3 ms·

This is not offering your house for it. That would be if google was actually hosting their site on its servers. In this case it's a domain pointing to their con

This is not offering your house for it. That would be if google was actually hosting their site on its servers. In this case it's a domain pointing to their content. As a registrar Google is serving the public and I doubt you can deny someone this service in a moral sense. Can a doctor deny to treat them if they end up in his office for serious injuries? What if all registrars deny them, is it morally right to effectively erase them from the internet for simply expressing their thoughts?

_jgvg 9y ago
> As a registrar Google is serving the public and I doubt you can deny someone this service in a moral sense. Actually, you can deny anyone except protected categories. > Can a doctor deny to treat them if they end up in his office for serious injuries? Yes, the doctor chooses not to treat patients with the illness or injury you suffer from. > What if all registrars deny them, is it morally right to effectively erase them from the internet for simply expressing their thoughts? Nobody is being erased from the internet. Also, they can open their own registrar system. So no, there's no obligation for Google, or any other registrar, to host their information.
- kareldonk 9y ago
  I hope you dont end up in an emergency hospital with the only doctor who can help you refusing to do so because he doesnt like you for some reason.
  - ucaetano 9y ago
    So do I, but that doesn't change reality. And a hospital might fire a doctor for refusing to treat you.
    - kareldonk 9y ago
      "Having made that decision we now need to talk about why it is so dangerous. I’ll be posting something on our blog later today. Literally, I woke up in a bad mood and decided someone shouldn’t be allowed on the Internet. No one should have that power." http://gizmodo.com/cloudflare-ceo-on-terminating-service-to-neo-nazi-site-1797915295 http://gizmodo.com/cloudflare-ceo-on-terminating-service-to-...

_jgvg 9y ago

> As a registrar Google is serving the public and I doubt you can deny someone this service in a moral sense. Actually, you can deny anyone except protected categories. > Can a doctor deny to treat them if they end up in his office for serious injuries? Yes, the doctor chooses not to treat patients with the illness or injury you suffer from. > What if all registrars deny them, is it morally right to effectively erase them from the internet for simply expressing their thoughts? Nobody is being erased from the internet. Also, they can open their own registrar system. So no, there's no obligation for Google, or any other registrar, to host their information.

kareldonk 9y ago
I hope you dont end up in an emergency hospital with the only doctor who can help you refusing to do so because he doesnt like you for some reason.
- ucaetano 9y ago
  So do I, but that doesn't change reality. And a hospital might fire a doctor for refusing to treat you.
  - kareldonk 9y ago
    "Having made that decision we now need to talk about why it is so dangerous. I’ll be posting something on our blog later today. Literally, I woke up in a bad mood and decided someone shouldn’t be allowed on the Internet. No one should have that power." http://gizmodo.com/cloudflare-ceo-on-terminating-service-to-neo-nazi-site-1797915295 http://gizmodo.com/cloudflare-ceo-on-terminating-service-to-...