3 ms·
In Germany, we have had a quite extensive network of night trains with proper beds (and the more expensive tickets also have a shower in the carriage); unfortun
by mschuster91 9y ago
In Germany, we have had a quite extensive network of night trains with proper beds (and the more expensive tickets also have a shower in the carriage); unfortunately the network got massively thinned out in the last years and only the profitable core routes are in service now by Austrian ÖBB.
Shouldn't something like this be possible in America, especially between far-away cities? Could at least be more profitable because you don't need to shunt around carriages every couple hours and if it gets kept between hubs there's no need for inter-route stops either.
- totalZero 9y agoshrug https://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/08/economist-explains-18 https://www.economist.com/blogs/economist-explains/2013/08/e... These guys tried to answer that question. Still, it seems to me that even they didn't touch on any good answers. shrug
- the_mitsuhiko 9y agoFWIW OeBB is investing into new night trains for routes between Austria and Italy. If they get popular they want to expand that. https://www.oebb.at/en/news/nightjet-der-zukunft https://www.oebb.at/en/news/nightjet-der-zukunft I generally really like nighttrains but there are not enough routes i need to take.
- FTA 9y agoAmtrak offers this with "roomettes" all the way up to 4-person rooms, though whether it's an overnight or a day trip depends on your origin and destination (for example, Chicago to Dallas is an overnight). You mention that Germany had eliminated all but the profitable ones--well, the U.S. government loses money on these routes to keep them running even in spite of the high prices. I'd usually pay $800 roundtrip for CHI->DAL; meals _are_ included and you get I believe up to two carry-ons and two checked bags for free. I will say it is definitely a lower stress option. You can show up 30 minutes before your train is leaving and there's no security lines. Depending on the station, it could be just an empty train station in a rural town or a large station interconnected with other transport services (e.g. Boston, Chicago). The population you are traveling with is much different compared not only to airlines but also coach on the train. Generally your sleeper carmates are retired folks who don't want to deal with the hassle of TSA, running between connections, arriving three hours early, and so on. I've met some extremely nice people with amazing stories (you are seated with strangers at meals, so this is almost forced on you). If you are not in a hurry and have a few extra bucks, it's worth it at least once to experience the journey, especially across the Upper Midwest or coasts.
- mschuster91 9y ago> I'd usually pay $800 roundtrip for CHI->DAL; By car (and Google Maps measuring) that's about 3.000km total. Hamburg-Munich is about 1.500km total, so half the distance. But ÖBB Nightjet tickets start for ~160€ to 250€ roundtrip, about half the price and Amtrak is losing money? How is that even possible?
- SOLAR_FIELDS 9y agoProbably because the trains never fill up.
- chrischen 9y agoThey're losing money because that's a ridiculously expensive price and people looking to just get from point A to B would not pay that.
- ghaff 9y agoSo they should cut their prices and lose even more money? The basic problem is that outside of the Northeast Corridor--which is very popular, profitable, and getting new infrastructure investment--there are very few city pairs in the US that have the right combination of density and distance. Effectively the Northeast Corridor makes all the money that Amtrak then loses in the rest of the country. This is a few years old but summarizes Amtrak profit (or lack thereof) by route: http://reasonrail.blogspot.com/2014/11/amtrak-routes-by-2014-cost-recovery.html http://reasonrail.blogspot.com/2014/11/amtrak-routes-by-2014...
- chrischen 9y agoSometimes something is just obsolete. Their uncompetitive price reflects that.
- ghaff 9y agoYes. But, it's not politically tenable to simply shut down rail service in the US outside of the Northeast Corridor. (Nor is it obvious that would be a good decision at a national level for many reasons.)
- _delirium 9y agoAmtrak does run a number of night trains, mostly on the routes where the trip is too long to plausibly do it as a day train, though. For example the NYC-Chicago night train (Lake Shore Limited) departs NYC at 15:40 and arrives in Chicago at 09:45 the next day (19 hours). And Chicago-SF is a 2-night trip (51 hours).
- ghaff 9y agoYou can also do Boston to DC as an overnight but I don't think they have any sleeper cars on that route. (Even with Acela, few people do that full route.)
- bpye 9y agoI took a few of the night trains in Europe this year, Krakow - Prague and Prague - Zurich (both CD, Czech, I think) were great, Verona - Paris kinda sucked though (Thello, private)
- matthewowen 9y agoThe USA is really big. I took the train from Chicago to San Francisco. I loved it, but it took the best part of three days. Flying is always going to be more compelling for functional travel like this.