7 ms·
FWIW, my assessment is that this paper passes the Aaronson test, as well as my own personal bogometer. If I were a betting man, my money would be on "the proof
by lisper 9y ago
FWIW, my assessment is that this paper passes the Aaronson test, as well as my own personal bogometer. If I were a betting man, my money would be on "the proof will turn out to have a flaw, but it will be hard to find the flaw, and the finding of the flaw will be interesting in and of itself, and possibly even advance the field."
- wolfgke 9y agoAfter overlooking the paper and applying Scott Aaronson's criterion I bet against you and bet: - The proof will turn out to have a flaw - The flaw will not be that hard to find (though probably not completely trivial; but rather of the kind: it takes much time to go to the details of the proof arguments) - The flaw will not be interesting in itself and will not advance the field
- kittysasa 9y agoSeconded. The flaws in these papers are not hard to find. They usually amount to misunderstanding of definitions or the results they cite.
- westoncb 9y agoUnlikely considering the author of the paper. I'm basing that on other comments on the thread which this section seems to be missing, e.g.: > ...this guy is an established senior researcher at the University of Bonn
- hnaccy 9y agoEven experienced people can make "silly" mistakes. https://arxiv.org/abs/1612.04208v1 https://arxiv.org/abs/1612.04208v1
- westoncb 9y agoThey can—but that doesn't mean we should assume it's a silly mistake (as opposed to a deep one) without more information than that he's an accomplished researcher.
- KGIII 9y agoTo add to this, I have a Ph.D. in applied mathematics. I am also an accomplished researcher, albeit retired. I make more mistakes by 09:00 than most people will make all day. Hell, my girlfriend would suggest that we can move that time forward a couple of hours.
- jl6 9y agoAnd even though it may be hard to find the flaw, it will be easy to verify that it is a flaw.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- GenerocUsername 9y agoIf only we had a way to make finding the flaw as easy as verifying the flaw
- Filligree 9y agoI don't think it would be possible to make finding it as easy as verifying it, but how can we prove that?