7 ms·
> He was not saying that women who work at Google are at a biological disadvantage, in any way, and that is a perverse misreading. He was saying that on the who
by dahart 9y ago
> He was not saying that women who work at Google are at a biological disadvantage, in any way, and that is a perverse misreading. He was saying that on the whole there's a biological reason when you roll the dice enough that more males are suitable for that work.
I don't understand what you said there, can you elaborate? What is the difference between males being more biologically suitable and females being at a disadvantage? From my perspective, you just contradicted yourself, can you help me understand why it's not a contradiction?
What the memo proposed is that it's "possible" there are fewer women in tech right now because of the biological differences. He may not have claimed it as fact, but he implied it. The problem I have with the implication is that it's obvious that evolutionary forces are not the primary causes of the current distribution, because the distribution of women in tech has changed drastically in the last 50 years faster than evolution's say in the matter. It's not possible that the current distribution is primarily caused by biological differences, and it's exceedingly likely that it is caused by social issues. But he suggested it is possible, and followed that by suggesting we should stop treating it like a social issue because it's possible.
And all of this so far is ignoring that the memo unironically takes the opposite stance on the minority group of conservatives.
So what is the root part that I'm missing?
- ta2017 9y agoSuppose you have one million red cars and one million blue cars. Red cars get better gas mileage on average. Suppose you select the 100 red cars with the best gas mileage among the red cars and the 100 blue cars with the best gas mileage among the blue cars. Which group of 100 cars has better average gas mileage?
- dropstickle 9y agoLet's say you are an american. 60% of americans are overweight. Does that mean you are overweight?
- manigandham 9y agoAlso Americans on average are more overweight than Japanese. This does not mean there are no overweight Japanese or thin Americans, or that either are less capable of a specific sport.
- dahart 9y agoClearly not. Does 60% of Americans being overweight today mean that it's likely that 60% of people are naturally and biologically incapable of maintaining a healthy weight? There are genetic differences among underweight and overweight populations, so it is "possible" that the distribution of healthy weights to overweight people is natural a result of those genetic traits, and not the result of advertising and availability of high calorie foods. We should stop treating obesity as though it's a problem, right?
- dropstickle 9y agoI think you misunderstood me. I was not making a biological correlation, but a statistical one; namely that group averages doesn't say anything about an individual. The nature/nurture debate of overweight people is besides the point.
- dahart 9y agoThen I think you misunderstood the memo. The memo is making a biological correlation. It suggests that the current distributions might accurately reflect differences in biology. Nature vs nurture is completely the point here, Damore argued that nature is the primary force, not nurture, and therefore we should stop nurturing women in tech.
- dropstickle 9y agoMaybe I should have been clearer, you stated to the parent reply that: >> I don't understand what you said there, can you elaborate? What is the difference between males being more biologically suitable and females being at a disadvantage? From my perspective, you just contradicted yourself, can you help me understand why it's not a contradiction? This was in response to the parent that said Damore had not singled out any female google employes. The overweight example was an attempt to clarify that even though statistical averages say something about a group, it does not say something about the individual, i.e the google females should not feel singled out by statistical averages. As for the nature/nuture point in the memo: yes the memo is making a biological claim backed by sources. It does not suggest that current distributions are correct. No, the memo is not saying that nature is the primary force, only that it might play a part [1]: "Differences in distributions of traits between men and women may in part explain why we don’t have 50% representation of women in tech and leadership." [1] https://diversitymemo.com/ https://diversitymemo.com/
- endorphone 9y agoFrom my perspective, you just contradicted yourself, can you help me understand why it's not a contradiction? The IQ distribution of men and women is slightly different, and this is essentially settled science (it really is, however much we might pontificate -- our genetic past rolls the dice more with males). The male curve is slightly fatter, yielding larger numbers of exceptionally high and exceptionally low members. This means absolutely nothing if you have a male with an IQ of 140 and a female with an IQ of 140, however. Nor does it mean a 100 IQ male should be working at Google because there are slightly more high IQ males born. We are smart enough to understand the difference between set probabilities and individual traits. Right? because the distribution of women in tech has changed drastically in the last 50 years faster than evolution's say in the matter Obviously there are social factors. That is indisputable. But at a point the gains in leveling the sexes for some domains become harder to get because there are confounding factors. Women in engineering has stayed virtually constant for several decades now.
- dahart 9y ago> The IQ distribution of men and women is slightly different, and this is essentially settled science How different? Can you source this claim? Are the means & medians at different places? How far apart are they? Are they far enough part to justify a male/female ratio in the tech workforce of 4x? I'm not arguing with you, but you are contradicting the article at hand. "the mainstream view is that male and female abilities are the same across the vast majority of domains — I.Q., the ability to do math, etc." > Women in engineering has stayed virtually constant for several decades now. Which decades are you talking about? Which countries are you talking about? Please source this wildly inaccurate claim. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_women_in_engineering#Statistics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_women_in_engineerin... "According to studies by the National Science Foundation, the percentage of BA/BS degrees in engineering awarded to women in the U.S. increased steadily from 0.4 percent in 1966 to a peak of 20.9 percent in 2002" That's a factor of 40x in 40 years. That doesn't sound super constant to me. How fast does evolution work again? "Only 9.6% of engineers in Australia are women" Interesting. Does that mean it's likely that Australian women are biologically only half as engineering capable as American women?