4 ms·
> Isn't your wife supposed to be your best/closest friend? No, although that's a common misconception; it can turn out that way, but rarely does, and there's n
by throwanem 9y ago
> Isn't your wife supposed to be your best/closest friend?
No, although that's a common misconception; it can turn out that way, but rarely does, and there's nothing of necessity wrong with a relationship in which it does not.
I was married myself for about a decade, and also painfully lonely through most of it despite being nearly never physically alone. I've operated under the impression that this had to do with the abusive nature of that relationship, and wasn't representative of any general case. Now I'm starting to wonder if I might not have been wrong about that. Certainly I still hesitate to draw any kind of general conclusion from my own experience of marriage - but I'm hearing a lot more lately from men whose experiences in this regard are similar, despite their relationships generally not appearing to be so.
- Aaargh20318 9y agoThen why have a relationship at all ?
- throwanem 9y agoWell, for one thing, it's the best model our society makes available for raising and supporting kids. That's not to say it is necessarily a very good model, but I think if you have to choose between your kids growing up with their parents in a stable and functional, if not especially warm or happy, relationship on the one hand, and your kids growing up with divorced parents on the other, it's very hard to find any way to justify the latter choice on the basis of their welfare. Quite aside from that, though, I'm still not seeing any reason to assume that relationships in general exhibit this problem - only that it's not quite as uncommon as the highly atypical nature of my own experience led me to surmise. (Or what I hope to be the highly atypical nature, anyway. If marriages like mine are anything except vanishingly uncommon, that's a serious problem. There are so many improbable circumstances around the way mine started that I've seen no reason to assume many similar relationships exist - but on reflection it occurs to me that I've failed to account for the possibility of stochastic convergence.)
- Aaargh20318 9y ago> Well, for one thing, it's the best model our society makes available for raising and supporting kids. You're not required to have kids. I guess what I'm trying to figure out is why even start a relationship if you don't get anything out of it. Never mind getting to the point where you start producing kids.
- matz1 9y agoBecause sometimes you just can't help it, or very difficult not to.
- throwanem 9y agoI don't see how.
- matz1 9y agoRelationship can be exciting, it can be incredibly difficult to resist.
- drdeadringer 9y agoTo be fair, that would be getting something out of it.
- throwanem 9y ago> You're not required to have kids. No, but a lot of people want to. (A lot of people have kids without the formality of a relationship, too, but that's a whole 'nother kind of problem.) I guess I'd say that for most people there are a lot of reasons to want to be in a relationship - good reasons and bad ones alike. With rare exception, nobody goes into a relationship expecting that it won't improve their life in some way, and if you're not seeing what you might get out of one, then I can't see any reason why you should start one. It seems like a lot of people do eventually discover that they don't get out of a given relationship what they hoped they might, or what they previously did - but that's also a whole 'nother kind of problem, and because it often involves strongly felt responsibilities to people other than oneself, a kind that is rarely easy to solve even if there's no clear way to incrementally improve upon the status quo. I don't think I've done a very good job explaining it here, but I'm not sure how I might do a better one.
- goodcanadian 9y ago> Isn't your wife supposed to be your best/closest friend? No, although that's a common misconception; it can turn out that way, but rarely does, and there's nothing of necessity wrong with a relationship in which it does not. Just to provide a counter anecdote. My wife is very definitely my best and closest friend.