3 ms·
Is it? Does putting something in writing automatically force you to do it, legally, if that writing is not a contract? Perhaps the mistake here is Benchmark's.
by mike_hearn 9y ago
Is it? Does putting something in writing automatically force you to do it, legally, if that writing is not a contract?
Perhaps the mistake here is Benchmark's. If Kalanick agreed to do this in writing, and then didn't do it, that makes him look bad but it's unclear to me that Benchmark can do much about it. Maybe Travis has the last laugh.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Does putting something in writing automatically force you to do it, legally, if that writing is not a contract? It's unclear from the letter if this agreement was a contract or e.g. an email. If a contract, the answer is clear. If something less formal, note that American courts tend to treat written communications between sophisticated parties as legally binding, particularly if it occurs around negotiating a contract [1]. There's the further distinction that these are written communications between a CEO and his Board. At the very least, Kalanick made untrue statements to his investors. If he did it intentionally, it could constitute fraud. [1] https://www.law360.com/articles/950866/bank-bound-by-unsigned-lehman-deal-despite-dismissal https://www.law360.com/articles/950866/bank-bound-by-unsigne... Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This is not legal nor investment advice.
- tannhauser23 9y agoIf that was in a contract, Benchmark wouldn't have to sue for 'fraud' - they can sue to enforce the contractual agreement. Sounds like what they have on paper isn't as solid as they'd like you to believe.
- dcole2929 9y agoGenerally, yes it does require you to do so unless you also have it in writing that whatever document you just signed is not in fact binding. Even verbal agreements can be enforced as a legally binding contract so having a written document is a pretty high barrier to overcome legally speaking.
- Powerofmene 9y agoIn the US, generally it is binding. Communications and agreements between parties are binding particularly if TK received something in return for said promises. Even verbal agreements are binding in the US especially when dealing with parties such as these. If TK hopes to have any credibility moving forward, with the Board or in the courts, it would be in his best interest to keep commitments or he will be stuck in the "did you lie then or is this version a lie" mess. If he wants to argue that he made the agreement under duress then he can argue that in court and the court may find the the agreement is not enforceable but duress can be a steep hill to climb without physical, or threat of physical, harm.