9 ms·
Rich more likely to walk away from mortgage
- TylerJewell 16y agoBoth my girlfriend and I have been pursuing strategic defaults on our primary residences in the state of California. Her property is underwater by 300K. Mine is about 250K. Neither of us are wealthy, but the financial upside of pursuing this route is very compelling. In California, if the loan on the home is a purchase money loan, which is the one used to purchase the home, and not refinanced, then in a foreclosure situation, the banks are not in a position to pursue you for a personal deficiency. In other words, they cannot sue you for the loss on the home. We had our lawyers check this out and it's due to laws dating back to the Depression era. At the time that a house is sold, there are three parties agreeing to the price: the buyer, the appraiser, and the mortgage lender. So if a home goes down in value, all parties share the risk. It's no different than a VC investing in a small business. If the business fails, the VC cannot sue the managers of the business to get their money back. The same holds true with foreclosures in California. In the depression, this same situation happened, property values fell, people lost their jobs and were sued by the banks to pay them back. Bad stuff. We are both pursuing short sales of our homes, but are perfectly OK with a foreclosure. In both situations, our credit ratings will take a huge hit, but they recover in 7 years for a foreclosure, and in 2 years if it's a short sale. So we asked ourselves, is our credit score worth 300K? And with some simple financial modeling, we figured that it was about 10 years for the property values to break even. And the trade off was simple. The short sale does turn into cancelled debt, though, and the IRS will get a 1099-C. Cancelled debt counts as income, which makes it taxable. Except the US govt passed the 2007 mortgage debt relief act, which makes cancelled debt from a mortgage tied to your primary residence an exception. You do not have to pay income tax on it. This is valid through the 2012 calendar year. At the state tax level, if the home has cancelled debt, it's still seen as a loss sales against the orginal value of the home. And losses are not taxable. So this is a great situation financially - no liability to the mortgage company, no federal or state tax. Really bad credit for a couple years :(. But as a question of opportunity cost, this seemed to make the most sense. In order to pursue this, both of us had to stop making all payments on the mortgages. We both got harrassing debt collection calls for awhile, but once you get into the foreclosure process, they eventually die down. We each will get 6-12 months of living in our homes for free, so in some ways that is a loss recovery. Hope this helps some of you...
- jdminhbg 16y ago"Her property is underwater by 300K. Mine is about 250K. Neither of us are wealthy..." I realize that "wealthy" is a hopelessly vague relative term, but unless your houses are literally worth $0 now to put you $550K underwater, most people would consider you wealthy to have bought them in the first place.
- jakevoytko 16y agoChris Rock has some good input on the subject: "Shaq is rich. The white man who signs his check is wealthy." If you're rich, you can buy an expensive house. If you're wealthy, you can forget exactly how many expensive houses you have.
- TylerJewell 16y agoHello, jdminhbg. It's an interesting point that you make, but here is the real situation with my girlfriend. Do you still think that she is considered wealthy? - She has been employed as a licensed clinical social worker for 11 years with a county in california. - She owned a condo for 3 years, sold it, made 100K profit. - She used that 100K as a down payment on her current home. - She bought the home for 500K, 400K 30 yr fixed mortgage. - She bought the home 6 years ago. - Today, she owes $370K, and the BPO of the home is 170K. This is commensurate with other homes in the area. - She has 30K in the bank and a pension plan with the state of California. She is still employed with the county, but they are pursuing layoffs in social services. Her job is at risk. Technically, she is insolvent, as the 300K owed is greater than the 30K she has in the bank. Her retirement pension doesn't count towards solvency. So a set of circumstances where she used the profits from one investment, and placed all of those profits in another investment to buy a nicer home for herself has turned sour. Her salary let her afford the 400K mortgage, but she wasn't able to save or invest in other items. She didn't have tremendous wealth, but she did have skills and a job that would allow her to continue payments against a loan, at the cost of not being able to afford any other investments. When this is all done, she'll have 40K in the bank from saved mortgage payments, a pension, her job (hopefully), and bad credit.
- 16y ago
- RiderOfGiraffes 16y agoHere are some earlier submissions on this and similar topics: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1491252 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1491252 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1175576 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1175576 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1011716 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1011716 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=726110 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=726110 <- This has lots of comments
- motters 16y agoIt makes sense if you took out an overblown mortgage and are in a big negative equity situation. If that's the case then getting rid of the property as soon as possible is really just about cutting your losses to the minimum.
- bsnss-mn-cdr 16y agoQuote of the day: "The rich are different: they are more ruthless"
- crpatino 16y agoNot necessarily ruthless, but money literate. I'd rather reserve my kindness and good manners for actual people. Banks are, in a way, abstract machines made of policies, rules and procedures. You do not gently talk to your computer; you type the command as outlined in the fine manual.
- wheaties 16y agoBanks and businesses have been doing this for years. They weigh the economic impact of supporting an unprofitable entity versus the impact of letting it go. I don't see why people insist that other people are "morally" obliged to continue to pay a mortgage. A mortgage is a business contract. The banks evaluate you in terms of risk of not paying and you evaluate the prospects of the mortgage contract they write for you. There's no blood oath or secret brotherhood you join.
- josephruscio 16y agoThere is absolutely no moral or ethical dilemma in "jingle-mail". These banks handed out huge no-money down loans like candy to people who bought way more house (and in some case multiple houses) than they could legitimately afford. Both parties were complicit in a transaction that should never have occurred. Now that the inevitable has occurred and the music has stopped, the only thing that matters is the letter of the law regarding the contract. If the bank proposed/agreed to a no-recourse loan, just walk away. Morality aside, jingle-mail is also the healthiest solution from a market perspective. The faster banks are forced to take their lumps, move these foreclosures through the market, and return lending standards to their historical norms (e.g. 20% down), the sooner the housing market can return to normalcy.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- moonpolysoft 16y agoI'm currently in the process of walking away from a home out of state. I moved from Delaware to California close to 3 years ago due to a really good job opportunity. I couldn't take the hit in selling our house at the time since it was underwater, so I wound up renting it out. Through that time I have had 2 renters on the property, both of whom wound up walking away from their leases. The last renters trashed the place and I could not afford to get it fixed up enough to rent it out again. So I was stuck with an unrentable home out of state that I could not afford to fix up and could barely afford the mortgage payments on. Therefore I just decided to simply walk away from it. Given that context, I simply cannot understand how people can say it's either immoral or unethical to walk away from a house. The loan modifications that banks try to shove down your throat are generally shitty deals, they simply want recapitalize all of your late fees and missed payments back into the principle, putting you further underwater. Working out a more equitable deal with the home retention folks is damn near impossible. Not to mention all of the collections calls and come ons from unscrupulous firms that want thousands of dollars to try and work out a deal for you. Walking away is an act of last resort and the financial and credit penalties are there to mitigate it.
- roc 16y ago> "I simply cannot understand how people can say it's either immoral or unethical to walk away from a house." It's a social hack, leveraging legacy social behavior. When loans were primarily between family, friends and neighbors who are not professional businessmen, the social pressure is beneficial to the community. If you took advantage of the lender, the community would be less cooperative in the future. That no longer being an accurate description of most business deals, individuals are still encouraged to think of legal contracts as being akin to their social/moral 'word' (of honor). This gives an advantage to the businessman who treats it as a legal contract and nothing more. The individual, once-convinced, will go to great lengths to ensure moral justice, dramatically mitigating the financial risk the businessman agreed to. e.g. the mark is socially pressured to accept increasingly-onerous terms to try and repay a debt he 'swore' to repay; even though the contract clearly stipulates interest as the price of the businessman's risk in the first place. Most people just don't realize their tradition is being used against them. The rest are encouraging the stigma because they like being paid interest for one risk level, but actually enjoying a much lower real risk. See also: credit counseling and debt restructuring as new legal pre-requisites to filing bankruptcy. It dramatically lowered risk of lending, without any commensurate decrease in the cost of borrowing. Yet bankruptcy is still stigmatized as something that only happens to deadbeats and losers. The skyrocketing proportion of bankruptcies due job loss or medical costs are brushed under the rug. The price of interest being the bank's reward for accepting the risk of lending is brushed under the rug.
- rada 16y agoThere is a big difference between regular debt and collateral-backed debt. The whole point of a loan backed by a collateral (in this case, the house) is that the lender gets said collateral upon default. Mortgage lenders are not "screwed" by foreclosures - they would love a foreclosure on a house whose value is up. Banks do not count on your paying off the house - if they did, they would not explicitly demand your house as a collateral upfront. They are exactly like the pawn shop owner who takes your wedding ring in exchange for some cash. It's not a moral obligation on the part of the owner to buy the ring back if the price of gold goes down to the point where it's cheaper to buy a new ring - so why is it a moral obligation on the part of the home owner to buy the house back from the bank? Perhaps those rich people are not "ruthless" - perhaps they are rich because they understand things like that.
- bosch 16y agoIt's fucking pathetic that both banks and homeowners look for a bail out from the tax payers who were fiscally responsible. Why is there no punishment for people being stupid and why should responsible citizens help you keep the house that's bigger and better than theirs with a government bailout? Does anyone have any integrity or pride in themselves anymore? Walking away from a mortgage you signed is about as responsible as the banks asking for bail outs!