3 ms·
> As did Communism, and we fought a Cold War over that. You know this is a false equivalence - they're not even remotely comparable. > a communist is currentl
by zimpenfish 9y ago
> As did Communism, and we fought a Cold War over that.
You know this is a false equivalence - they're not even remotely comparable.
> a communist is currently threatening to nuke the United States [...] has to be worse than running over a single person
Again with the false equivalences.
Also I don't think Kim Jong-Un is a Communist - they have collective farms, sure, but the country is much more a dictatorship than anything.
- Turing_Machine 9y ago> You know this is a false equivalence - they're not even remotely comparable. "False equivalence" how? Communists have murdered way more people than the Nazis ever did. > Also I don't think Kim Jong-Un is a Communist - they have collective farms, sure, but the country is much more a dictatorship than anything. Can you give me an example of a Communist country that isn't a dictatorship? The "But that wasn't real communism!" argument doesn't fly any more.
- true_religion 9y agoHow about china?
- Turing_Machine 9y agoMao wasn't a dictator? China has certainly made some significant steps away from dictatorship, though it's still damned authoritarian. It's also made significant steps away from communism (I mean, it has billionaires and everything). That's not a coincidence.
- dismantlethesun 9y agoChina is a communist autocracy where the leadership is a ruling counsel. It has divisions of power, and peaceful transitions of power. It's not a dictatorship characterized of a single leader ruling by force, with no stable transitions of power. As an aside, North Korea is a stable hereditary monarchy, and not a dictatorship. Neither him nor his father took power via force. Now that doesn't make them "good people". Mary Queen of Scots, and King John of England, were legitimate monarchs and terrible leaders.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> "False equivalence" how? Communists have murdered way more people than the Nazis ever did. Has there been a world war against the communists? Not that I am aware - your comparison of WW2 and the Cold War is false although I appreciate that you're only doing it to try and force an argument to the extremes. (You also might want to reflect on why you're this eager to minimise the crimes of Nazism.) > Can you give me an example of a Communist country that isn't a dictatorship? I don't need to - it's for you to show that Kim Jong-Un is a Communist and a handful of collective farms doesn't really get you there.
- merpnderp 9y agoIf you're going to categorize him, wouldn't he fall into the "People who've controlled countries and called themselves Communist, but who I don't think should represent Communists even though every person who's controlled a country and called themselves Communist was roughly like him?"
- Turing_Machine 9y ago> Has there been a world war against the communists? Yes. It ran for 70 years, with a truce during WWII. It was called the Cold War. It was fought in Korea, Vietnam, and many other countries. > why you're this eager to minimise the crimes of Nazism. I'm not eager to "minimise" anything. Nazis were horrible, but Communists killed more people, and that is just a fact. Why are you so eager to defend Communism? > it's for you to show that Kim Jong-Un is a Communist Umm... no, it isn't up to me to prove something that's been common knowledge since the 1950s, namely that North Korea is a Communist regime.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> no, it isn't up to me to prove something that's been common knowledge since the 1950s, namely that North Korea is a Communist regime. The DPRK was notionally Communist in the Leninist mold originally, but it was progressively recast into what its own propaganda describes as an alternative Socialism/Communism, but which expressly rejects Marxist materialism and the central role of economic relations with a central role of the individual and the single great leader. In many ways, it's more Fascist than Communist in substance (the highly centralized ideology of Juche bearing an analogous relation to the heirarchical Fuhrerprinzip as absolute monarchy does to feudalism.)