4 ms·
consider if Starbucks customers visited the store only once every 10 years to buy a single cup of coffee? How soon do you imagine they’d go out of business? Im
by jodrellblank 9y ago
consider if Starbucks customers visited the store only once every 10 years to buy a single cup of coffee? How soon do you imagine they’d go out of business?
Imagine if one cup of coffee "worked" for ten years, how much you'd care if Starbucks went out of business?
Consumers aren't there as a substitute welfare state to provide eternal employment for hungry programmers.
Nobody pays a subscription to an author instead of buying a book. "Oh they rewrote chapter one?"
It's just a case of holding information hostage in the cloud because you can.
[Stallmanning intensifies]
- wccrawford 9y agoIndeed. I just unsubscribed from Adobe's online Photoshop offering because I don't use it enough to pay $10/mo every month. Instead, I went looking around and found a great alternative with a set price... And then I decided not to buy that until I actually needed it. Once I needed something for simple image work, I ended up downloading Krita for free and it works just fine. I may still buy the other software, but not until Krita can't do what I need. (To be fair, the other software looks amazing... But so is Photoshop, if you use it daily. Which I don't.)
- tapatio 9y agoYou are not the target market.
- jodrellblank 9y agoYou say that as if being the target is desirable.
- StavrosK 9y agoYeah, this is just a bunch of "why should I charge a little when I can charge a lot?". I don't know, people spent a bunch of man-years making my washing machine, but I don't pay a subscription on it. If the choice is between $120 up-front or $5 a month, maybe it's worth it (e.g. maybe paying $8/mo is better than paying however much for Photoshop+Lightroom), but I have a feeling that this developer is talking about $2 up-front or $5/mo.
- chrisaycock 9y ago> I don't know, people spent a bunch of man-years making my washing machine, but I don't pay a subscription on it. You pay a subscription for the detergent. Hardware is the washing machine; software is the detergent.
- jacquesm 9y agoDetergent is a consumable, and typically not made by the same company that made the washing machine. Nonsense analogy. Even without a washing machine you'd use soap.
- probablybroken 9y agoIn the case of a washing machine, they design the unit to stop functioning in the near future, sell you a limited warranty, and then frequently try to sell you an extended warranty. It's different, but yes, things are dressed up to extract the most they can from a customer.
- iamatworknow 9y ago>they design the unit to stop functioning in the near future I don't believe anything is "designed" to stop functioning. That's just a happy accident that results from cost cutting measures in the manufacturing process.
- probablybroken 9y agoOk, maybe it's arrived at via an evolutionary process then - with selection being provided by stakeholders. The outcome is however the same.
- nhtoe78hnt 9y agoAnd it doesn't work. I moved into a new house and the relatively new LG refrigerator stopped working 2 days later. The repair person said the compressor had died and it would cost $1,000 to fix. We opted to buy a new refrigerator and completely avoided anything made by LG. The other appliances in the house are LG, too. I believe the previous owners were in the house for ~5 years so I don't think any of the appliances are older than that. If any of them breaks in the next few years, they will be replaced with different brands.
- Analemma_ 9y ago> Consumers aren't there as a substitute welfare state to provide eternal employment for hungry programmers. The flip side to this argument is that programmers aren't obligated to continue fixing bugs and adding features to software forever if they aren't being paid. Software subscriptions are the only way I know of to align the incentives properly so that programmers will actually fix things instead of moving on to an entirely new piece of software that they can sell anew and leave the old one to rot, which is a real problem that has plagued small dev shops forever.
- ghaff 9y agoYes. Historically, it was very common for the stock response for bugs to be "It's fixed in the next version." There was a very strong incentive for companies to force buyers (especially those who weren't on maintenance contracts) to upgrade as frequently as possible. In part for supportability reasons, vendors still cut off support for old versions at some point, but from a revenue perspective, subscriptions get rid of much of the reason to force upgrades.
- pjmlp 9y agoBack in the day fixing bugs meant buying the next version, with a possible discount for being an existing customer.
- Clubber 9y agoSoftware companies used to survive through maintenance contracts for enterprise software and upgrades for consumer software. With the Apple App Store model, all upgrades are required to be free. This of course took a huge chunk of revenue away from software shops. >It's just a case of holding information hostage in the cloud because you can. Or because they have to. >Consumers aren't there as a substitute welfare state to provide eternal employment for hungry programmers. Software is expensive. Developers are expensive. I much prefer the upgrade model to the subscription model, but the marketplace in a round about way, decided it would rather pay eternally rather than one version at a time. Photoshop use to cost around $800 for a license, now it's $20 a month. That works out to 3.33 years until you pay as much as an outright license. I'm fairly certain that the Photoshop upgrade schedule was shorter than 3.33 years, so in the end, you end up paying less, assuming you constantly upgraded. *The upgrade prices was usually cheaper than the original full license, but I don't know how that works out long term with the subscription model.
- detaro 9y agoWith Adobe CC it really depends on what combination of software you had and how often you updated. AFAIK, if you bought only one or two applications and skipped every other version, CC is basically always more expensive. (update prices were a lot lower than full, and upgraded the second-to-last version as well (and in the beginning, even more)) If you bought the larger bundles and/or want to keep it up-to-date all the time, CC pricing generally is similar or cheaper.
- nhtoe78hnt 9y ago> With the Apple App Store model, all upgrades are required to be free. That's not true at all. You can, at any time, take your FooSoftware 1.x off the store and make a new product called FooSoftware 2.x and charge the new price for it.
- Clubber 9y agoYes, but that's a workaround. All the effort you put into marketing an app called "FooTime" is now devalued because the actual app name is now "FooTime2" Furthermore, if you remove "FooTime" from the store, there are now a bunch of dead links.
- ghaff 9y agoSubscription is a reasonable model for software that's part of your core workflows and that you probably want to be current on in any case. If you're a graphic professional, Adobe Creative Cloud is mostly a reasonable deal. If you dust off Photoshop Elements a few times a year? Not so much. Similarly, with a few exceptions, subscribing to something like a game doesn't really make sense for a buyer. It would be like subscribing to a movie or, as you say, a book. I'm probably going to play it once (or even a few times) and it's going to sit unused. The flip side of the author's premise is that subscribing to something, even for a very low price, is generally a much higher bar to me than taking a flyer on something at $5-$10. Yes, there's some combination of subscription price vs. purchase price where I'd view the subscription as lower risk but I tend to be pretty conservative about opening up monthly money leaks.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoImagine if one cup of coffee "worked" for ten years, how much you'd care if Starbucks went out of business? Excluding the most robust embedded systems on spacecraft and nuclear submarines, I don't know any software especially consumer software that would last 10 years without revision. Maybe a better analogy is having an unlimited refill.
- kgwgk 9y agoI use software I bought 10 years ago. It works as well as it did in 2006. (Edit: to be fair, I’ve checked and while I bought it in 2007 I paid for maintenance for a while and I upgraded the software in 2010. Anyway, that’s over 7 years ago.)