3 ms·
The first sentence already states, that fired guy said women "unfit". Stopped reading right there.
by lostmsu 9y ago
The first sentence already states, that fired guy said women "unfit". Stopped reading right there.
- thinkfurther 9y agoWhile this https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15004138 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15004138 gets flagged instantly, that rises to the top? Google, HN, New York Times, Gizmodo -- who else? Stand up and be counted.
- KirinDave 9y agoThis is off-topic but I figured I'd let you know: I flagged the post you linked, without coordination from others, for being derivative and lacking in any new content, perspectives or even a novel presentation. I am sure that other people flagged it too. I am not a big fan of this piece for its inaccuracy, but at least it brings some new subjects and perspectives so I can't find a reason to flag it other than my exhaustion with the subject (which is, of course, insufficient). Why would you blame HN here? The post had 8 points on a midday Sunday.
- thinkfurther 9y agoBecause that's the pattern I noticed in the last few days (or maybe I missed the good discussions that were had previously of which this is a repeat?). For example, as I pointed out here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14997068 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14997068 > Yesterday, this had 156 and 101 comments points after 4 hours, and had been sunk like a brick to place 46 on page two (which I now realize should have read "156 points and 101 comments") How about flagging things that absolutely don't belong on the site, and simply not upvoting things you don't find very good? edit: I mean, especially in the context of a guy writing a memo the "larger point" of which is to not silence people who aren't ultra-aligned, to have free discourse about ideas and how to make Google and the situation for women at Google better, getting fired for that and then HN being filled with people distorting what he wrote, while "journalists" do the same. And yes, it's getting upvotes, too, people do want to discuss it, it's just that others don't want to let them. This is an outright attack. This is another move of sociopath social engineers testing the limits of what they can get away with, and just like with Appelbaum, HN fucking FAILS. It's not about "content", at most about the content of the personalities of the people involved.
- KirinDave 9y agoFor comment points dropping and rising, I am not positive on this but what I've heard is that we're sometimes witnessing fake accounts get banned off the site and their votes being retracted. I've had bug negative votes on posts suddenly pop back up almost instantly. In threads on this subject, it happens an awful lot. I suspect people are availing themselves of various vote purchasing schemes to amplify their points.
- thinkfurther 9y agoThat wasn't about points dropping and rising, it was about a story that would without flags be square on page one clearly being sunk with flags. It was in neighbourhood of stories with either much less points, or that were lots older. Once a month I think of making a scaper just to detect this, to filter out the interesting stories automatically, if you will. The ones that are clearly not spam or such, but still get dropped like a hot potato.
- KirinDave 9y agoWell I can't speak to other people's actions, only mine. When a story is small and it's submitter is of medium karma it doesn't take many flags. I have had many arguments with the mods over my years here and we still have our disagreements, but I don't see them nuke things often. I see vote and flag manipulations a lot.
- thinkfurther 9y agoOh, I absolutely didn't mean to imply that HN mods intervened manually. They're just not intervening to keep people from keeping others from having a discussion, either.
- CalChris 9y agoIf you put the word "unfit" in quotes then you are quoting the article. The first paragraph of the article says: > The Google engineer who was fired last week over his memo wrote that most women were biologically unsuited to working in tech because they were more focused on “feelings and aesthetics than ideas” and had “a stronger interest in people rather than things.” The article does not use the word unfit in the first or in any of the remaining paragraphs. Since you got that simple fact wrong I stopped reading your in-depth analysis right there.
- thinkfurther 9y agoI vouched for the story (which I didn't flag) just so I could reply: "unfit" and "unsuited" mean exactly the same thing. Are you being this intellectually dishonest on purpose? > Since you got that wrong I stopped reading your analysis right there. That's great, because the analysis is concluded: hack fraud journalism. Next.
- CalChris 9y agoUnfit and unsuited do not mean exactly the same thing. In particular, I can't say that the manifesto said that women are unfit to work in tech. Damore didn't say and he didn't mean that. I can and will say that the manifesto said (not quoting here) that women are unsuited for tech. There's sufficient difference between the two words to drive that truck between them. Unfit: not of the necessary quality or standard to meet a particular purpose Unsuited: not right or appropriate. When you quote, quote accurately, especially if you put your quotes in quotation marks.
- thinkfurther 9y ago> In particular, I can't say that the manifesto said that women are unfit to work in tech. You can't say it said they're unsuitable to work in tech either. > I can and will say that the manifesto said (not quoting here) You can't make this shit up.. well, as long as you're not quoting I don't care so much what you "can and will say". It's just hot air and saying nothing. But with the way I hobble around in the uncanny valley of the English language, I'm always happy to teach bits of it to a native speaker: http://www.thesaurus.com/browse/unfit http://www.thesaurus.com/browse/unfit unsuited is one of the synonyms. Though not vice versa, but then again, that's just some random site: http://www.thesaurus.com/browse/unsuited http://www.thesaurus.com/browse/unsuited Here's another random site: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/unfit https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/unfit a : not adapted to a purpose : unsuitable But what really gets me that rather than correcting that, you just add something even more silly: Unfit: not of the necessary quality or standard to meet a particular purpose Unsuited: not right or appropriate. Do you notice something? "Unsuited" without a qualifier such as "to meet a particular purpose" makes no sense, and cannot be used that way. If anything, unfit can be used that way, though the purpose (being a mother, or standing up without wheezing) is usually implied. You might as well spell the definition of one word with capital letters and the other with lower ones and say "that's not exactly the same". I agree that unfit can be used to mean a value statement, a "not good enough", where unsuitable is more neutral. But even the Oxford Dictionary which defines the individual words in such a way then has this: https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/thesaurus/unfit https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/thesaurus/unfit Drive a truck between them? Heh. Language is too nice an invention to play games with it like this. > When you quote, quote accurately, especially if you put your quotes in quotation marks. If you get hung up on this, and actually defend it, you would otherwise have ignored it or found something else. I'll just claim that -- I can, and I will! -- to save us both time.
- jkelsey 9y agoWhat do you think the motivation for the Google memo was, exactly?
- ktRolster 9y agoI think the proper response to the Google manifesto is to say that women don't always choose to become programmers, but when they do, they're pretty good at it.