3 ms·
Huh? Sorry, one of the problems with your analogy was that it seemed to presume the legitimacy of transgender identity. I personally recognize it, so if Pat, b
by danso 9y ago
Huh? Sorry, one of the problems with your analogy was that it seemed to presume the legitimacy of transgender identity. I personally recognize it, so if Pat, born a man, tells me that they're a transgender woman, I would say, "Good to know Pat". If Bob thinks transgenderism is total bullshit, I'd disagree with that, but if that Bob told Pat, "I still think you're a man" -- I'd understand Bob's line of reasoning.
Not sure what we're arguing about anymore. You said [0] you've seen "lots of comments on HN that interpreted [Damore] as saying something indistinguishable from those things [e.g. fewer women are able to be good engineers than men)."
I replied with what was not meant to be a direct disagreement (I don't doubt you've seen those comments), but to suggest that someone can read Damore's memo and by reading between the lines
, argue that Damore was asserting/implying things even as he didn't literally say them. This includes thinking that Damore is anti-diversity even if he claims to be pro-diversity, because some people who act very racist have been known to claim that they are not racist and that they have many friends of different racial groups. That's all.
I get that Damore supporters don't have to agree with how anti-Damore folks have chosen to interpret and paraphrase Damore's memo. I argue only that it's hypocritical to dismiss such arguments-via-interpretation (especially since Damore used it when referring to articles and studies).
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14986958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14986958