4 ms·
Resetting the Clock of Life
- reasonattlm 9y agoA great example of the way in which researchers leap to try to alter downstream consequences of aging. This impulse is why 99% of all efforts to treat aging as a medical condition are doomed to failure. The research community has an institutional problem in that all the short-term incentives have them studying the biochemistry of the system in a broken (aged) state, and then working backwards towards causes. Each link in the chain takes years of work. The first place they stop is thus a long way removed from any root cause, but then the incentives work to say "prove your work is valuable" and someone tries to commercialize it. All medicine for age-related disease (so far) is marginal precisely because it attempts to compensate for or tries to improve downstream consequences that are a long way removed from fundamental damage that causes aging. You can change the oil as much as you like in a car that is failing for mechanical reasons, but the degree to which you gain benefit from that action is much what you'd expect. You can press the accelerator to try to drive a faltering engine faster. Same story. You fix problems by fixing the root causes, not by ignoring those root causes in favor of things that happen to be what is right in front of you.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jostmey 9y agoHow many people periodically restart their computer just because they think it might run better afterwards? Maybe it was easier for natural selection to periodically restart the clock than to debug all the molecular pathways so that they remain stable over an organism's lifetime.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 9y ago> debug all the molecular pathways so that they remain stable over an organism's lifetime. It did just that. Hence the lifetime being what it is... You now want to debug the molecular pathways to remain stable longer than the present lifetime, which will merely move that point a bit into the future, and will then be the new lifetime.
- candiodari 9y agoExcept the cells used for procreation are also part of the cell line, and do require "debugged molecular pathways" (nature doesn't debug, nature makes things recover from errors, though not always in ways you'd like) This reason for death does not really make sense. Only the connections between cells get reset. The cell line has to continue, with the potentially problematic molecular pathways (look at all the mitochondrial DNA syndromes). In fact, if you think about it, there is a continuous cell line between that skinflake you just shed and the very first time DNA started replicating on this planet.
- MichailP 9y agoI wonder what occasional socially accepted sleep deprivation (staying out late, working long hours, making love all night ^^ ) does to a body. The day after does typically feel like part of you died, and that dead part has to go to work anyway.
- ams6110 9y agoI used to make the effort to go to work after a long night out. Now I just call in sick and sleep. Work will be there the next day.
- lngnmn 9y agoLife has no clocks. It, as a set of processes, has phases, which happen follow the phases of the environment and use these phases to maintenance and repair. There is no such thing as time, so Nature and evolution does not have any clock or counters. Life does not work the way we conditioned to think as observers. It cannot use abstract mental concerts which does not exist at molecular or cellular level. Cells do message passing and explicit pattern matching. No clocks or counters.
- carl_corder 9y agoThis reminds me of a passage from "Einstein's Dreams" by Alan Lightman. It's the difference between mechanical time & body time. You can read it here: http://members.iif.hu/visontay/ponticulus/britannicus/einstein-dream.html http://members.iif.hu/visontay/ponticulus/britannicus/einste... (the 24 April 1905 entry).
- otto_ortega 9y ago> Life has no clocks Oh yes it has! it's arrow is called entropy and it ticks at the speed of atom decay.
- lngnmn 9y agoFrom the life's point of view, so to speak, atoms are immutable. The actual process of decay are below the level of abstraction. Life "knows nothing" about it by definition.
- cannonpr 9y agoFor something that has no clocks, it sure has a lot of gears like atp synthase https://youtu.be/b_cp8MsnZFA https://youtu.be/b_cp8MsnZFA While I appreciate your comment in being fairly correct, I still think there is a lot of value in trying to understand the human body as a molecular machine that runs on top of reality and generates sub environments that have "clocks" to synchronise processes. After all a clock signal doesn't measure the day, it measures discrete intervals.
- titzer 9y agoCare to offer references for your claims that differ completely from, e.g., the article, which is based on decades of research and established science by experts on the matter?