3 ms·
> not offer true state encapsulation, it just hides it. That's kind of the definition of encapsulation. > difficult to reason about This is repeated as a man
by mpweiher 9y ago
> not offer true state encapsulation, it just hides it.
That's kind of the definition of encapsulation.
> difficult to reason about
This is repeated as a mantra without any backup. Most people find state trivial to "reason" about. What becomes more difficult are certain types of proofs that nobody actually does.
> [FP] makes it easier to manage and control state
No, not "easier". In fact, incredibly more difficult. Just try updating a nested member. What it does is make it easier to isolate state updates, because it makes it so arduous.
- willtim 9y ago> That's kind of the definition of encapsulation. State encapsulation, at least in FP, means that the state is not visible externally. For example a pure function that uses mutable state in its implementation. Such state does not contribute to the sytem global state. > This is repeated as a mantra without any backup. The more global mutable state your application has, the harder it is to reason about. That should be fairly obvious I think.