braking as aggressively as possible. I can drive all over town without touching the brakes. I haven't driven a Leaf myself, but I know people who have, and they much prefer the Bolt EV. I'll try to keep an eye on this thread if you have any specific questions.
- Baeocystin 9y agoThanks for the response. I've done a little more searching about, and the general opinion is that the Bolt is genuinely a better vehicle. That L mode sounds interesting. Are there any negatives you've come across?
- DamnInteresting 9y agoThere are a few downsides, mostly minor. For one, it doesn't come with a spare tire or jack (probably to save weight and improve range). It uses special tires to reduce the likelihood of a flat, but a blowout would require roadside assistance unless you add a jack and tire. For another, it's small inside, especially horizontally. It's not a big deal for me, but two large people side by side would be quite close together. The gauge cluster screen is a bit boring, it seems like it could be more attractive and interesting. But that's a minor quibble. Nothing else comes to mind, it's mostly been an excellent car so far.
- outworlder 9y ago> This is only true for apartment dwellers (for now). People who live in houses typically charge at home. Having stations built in convenient locations means that you can greatly extend your effective range. If I have a car that can drive for 80 miles, then I can only go 40 miles away before reaching bingo 'fuel'. Often, one will leave some buffer. Doesn't matter if you are picking up someone at the airport, grocery shopping or working. If charging stations are everywhere, then you would only need to worry about how far you can go. If said stations were also wireless, then one might not have to stop to charge at all.
- concede_pluto 9y agoThat future isn't here. At my current job, people are encouraged to go out and move their cars when charged, and still they can't be confident there will be a charger available every day. My previous job had none. If I could drive down the street and replace my electrolyte, neither changing jobs nor moving would suddenly make an electric vehicle unusable.
- greglindahl 9y agoYour current job problem is an interface problem. If you could arrive at work and plug in, with a guarantee that you'd get X charge by the end of the workday, that'd give you the confidence that you're lacking with most of today's charging systems. It's not hard to imagine how to do that: a smart system with reservations is not rocket science. Even better: if you have a big battery and don't need to charge every day, your car can help smooth variations in wind and solar power. If you want to protect yourself against both a job change and a home change, well, sure, a new job and a new apartment might not offer charging.
- ams6110 9y agoIt's just ridiculous to claim that recharging time is not a huge downside to EVs. If I have to drive more than the range of the car, I've now added hours to my trip instead of the minutes a liquid fuel refill takes. I often drive more than the range of a Tesla and certainly more than the range of something like a Leaf, which is why I have not considered buying one.
- greglindahl 9y agoIt takes hours to supercharge a Tesla?
- Spivak 9y agoAccording to Tesla it takes 1h15m for a full charge. If you don't happen to be around a supercharger and have to use a 240v outlet you're looking at 9.5h for a full charge.
- sowbug 9y agoWhat's especially cool about this is that most homes in the U.S. have a 240v outlet in or near the garage, meaning it's easy to recharge while visiting friends or family.
- azinman2 9y agoIs that really true? What for? I'm remodeling a house and putting in 240 just for the dryer an an unusual French range. Why would I need that in the garage? I certainly won't have that long an extension cord.
- newman8r 9y agoyou richer. us poor folk quite often put our laundry machines in the garage.
- 9y ago
- vacri 9y ago> People who live in houses typically charge at home. There are plenty of houses out there that use on-street parking.
- friendzis 9y ago> How is this fueling and distribution system cheaper or more efficient than the grid plus a bunch of 240v/60a outlets, most of which are already available in home garages. If instant refueling is a really a dire need for someone, they can just get a plugin hybrid (i.e. Chevy Volt) and no new infrastructure needed at all. Simple. The grid - electricity transmission and especially distribution networks (depends on how they are classified at your location) are most likely not designed to sustain the load. There are multiple problems here. First, not sure about US, though, distribution networks are usually overcommited by some factor (sometimes hundreds of percent). It works only because urban end users in a community do not utilise their line to the max all at once. Plug in whole suburban neighbourhood full of EVs for a night and quite likely will see power outages. Oops. Second, the problem is not as simple as "more copper = more load". Mainly the grid must have some level of redundancy - single home unit is reached from power plant via multiple paths, so fault of a single line disrupts minimal portion of the grid. Next, there is balancing (or whatever that is called. Balancing is having redundant coal/nuclear reactor to balance quick and unpredictable output variations from e.g. solar/wind, variations in demand quicker than output increase rate of a plant, etc.) - grid designers/operators must ensure that energy flows more or less equally through out the grid. Similar problem to wireless mesh networking - one needs smart routing to avoid bottlenecking at single link. Some of electric grid and computer network problems are almost the same. While users can say, well 10 years ago we had single desktop at each home unit and were happy. Now we have the problem that each home member has laptop, smartphone, tablet. We will install wireless routers and ISP can "ADD MOAR FIBER!!1". Not that simple, right?
- neltnerb 9y agoIt's nice to be able to recharge the fluid slowly and steadily vs needing to build the infrastructure to provide high current capacity. I'm kind of surprised that, if they're already assuming they can build the battery and make it small enough to fit in a car, that they don't suggest that they will be able to build a charging station for pretty cheap too. But transporting the liquid maybe is just even cheaper still, if they assume more of a distribution center with the charging equipment and higher capacity electricity access.
- greglindahl 9y agoMy apartment complex has chargers available, because there are a lot of electric cars in the local area. New apartment complexes are required to install chargers. It's not rocket science.