3 ms·
I, for one, think that this site has gotten much BETTER in the past year. It's the first (and last) I go to every day. It's got just the right mix of outside
by edw519 19y ago
I, for one, think that this site has gotten much BETTER in the past year. It's the first (and last) I go to every day. It's got just the right mix of outside content, intellegent discussion of that content, "Ask YC" threads, and self-examination.
I sure hope I don't upset anyone, but here goes:
1. BrandonM, I recognize your name from encountering you many times in interesting threads. Sure hope you'll reconsider. We'd miss you.
2. BrandonM, you've been a member for 369 days and have posted an outside submission 8 times. AFAIC, your complaint carries no weight. If you don't like the content here, submit more better content.
3. If anyone sees a thread they don't like, don't vote up or click on it.
4. If you're tired of what I call "self-examination" threads, don't vote them up or click on them.
5. Personally, I find the threads discussing this site the most interesting. Here's why. Even though most of us are hackers, we're also users. (We'd better be, or we'd lose all perspective.) The one thing we all have in common is that we are users of THIS SITE. We NEED to keep talking about it. It provides valuable feedback to pg, and interestingly, it provides us much better feedback about each other. I learn more about how you guys think and work from your comments in these threads than any other type. Not sure why, just the way it is.
6. If you're concerned about the content here, DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT. I surf about a dozen other sites throughout the day, and whenever I see anything interesting, I submit it. I don't feel like I've gotten everything out of the story until I get feedback here. Many stories die quickly (I'm disappointed), but many others take off. If you find something cool somewhere else, don't keep it a secret; let us know about it.
7. Vote!
8. Visit the "new" page more often. Lots of good stuff falls out of the top 30 to a quick death. Maybe we need a more prominent link to the new page, a "split screen" default, or more than 30 new links.
9. Starting a software business takes a lot more than good hacking skills and raw intelligence. You need passion, perserverence, thick skin, and big balls. Don't like something (here or anywhere else)? Shut up and do your part to make it better. Whiners don't belong here.
Sure don't mean to offend anyone, especially you, BrandonM. At least you had the balls to say what others must be thinking but won't say. And you gave the rest of us a chance to get a few things off our chest. Thanks. Hope to continue to see your name around here.
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoGood comment. I notice that your karma is over 4000. Could it be that you're just one of the "chosen few" who are supposed to represent the community at large? If so, it would stand to reason that your karma would go through the roof and you would be finding the site more and more interesting. I wonder if the reverse holds true: if by choosing the "holders of quality" it also has the effect of choosing certain personality types as being "anti-quality" In other words, when a site gravitates to being represented by a select few (which we all know happens) does it also tend to completely turn off people of opposite personalities and tastes? This is probably not such a big deal with a low volume of articles and submissions, ie, everybody gets a chance to make a difference in the conversation. In a 10-article-per-day site, everybody's opinion can get something on the front page. But as the volume increases, individuals get lost in the system and those that don't exactly match the opinions of the select few feel more and more isolated. Just wildly speculating here. I didn't mean to criticize you personally, just using your account and comment as an example. Hope that is okay.
- edw519 19y ago"Could it be that you're just one of the "chosen few"" I've never been "chosen" for anything in my life. That's why I'm a hacker. With few exceptions. everything I've ever had or accomplished has been a result of hard work and perserverence (good thing I love what I do). "represent the community at large" Ha, if only it were true! I often wonder if I'm the most contrary person here. I've never "audited" my comments here, but I'd be willing to bet many of them were "against the common grain". A little background: I have absolutely NO formal computer education. I was a math major in a college without a computer science department. I have written tens of thousands of original programs in many technologies in over 80 companies. I don't fully understand social networking, or ad based revenue, but I do know how to build what users need. I don't blog, facebook, twitter, instant message, or text. I often worry that I don't fit in here, because I feel so different from the "typical" member, if there is such a thing. My karma score is a direct result of participation, nothing else. Anyone can do it. I have no idea (nor do I care) if that score "entitles" me to anything. I love it here. I sit at my terminal from 12 to 16 hours 6 or 7 days per week. Except for the few precious hours with friends and family, THIS is my social life. Don't even have to get up to interact with other humans, alt-tab does it. Yes, you are wildly speculating. But that is okay. How else would we know about things unless we talk about them?