3 ms·
That's not the idea I was trying to convey. I think any claim that any language (computer or ordinary or otherwise) captures the way people think independent of
by brudgers 9y ago
That's not the idea I was trying to convey. I think any claim that any language (computer or ordinary or otherwise) captures the way people think independent of the use of that language is at least suspect [and for me probably false, but I could be wrong].
To me, it seems more likely that the flexibility of human cognition allows a person to think in terms of a programming language than any particular programming language expresses something important about the mechanics of human thought. Another way of putting it is that the claim that object oriented programming is ontologically different from other Turing complete languages seems less believable than ontological equivalence -- the Chicken [1] interpreter is written in JavaScript.
http://torso.me/chicken http://torso.me/chicken
- logicallee 9y agoI'm afraid we disagree entirely. Before the existence of any computer language, humans talked, and thought: at various levels of rigor. Mathematical books were published for millennia. People thought, interpreted their world, argued with each other, and so forth. With the advent of computer languages, some of these have captured more of this independent thinking and abstraction, others capture less of it, while still others require their users to learn abstractions they were not used to. The idea that all of this falls in the last category, with no capturing of the way "people think independent of the use of that language" is totally false to me. Sorry.
- brudgers 9y agoMathematical books were published for millennia. Writing is thinking...etc.
- logicallee 9y agoCan you be a bit more precise? I feel like we're talking past each other but perhaps have misunderstood each other.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]