2 ms·
> but it can't force people to actually read the articles before responding They could hash the title for a minimum time, or until at least three comments are
by krapp 9y ago
> but it can't force people to actually read the articles before responding
They could hash the title for a minimum time, or until at least three comments are posted.
That would at least force people to click the link to find out what's there, and filter out commenters too lazy to do even that.
- throwaway413 9y agoOr just force the user to click the link before the comment box is enabled for that posting.
- mgkimsal 9y agothen waiting X minutes before enabling the comment box too, to avoid just clicking and posting?
- SwellJoe 9y agoHashing the title when first posted would likely lead to more quality problems. The first stage of QC is New. Nothing makes it to the front page without a little time on New. So, I think that hashing titles would make it so that the worst (by some definition, but one that probably matches HN's definition) clickbaity stuff would rise to the front page faster and more often. This would happen because people could no longer make any decisions about what to click on New by it's title, and so the short articles that confirm common tropes, the funny pictures, etc. would get people coming back faster to click the upvote, while the longer articles would be more slow to get upvotes. Same problem we have already, only moreso. At least now, we have a stage where we can see the title in New and the interesting things might get upvotes sooner...you have a little more knowledge going in. i.e., I might not read the whole article about something I find really interesting, but I might click over to it, see that it's by someone I trust or seems to be well done and free of fluff, and upvote it before finishing reading. I dunno. I could see blocking commenting for a time after a post. But, hashing titles seems to just take away valuable information people use to make upvote decisions during the vital New phase of a post. Also, there's no way I'm clicking on every link on New. New is a goddamned wasteland; 50+% garbage, sometimes.