8 ms·
The AMD Radeon RX Vega 64 and RX Vega 56 Review: Vega Burning Bright
- coldcode 9y agoI wonder which model Apple will use in the iMac Pro.
- johnbehnke 9y agoI think Apple says 11 TFLOPS Single Precision and 22 TFLOPS Half-Precision, which puts the GPU at a Vega 56 I think? I don't think Apple has said how many possible GPU configurations there are, so you could be able to bump it to a 64.
- aseipp 9y agoYou're correct -- the specs page of the new iMac Pro is intentionally vague, but they do confirm this much at least: https://www.apple.com/imac-pro/specs/ https://www.apple.com/imac-pro/specs/ (The 64-variant will actually have 16GB HBM2, instead of 8, though.)
- iClaudiusX 9y agoThey're certainly not putting a 300 Watt gpu in an all-in-one enclosure. The only way that would work is if they used the closed loop cooler version, which is too bulky.
- Nursie 9y agoWell I bit the bullet and ordered one of these, at the "special introductory price" of only as much as an nVidia GTX 1080... The compute power seems pretty good from that review. YesI will be mining with it, so I'm hopeful of good results. I won't just be mining with it so I hope the game performance is worth it too!
- sgarman 9y agoDon't you have to carefully balance your mining speed and power consumption to be profitable. This seems like the worst card for that?
- Nursie 9y agoIf you're buying the card purely for mining, sure. If you want one anyway (i.e. you don't necessarily put the card cost in your sums), then the returns ought to be better than just the electricity costs. Especially if (say) mining to hold rather than sell straight off. There are also rumours of outrageous hash rates being possible - multiples of the current nVidia hash rates. But we'll see if they ever come to fruition.
- popol12 9y agoI really wonder if miners are going to buy the whole stock despite the game bundle program and the low power efficiency.
- jrs95 9y agoI doubt it, a 1070 is still better performance per dollar with the power consumption figured in
- nsxwolf 9y agoImpossible for me to get excited about this. What are these really going to sell for after the introductory stocks run out - $1000? Can't wait for this crypto madness to end.
- manaskarekar 9y agoI feel the other way, I want power users to buy these in bulk and dump them for cheap on ebay once they are no longer powerful enough for mining. Of course, many factors affect the final price on eBay and it's also about whether you need one today.
- nsxwolf 9y agoRight now it looks like the RX 480s and 580s get dumped for MSRP. After being abused like that.
- Nursie 9y agoThe "launch price" of $499 (or £450) for the basic model was only for a very limited number of cards with a few vendors AFAICT. The prices immediately jumped £100 when they had sold (under an hour). So the "MSRP" of $499 is effectively a lie at this point. What they will sell for when the crazy market forces we are experiencing right now kick in ... who knows. I suspect that depends on the hash rate people can force out of them. -- edit -- am actually tempted to leave the one I've ordered boxed for now, just to see what happens to the market over the next week or so.
- Agathos 9y agoIt runs hot and sucks a lot of power. Are miners going to be interested in that?
- Nursie 9y agoSomebody is, the UK vendors I've watched are basically sold out now...
- 013a 9y agoThis is unfortunately very disappointing. It practically can't even compete with a 1080 at the same price, and that card has been out for a year now. Really goes to show how far ahead Nvidia is.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoOnly on DirectX 11 games, which I could care less about. When I buy a video card, I expect it to last 2-3 years, which means that the most important benchmarks are the DX12 and Vulkan ones. Vega has a significant lead on those.
- Armisael16 9y agoIs there a serious reason to believe that DX12 games are going to start coming out? Wikipedia only has 21 games on its list: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_games_with_DirectX_12_support https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_games_with_DirectX_1...
- nsxwolf 9y agoCertainly eventually? DX11 can't be the end of the line.
- Armisael16 9y agoSorry - to expect that in the next year and a half or so (it doesn't matter if the game comes out two days before you replace your card). Also we may end up skipping to DX13.
- shmerl 9y agoNot so much DX12, but Vulkan ones yes. All major engines are now pushing Vulkan support out.
- overcast 9y agoIf you could care less, then you do care at least somewhat. There are still PLENTY of DX11 games to play, considering a lot of us have backlogs the size of Texas. DX12 titles are very limited right now.
- gcp 9y ago"Surprisingly, native FP16 operations are not currently exposed to OpenCL" Given that these cards have potential to crash the price/perf of current deep learning solutions, this is more than regrettable.
- mattnewton 9y agoIs openCL really competitive with Cuda now? I thought it was still basically nvidia or bust for the mainstream libraries because they all depend on cudnn
- gcp 9y agoThere are two questions there that are really completely distinct, even though you're conflating them: 1) OpenCL vs CUDA In reality, performance of these is identical: i.e. writing the same kernel in OpenCL versus writing the same kernel in CUDA (this is almost always possible unless hardware intrinsics are used) gives the same performance, with NVIDIA's current drivers. The odds are pretty great the same compiler is backing them both. 2) cuDNN vs MIOpen I haven't seen much benchmarks here. AMD has patches for most of the big frameworks but they're not upstream yet. The gist of the implementation seems state of the art, but no idea if the level of optimization is comparble. hipCaffe exists, but haven't seen any usable benchmarks so far. So for deep learning, the question isn't CUDA vs OpenCL. It's cuDNN vs the alternatives (MIOpen, Intel MKL/DAAL).
- hedgehog 9y agoMy company is also working on broader hardware support, we haven't tried any of the Vega cards yet but we do have early results for OpenCL on hardware in our lab: http://vertex.ai/blog/bringing-deep-learning-to-opencl http://vertex.ai/blog/bringing-deep-learning-to-opencl
- mattnewton 9y agoThanks for the detail and clearing the waters I muddied a bit. I guess I'm just surprised that people are doing deep learning on AMD gpus, not because of the performance of OpenCL, but because of the reliance on Cudnn in frameworks like tensorflow and torch made that seem not worth it in the past.
- yohann305 9y agotheir stock price jumped 8% today, i wonder if it's too late to get in ?
- yclept 9y agoAMD has been bouncing up and down between ~ 10-14 since ryzen hype
- slizard 9y agoRX Toaster, they need to pull some magic out of the chip with upcoming drivers, otherwise this won't be the big return everyone expected, I feel. I just hope the MI25 cards will be far cheaper than the $6k Tesla P100's and that the ROCm stack is good enough so for compute the architecture may still be a viable and very competitive option.
- microcolonel 9y agoOn the Open Source Linux OpenGL drivers (but not the proprietary ones), it is competitive with the 1080Ti at considerably lower MSRP and real retail price (once stocks recover from the most hyped GPU launch since... the Geforce 9800GTX? I don't even know). Power to performance ratios are also not well shown with the current shipping proprietary drivers; frankly I don't understand how AMD can't seem to get that team to deliver stellar day-one drivers for every launch, it is what it is I guess.
- slizard 9y ago> On the Open Source Linux OpenGL drivers (but not the proprietary ones), it is competitive with the 1080Ti at considerably lower MSRP Yaaay! Really, that's cool but it's a negligible fraction of the market. Unless Linux gaming becomes a market force overnight, it won't matter a lot, I think. > Power to performance ratios are also not well shown with the current shipping proprietary driver I doubt they can close the large power gap that the initial benchmarks show (compared to the 1080 and esp. 1070), but I'm hoping the power margin will get narrower and a bit of performance increase might compensate too. Indeed, I am dampening my expectations, I'm most hopeful that in the high-end GPGPU compute arena they might not be too late and will provide enough Perf/W/buck to gain traction.
- lhl 9y agoI ordered a $499 RX Vega 64 from Amazon at 9AM this morning, mainly to show support AMD's open source Linux GPU efforts [1] and since there should be pretty good compute potential, but I will have to admit to being fairly disappointed about the power consumption and general performance (only a 30% improvement vs 2yo Fiji w/ a shift from 28nm to 14nm and much touted architectural improvements [2] vs Nvidia's 70% uplift launched over a year ago). Interesting notes from the reviews - HBCC is not enabled by default but doesn't give much of a performance boost anyway [3]. According to Computerbase [4] (DE) primitive shaders are still inactive: https://www.computerbase.de/2017-08/radeon-rx-vega-64-56-test/ https://www.computerbase.de/2017-08/radeon-rx-vega-64-56-tes... (RTG engineer discussing that it should be automatically used in the future [5]) One interesting note is that while it looks like initial supplies have all sold out, early testing shows that OOTB Vega is pretty awful for mining right now. [6] Vega 64 is clocking at about 30MH/s at about 300W - a flash-BIOS'd RX 470 can get 28-30MH/s at ~150W. [1] https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=rx-vega-linux1&num=1 https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=rx-vega-... [2] http://www.pcgamer.com/the-amd-radeon-rx-vega-56-and-vega-64-review/ http://www.pcgamer.com/the-amd-radeon-rx-vega-56-and-vega-64... [3] http://www.guru3d.com/articles_pages/amd_radeon_rx_vega_56_8gb_review,31.html http://www.guru3d.com/articles_pages/amd_radeon_rx_vega_56_8... [4] https://www.computerbase.de/2017-08/radeon-rx-vega-64-56-test/ https://www.computerbase.de/2017-08/radeon-rx-vega-64-56-tes... [5] https://mobile.twitter.com/ryszu/status/896304786307469313 https://mobile.twitter.com/ryszu/status/896304786307469313 [6] https://nl.hardware.info/reviews/7517/23/amd-radeon-rx-vega-56--64-review-minder-euros-meer-watts-testresultaten-amd-radeon-rx-vega-voor-coin-mining https://nl.hardware.info/reviews/7517/23/amd-radeon-rx-vega-...
- Nursie 9y agoAnd a non-flashed 1070 can get around 30 at 120W(ish)... I guess the miners are hoping that a driver update will unleash the rumoured 70+MH/s. If it dosn't materialise I can imagine these being sold on fairly quickly, with that power consumption.
- ihsw2 9y agoI wouldn't be surprised if the performance is artificially hindered until later driver updates, to prevent them from being gobbled up by miners.
- JohnTHaller 9y ago"Relative to the GeForce GTX 1080, we’ve seen power measurements at the wall anywhere between 110W and 150W higher than the GeForce GTX 1080, all for the same performance." The Vega 64 has similar performance to the GTX 1080 for a similar price (if not for the fact that the new Radeons will never be in stock due to mining), but with much higher power consumption.
- shmerl 9y agoWhy are they so power hungry? Vega looks very promising for Linux gaming, but that power consumption is just way overboard.
- zanny 9y agoIt is a trend that AMD overvolts their cards to push their clocks to compete with Nvidia. Undervolted every GCN generation comes in line with Nvidia in performance per watt, the problem is your actual performance is too low to be impressive then. In the end, the numbers win - so if you are at a slight disadvantage (and generally AMD makes one series of dies, and sells them to both the consumer and enterprise segments, whereas Nvidia will at the hardware level disable features of dies when going into gaming cards to eek more efficiency out of them) then cranking up the power draw to reach performance parity almost surely sells more units than being just as efficient but performing worse per die area (because wafers are near fixed cost).
- phkahler 9y agoWhere is Quantum [1] and the EHP[2]? Since we have Epyc with 4 die, and Thread Ripper with 2 die and 2 place holders, it's time for AMD to make a multi-chip module with Ryzen, Vega, and 2 stacks of HBM2 memory. That could be packaged into an awesome SFF PC much like their old Quantum concept. [1] http://wccftech.com/amd-project-quantum-not-dead-zen-cpu-vega-gpu/ http://wccftech.com/amd-project-quantum-not-dead-zen-cpu-veg... [2] http://wccftech.com/amd-exascale-heterogeneous-processor-ehp-apu-32-zen-cores-hbm2/ http://wccftech.com/amd-exascale-heterogeneous-processor-ehp... And please don't illuminate it with plain LED light, use laser diodes so we get that ethereal look of the interference pattern ;-)
- Matthias247 9y agoDoes anyone else also think the bundles are mostly a bad deal for the customers, and maybe only a good one for AMD? First of all the monitor. Chances that I need one are fairly small. And if yes, why would I want exactly that one? I personally think the resolution (and especially pixel density) is below what I would want now, especially with so much GPU power available. A 4k screen with Freesync would be more attractive. Then the CPU/board. Chances are a little higher that one could use that, but I guess even less than 40% of buyers would require a CPU and board. If we restrict it to Ryzen 1700 options the number would be even less, since a 1600X might be the more interesting option for many gamers. And of course some may also prefer Intel. If we treat the CPU/board part as the main benefit of the bundle it's also still mostly a zero-sum game, you pay 100$ extra to get a 100$ discount. I could most likely get a better overall deal when I buy both GPU and CPU seperatly in shops where each has the best price. When we finally factor the games in it might be a small benefit for a small number of buyers. However their value is really small, since Prey is already some days old and one can get it discounted. If the demand for the bundles is as low as I think and AMD really wants to sell most of the cards in bundled form (predicted by anandtech), then the overall prices will mostly trend towards the bundle prices for all cards due to availability.
- benchaney 9y agoThe reason for the bundles is that they are trying to prevent purchases by miners. I do agree that they aren't a perfect solution