3 ms·
> This is really about C++ vs C/Pascal and not OO vs Proc. Also this is 1997 C++... I can imagine the Smalltalk community rolling its collective eyes and sayin
by mannykannot 9y ago
> This is really about C++ vs C/Pascal and not OO vs Proc. Also this is 1997 C++...
I can imagine the Smalltalk community rolling its collective eyes and saying "that's not OO..."
My issue with the primary study is that the two programs are not really comparable: a think a C++ parser was a harder problem than a C parser (even given that it is 1997's C++), and this is backed up in the study:
"The C++ parser by further contrast is a recursive descent parser owing to the intractability of parsing C++ using 1 token-lookahead grammars. In other words, they are very different products..."
In mitigation, it says that the C++ parser, as used in the comparison, did not parse the full language, thereby presumably reducing the difference in the complexity of the requirements, but I think the difference in architecture alone is enough to raise doubts over the significance of the results.