3 ms·
This is a bad article. A general principle in debate is to attack the strongest arguments from the opposing side, not the weakest ones. Yes, dragging Shanley fo
by geofft 9y ago
This is a bad article. A general principle in debate is to attack the strongest arguments from the opposing side, not the weakest ones. Yes, dragging Shanley for her low-context low-nuance tweets is easy. (I suspect she enjoys seeing people fall into that trap.) The article completely dismisses a well-reasoned critique of the ACLU by a former-as-of-yesterday ACLU of Virginia board member who was directly involved in the Charlottesville legal proceedings until the ACLU showed up to oppose him:
https://twitter.com/waldojaquith/status/896512190563454977 https://twitter.com/waldojaquith/status/896512190563454977 (thread)
https://twitter.com/waldojaquith/status/896566113974317058 https://twitter.com/waldojaquith/status/896566113974317058 (thread)
All they say about this is "One board member of the ACLU of Virginia, Waldo Jaquith, waited until the violence erupted to announce on Twitter that he was resigning in protest of the ACLU’s representation of the protesters – as though he was unaware when he joined the Board that the ACLU has been representing the free speech rights of neo-Nazis and other white supremacist groups (along with Communists, Muslims, war protesters and the full spectrum of marginalized minorities and leftists) for many decades."
Of course he knows that and knew that. Greenwald would do well to debate his actual points.
In particular, the ACLU was not defending the right of the neo-Nazis to assemble, but the right of the neo-Nazis to assemble in a crowded park that was too small for effective logistics. (Greenwald half-mentions this in a parenthetical, without context.) Jason Kessler and Emily Gorcenski agree on approximately nothing, but they both have criticized the inability of the city to keep order during yesterday's events, which appears to be the direct cause of the life lost yesterday: the road that James Alan Fields drove his car down was not a protest location but was between two of the parks, and the counter-protesters believed that it was supposed to be closed to vehicular traffic.
The city was not trying to prevent the neo-Nazis from speaking. They were merely trying to move them to a larger, easier-to-secure area to prevent exactly the thing that happened yesterday. The ACLU defended the right of the neo-Nazis to protest in the smaller park simply because they claimed it was their free speech right to assemble next to the statue of Robert E. Lee, instead of somewhere that the city could ensure a safe event.
It also gives no serious response to this critique of the ACLU by a current ACLU lawyer:
https://twitter.com/chasestrangio/status/895351745693585419 https://twitter.com/chasestrangio/status/895351745693585419
and completely ignores this information, which utterly wipes out Greenwald's non-serious response to Strangio, from an attorney with the Asian Law Caucus:
https://twitter.com/anoop_alc/status/896468870764011522 https://twitter.com/anoop_alc/status/896468870764011522
"I asked the ACLU for help defending a Muslim immigrant being deported for protected speech. They declined. They CHOOSE to protect the KKK."
- valuearb 9y agoYour objections are weak and poorly thought out. 1) An ACLU member who spent thousands of dollars and their free time trying to suppress free speech rights shouldn't have been in the ACLU to begin with. Free speech didn't cause this violence, a terrorist and assorted thugs and instigators did. Banning free speech doesn't heal those people's brains of the ill they carry. 2) If Strangio can't support free speech for everyone, including people he finds despicable, he doesn't support free speech at all. Who decides which opinions and people are "despicable"? Sooner or later we all risk being viewed as despicable by someone in power, free societies have always degenerated into tyranny over time. Let's not hurry the process in the U.S. Again, Strangio should resign from the ACLU. 3) And what is the point of the last tweet? The ACLU doesn't have the resources to take every case and fight every battle. Are you arguing they should pick the ones that are less contentious? Or involve less despicable people? How about they pick the ones that have the most importance in our society?
- geofft 9y agoYou rebut your own points. > An ACLU member who spent thousands of dollars and their free time trying to suppress free speech rights ... Free speech didn't cause this violence That's exactly the point: he was not trying to suppress free speech rights, and conversely, the ACLU was not defending free speech. They thought they were. For good reasons. Nobody, including Jaquith, is questioning their good intentions. But they were wrong. He was an ACLU member because he valued free speech, and he took an action that he believed was likely to prevent violence without risking free speech. The ACLU disagreed. He decided to continue being a member of the board of the ACLU of Virginia because he respected that he could have been wrong and the ACLU could have been right. It turned out the ACLU was wrong. Are we now to believe that the ACLU is infallible, that anything they call free speech is in fact free speech, and that even anyone involved with the ACLU who disagrees with the organization's decisions is to be excommunicated? > If Strangio can't support free speech for everyone, including people he finds despicable Again, he's supporting free speech for everyone, as far as that goal is possible. He believes that the ACLU's case is not in fact advancing the cause of free speech for everyone. And, in any case, let us suppose that Strangio should resign from the ACLU and that Jaquith should never have joined. Even so, they have points worth debating honestly. Greenwald isn't doing that. Perhaps "free speech for everyone" is a self-contradictory goal, or a goal that simply serves as cover for "continued free speech for the powerful", and they can't honestly support that goal. That just means the ACLU is worth criticizing, and they're the people who would know the most about what the ACLU is doing wrong! > How about they pick the ones that have the most importance in our society? That is exactly what I'm proposing. Milo Yiannopoulos is in no danger of not having his ideas heard by society, of people not knowing that he exists, of people not knowing what he believes. Neither were any of the folks at yesterday's rally. Their message was clear months in advance: they believe we should keep the statue of Robert E. Lee because it symbolizes a history worth remembering. Milo is no minority viewpoint, nor is the alt-right. (Greenwald gets this wrong too, by pretending that the "mainstream" and the majority are the same, and everything opinion outside the mainstream/majority is equally marginalized.) His right to speak is important. But it is not significantly at risk, and as a result, defending his right is far from the most important thing in our society. The neo-Nazis were going to march in Charlottesville anyway; the ACLU picked a case that gave them the right to march in the park they wanted instead of the park they didn't want. I really do not understand the argument that anyone (neo-Nazis, antifa, the Papal Guard, whoever) being able to march in the right park is the most important issue in our society. We don't even know who the person the ACLU didn't represent was going to say. We don't know who they were. And not only were they silenced, they are now gone from America.