4 ms·
I've long thought that arrival of the earliest people by boat made a lot more sense than coming over the land bridge from Asia. There was a study published in
by tzs 9y ago
I've long thought that arrival of the earliest people by boat made a lot more sense than coming over the land bridge from Asia.
There was a study published in Nature last year [1] that concluded that it took hundreds of years after the ice sheets receded and the route become passable before plants became established, and then later animals, to make it possible to survive off the land during such a trip.
We know that the Clovis culture was established before then, so if they or earlier people came by the land route then they must have brought their supplies with them.
That was before the invention of the wheel, so if they brought all their supplies with them for the journey it wasn't on wagons or carts. They only animals they might have had to help carry things were dogs, because no other animals were domesticated at that point.
So we're looking at carrying everything they need for the trip on their own backs or on crude sleds, possibly with the aid of dogs (and if they are bringing dogs, they have to bring all the food for the dogs, too).
This just seems to me to be too farfetched.
Now compare to coming by boats. With boats it is easy to bring plenty of cargo. Whatever food they bring with them can be supplemented with fish and other seafood they can catch on the way. Maybe they can even live entirely off seafood.
[1] I haven't seen the study itself freely online, but here's an article that goes into detail about it: http://www.history.com/news/new-study-refutes-theory-of-how-humans-populated-north-america http://www.history.com/news/new-study-refutes-theory-of-how-...
- ajross 9y agoTo be fair: the theory is that the boats were coastal, hugging the edge of beringia. It's still basically the same crossing, and made possible by the same root cause (lower sea levels made the connection a single coastline and not open ocean). The technology is different, and maybe the time frame, but the basic structure of the theory is still the same.
- contravariant 9y agoMain difference seems to be that boats would actually allow them to carry supplies with them.
- pacaro 9y agoAnd makes living off the coast much easier, from fishing and shell fishing. Walking along a coast is a fractal enterprise
- Steko 9y ago> a study published in Nature last year To be clear this refers to the fusion of the Laurentide (Canadian) and Cordilleran (Pacific NW) ice sheets but the caveats are this doesn't preclude travel into parts of Alaska and it's also possible there was some travel before the sheets were fused. > brought all their supplies with them Maybe they didn't have a lot of supplies? I mean people migrated all over Siberia and presumably many/most of them did so on foot. > they have to bring all the food for the dogs The traditional view was that they were following the food source. And presumably they kept the dogs around in the first place because (among other reasons) they help hunt and are also a food source. > Whatever food they bring with them can be supplemented with fish and other seafood they can catch on the way. Maybe they can even live entirely off seafood. This logic works with any food source though.
- louthy 9y agoBoats (capable of crossing seas) were invented before wheels? I genuinely don't know, but that seems surprising.
- sjwright 9y agoThe useful, all terrain, load bearing wheel sounds more complicated to me than a watertight bucket with ropes and cloth.
- dpc59 9y agoA dugout tree with a paddle is even more simple.
- pacaro 9y agoI think that the step from dugout to outrigger canoe is relatively small and comes with massive advantages While they are obviously the end point of a technological development, Polynesian outrigger sailing canoes are both extremely efficient (some evidence points to them being the first craft to be capable of exceeding hull speed) and scalable. They're also a Stone Age technology
- JoBrad 9y agoI was surprised, too. I found this article[0] which specifically calls out boats as having been invented before the wheel. It puts the wheel's invention in good perspective, I think. Regarding boats capable of crossing the ocean: Australia was settled 40,000 years ago, presumably by settlers who arrived by boat. [0] http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/a-salute-to-the-wheel-31805121/ http://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/a-salute-to-the...
- contingencies 9y agoMore like 65,000 years. https://doi.org/10.1038%2Fnature22968 https://doi.org/10.1038%2Fnature22968
- 9y ago
- Iv 9y agoOn a boat you still need a lot of freshwater, which is why the boats probably simply followed the coast and replenished at rivers (or used melted ice)
- Iv 9y agoOn a boat you still need a lot of freshwater, which is why the boats probably simply followed the coast and replenished at rivers (or used melted ice)