2 ms·
I disagree, mainly because the author conflates multiple cases into one: 1. Is it okay if I dump trash into a discovery-based system? (No) 2. Is it okay if I d
by StavrosK 9y ago
I disagree, mainly because the author conflates multiple cases into one:
1. Is it okay if I dump trash into a discovery-based system? (No)
2. Is it okay if I dump trash into a system with no discovery component? (Yes)
If you want to post notes to your personal website or github account, go nuts, people don't really browse the entirety of GitHub to find interesting repos, there are other discovery avenues.
However, if you want to publish a module on npm that consists of the line "return 60", that decreases the SNR in a system that is used for discovery. I don't know about npm specifically, but I do browse PyPI to find some interesting packages to use, and if everyone uploaded their throwaway code to it, it would erode my (and everyone else's) trust in the package archive.
- mjw1007 9y agoMaybe a good rule of thumb is to 'police' anything that uses a shared namespace.
- mavhc 9y agoI guess people use a shared namespace until it goes wrong, then switch to a hierarchy. But that's different from the real problem, you want usage rankings, reviews, advice, etc, when looking for a library to use, not just a list of names.