3 ms·
Quick summary: It's a flow battery[1]. Replace the liquid with fresh liquid and you are recharged. This one is different by not having a membrane. [1] https:/
by ars 9y ago
Quick summary: It's a flow battery[1]. Replace the liquid with fresh liquid and you are recharged.
This one is different by not having a membrane.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery
- tedsanders 9y agoQuestion: Why is this a flow battery and not a fuel cell? My impression is that the difference between flow batteries and fuel cells is that flow batteries are closed systems whereas fuel cells are open systems. Since this can be refueled, it sounds like an open system. Edit: Your linked Wikipedia article answers my question. "A flow battery is a rechargeable fuel cell." I guess the distinction is not closed vs open, but rechargeable vs unspecified.
- ars 9y agoI think a fuel cell is distinct by having the oxidizer be from the environment, and not within it. A flow battery is completely self contained. Getting your oxidizer from the environment obviously helps with weight, but it comes with its own set of problems since it's hard to control purity. The wikipedia definition kinda touches on this. Since everything is contained in the battery you can recharge it with just electricity. In contrast a fuel cell will emit the waste (water usually), so you no longer have the raw material to recharge it anymore. (Although obviously you can just make more by collecting it from the environment - think emit the water, then electrolyze other water to recharge the battery.)
- ChuckMcM 9y agoYes, and this bit might make you pause : "'We are at a stage in the company’s growth that we are looking for additional financing to build large-scale prototypes and subsequently manufacturing partners,' Cushman said." The whole "Breakthrough! Just add money!" thing is really tiresome not because it would be wonderful if it was as simple as just adding money, but because so very many people have abused it when they really had no idea at all about what the issues were with their technology. I like the concept of flow batteries, and have read a number of interesting papers over the years on them. They solve a number of problems if you can get them to work and the instant recharge is perhaps the best one. That said, a very good flow battery demonstrator project would be a set of solar panels (cheap these days), continually pumping electrolyte from a reservoir and 'charging' it (inverting its oxidation reaction). Coupled to a flow battery and a constant load. If you can't build that, and show that by putting 'nX' load of solar cells in the loop, and continually run the base load 24x7, then you've got the basis for an actual breakthrough. Even doing it for a small "meaningless" load like 50 watts (1.2kWh / day), you will have demonstrated not only that your battery works but that it can be combined in a system that currently requires "previous generation" batteries. And from that demonstrator you can make educated guesses about how much maintenance would be required for a larger scale system, how well the system performs 24x7, how to maintain it while it is operating, Etc. Then you can say, for $X we estimate we could run a typical house off grid. For $Y we estimate we could provide Z MWhr of base load. If you can't build the 50W system though, it is unlikely you can build any system yet.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt sounds like their 0.5 watt system at least works: https://whova.com/embedded/subsession/icpma_201705/177114/177119/ https://whova.com/embedded/subsession/icpma_201705/177114/17...
- ChuckMcM 9y agoPerfect, Vanadium is only $28/kg[1]. 500W of solar cells is less than $1,000 these days. Saltwater and Methanol are also pretty cheap. Well you can charge it, so if the charge rate is .1C you hook your solar panels to 1000 cells that are charging ("charging" cells) and their electrolyte is then pumped into the 100 "load" cells for delivering load. But that only keeps you even, so 10,000 cells charging and filling the reservoir while 100 cells providing load. Damn the laws of thermodynamics! Still I would love to read how Dr. Cushman sees it working out. [1] http://www.reuters.com/article/metals-vanadium-prices-idUSL4N1II3WY http://www.reuters.com/article/metals-vanadium-prices-idUSL4...
- DrScump 9y agoI remember this being envisioned in Popular Science magazine in the 1970s. The front cover image depicted a "fueling station" with fresh electrolyte pumped in through one hose while depleted electrolyte was pumped out through another.