9 ms·
Crafting Plausible Maps (2015)
- seanalltogether 9y ago> Humans (especially pre-industrial, agricultural humans) like to settle near rivers. Apropos of nothing, back during the rush to build the transcontinental railroad, the Union Pacific thought Cheyenne would become the new hub of the west and Denver would turn into a ghost town. But a quick look at a map shows the abundance of rivers and waterways flowing through Denver while Cheyenne has just a small river flowing through. Not even a railroad was enough to overcome the lack of resources around Cheyenne.
- niftich 9y agoThe governor of Colorado and Denver businessmen, including David Moffat, were worried that their city would be eclipsed by Cheyenne, and their own neighbor, the City of Golden, so they raised money to build the 'Denver Pacific' railroad between Cheyenne and Denver. Around the same time, 'Kansas Pacific' built a railroad from Kansas City to Denver, and Denver became a railroad junction in August 1870. Union Pacific's bridge between Council Bluffs and Omaha wasn't completed until March 1872, requiring a ferry trip across the Missouri that was a widely-recognized annoyance [1]. This railroading victory revitalized Denver at a very opportune time. Moffat continued to dedicate his fortunes on continuing a railway directly west across the Rockies from Denver. He died in 1911 with his railroad companies largely bankrupt and incomplete, but in 1928 one of the successor companies opened the Moffat Tunnel, named in his memory, along the right-of-way he laid out. Now, the route from Denver west to Nevada is owned by Union Pacific, despite having been built by competitors to UP's (and CP's) route through Nevada-Ogden-Wyoming. [1] http://www.cprr.org/Museum/Reports/pictures/capture_00309.html http://www.cprr.org/Museum/Reports/pictures/capture_00309.ht...
- logfromblammo 9y agoI wish I could take all that advice back in time and give it to JRR Tolkien. I have lost count of the number of times I have looked at a map of Middle-Earth and thought, "mountains don't do that".
- bbctol 9y agoI just have to assume there are sinister magicks that make mountain ranges at, uh, right angles. http://www.tor.com/2017/08/01/tolkiens-map-and-the-messed-up-mountains-of-middle-earth/ http://www.tor.com/2017/08/01/tolkiens-map-and-the-messed-up...
- gonubalabala 9y agoOne could draw a few lines at right angles on this map as well http://bogost.com/middle-earth.jpg http://bogost.com/middle-earth.jpg
- arethuza 9y agoAmusingly that map places Weathertop fairly close to the Tap O'Noth which is ancient hilltop fortress where the stonework was vitrified (i.e. melted, apparently on purpose). When I was a teenager reading LotR I always imagined that Weathertop was like the Tap O'Noth - it is quite a distinctly shaped hill (having a dirty great ancient fortress on top) and can be seen from a long way away.
- richardknop 9y agoThat can be explained in a fantasy setting though. Arbitrary shapes of mountains can be attributed to ancient magic. Ancient elves and wizards might have been terraforming the geography for some reasons related to history of Middle-Earth. The weird unnatural mountains around Sauron's area of the map might have been built by him using spells to create a "natural" protective wall from elves so he has enough time to forge the ring in secret. If I remember correctly from the books (correct me if I am wrong), there is even a mention in the book about Misty Mountains being "built" by some ancient powerful beings (so that would explain ridiculous geology). The Wall in Game of Thrones is also not natural, it was build using magic an is held together by the same spell that created it.
- quake 9y agoA great deal of the land west of the Misty Mountains was old Beleriand, which was the major battlefield of the War of Wrath between the Valar and Melkor (of which Sauron was merely a lieutenant to). As far as Mordor, I believe that the way those mountains are are as old as Time, since Shelob moved there sometime in the First Age after escaping from Ungoliant (her mother)
- clarkmoody 9y agoHere's a Twitter account that generates interesting procedural maps: https://twitter.com/unchartedatlas https://twitter.com/unchartedatlas
- wonderbear 9y agoThat is amazing. Also now I've learned about NaNoGenMo.
- mastax 9y agoIf you like this, you'll love https://reddit.com/r/worldbuilding https://reddit.com/r/worldbuilding
- wikwocket 9y agohttps://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/ https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/ is also a great community, with great discussions. Part science, part fantasy. People tedn to post long fun answers that remind me of XKCD's What If? series.
- drusepth 9y agoSimilar, and also mightily related to the OP: /r/youfuckeduptherivers [1] has a ton of resources specifically for creating realistic rivers, mountains, settlements, etc. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/youfuckeduptherivers/ https://www.reddit.com/r/youfuckeduptherivers/
- petewailes 9y agoIf you're interested in fantasy maps, I'd recommend https://watabou.itch.io/medieval-fantasy-city-generator https://watabou.itch.io/medieval-fantasy-city-generator as an interesting tool. Also, if you're into tabletop RPGs, I'm going to give a shout out to my own blog - https://wail.es/ https://wail.es/
- hownottowrite 9y ago"Here Dragons Abound"[0] is another interesting take on this topic. The guy's been working for about a year now to beef up Martin O'Leary's work[1]. Fascinating read through if you start at the first post. [0] https://heredragonsabound.blogspot.com https://heredragonsabound.blogspot.com [1] http://mewo2.com/notes/terrain/ http://mewo2.com/notes/terrain/
- serhei 9y agoThe reasoning on this guy's website is often pretty fascinating: http://www.worlddreambank.org/P/PLANETS.HTM http://www.worlddreambank.org/P/PLANETS.HTM -- these are entire fantasy planets. For a warm-up exercise, he started out by tilting the Earth in different ways and working out how that would affect climate and biomes.
- danarmak 9y agoIf you're making a fantasy world (which is not a past or future Earth in disguise), you don't have to stick to plate tectonics and volcanism as they exist on Earth. Geology varies a lot between planets, even in our solar system! That's without even going into whatever makes your world "fantasy". Un-Earthly geology could be plot relevant (The Fifth Season, N. K. Jemisin). Or it could be a bit of colorful background that's still scientifically valid. Maybe you live on a tidally locked moon, or a geologically dead world with a cold core, or an ocean world with an ice crust (not of water necessarily). Maybe the locally important geological phenomena come not from inside the planet (plates, volcanoes) but outside (asteroids, meteors). Maybe your planet's liquid core has currents so strong that islands float around at meters per second and bounce off each other. Fantasy only needs to be consistent with yourself - not with our Earth. Otherwise where's the fun in worldbuilding? Relevant article from the same site: https://mythcreants.com/blog/should-your-fantasy-world-resemble-earth/ https://mythcreants.com/blog/should-your-fantasy-world-resem...
- jmilloy 9y ago> Otherwise where's the fun in worldbuilding. I think it's only fun if you operate within constraints. Choosing Earth-geology is a pretty reasonable constraint that allows you to more quickly get on to other aspects of worldbuilding (the ones that most fantasy worldbuilding focuses on anyways). What you are describing sounds more like science fiction worldbuilding! Plenty of room for overlap and deviation, of course.
- danarmak 9y agoI don't see a reason why playing with geology in particular should be restricted to science fiction and not fantasy. Authors often build geologically inconsistent worlds. The article has suggestions for fixing that by changing the geology to match Earth, but that will force the climate etc. to match Earth too. I think if an author wants to build a world with a geology different from Earth that's not a bad thing - they should just notice this and make sure it's consistent and has an explanation for being the way it is.
- 9y ago
- kibwen 9y agoFun read. This reminds me of Rich Burlew's (of Order Of The Stick) series of articles on designing fantasy worlds: http://www.giantitp.com/articles/xO3dVM8EDKJPlKxmVoG.html http://www.giantitp.com/articles/xO3dVM8EDKJPlKxmVoG.html > And the fractal pattern of rivers is directional: rivers will always merge as they flow toward the coast, never split. Interestingly, it is possible for rivers to split, sort of. Rivers naturally meander, and it is possible for two adjacent rivers to meander such that they intersect each other. Most of the combined flow will end up along the steeper path, true, but that doesn't mean the shallower path will dry up completely. For a real-world example, this is basically the catastrophe that Louisiana's Old River Control Structure has been staving off for decades.
- jcranmer 9y agoRivers can totally form large deltas (dozens, maybe a hundred miles wide for the largest) where the main path of the river is unclear. The Amazon, the Nile, the Rhine, and, of course, the Brahmaputra-Ganges. Outside of deltas, it is possible, although very rare, for rivers to connect to each other and be able to transfer flow bidirectionally. The Casiquiare Canal (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casiquiare_canal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casiquiare_canal) is the largest such example (despite its name, it is a natural river, not man-made). It causes part of the Orinoco River to flow into the Rio Negro and thence the Amazon.
- kibwen 9y agoTo the author's credit, I did omit a footnote that called out deltas as exceptions. But yes, such clear-cut exceptions to the rule are both quite rare and make for fascinating geography--which incidentally make them perfect for fantasy maps! :) What is Middle-Earth without the Lonely Mountain, after all?
- Waterluvian 9y agoI find it funny how "fantasy" is so templated. There's a right and wrong way to make a "fantasy" map. In honesty, I want to explore the bad example at the bottom of the page. I want to know what created those very rigid and artificial looking landforms! The "good" example looks like a generic island.
- Finnucane 9y agoSome (more than a few) years ago I was in the position of reading slush for Tor books. This was back in the day when it was all mailed in on paper. Unsurprisingly, many of the fantasy submissions came with the author's own, generally hand-drawn, map. They varied quite a bit in terms of quality, but were generally recognizable as being in the tradition of what was usually printed in fantasy novels. ("Land of the pointy mountains"). Since they were sometimes disposable copies, I took to keeping the maps in a binder. For all I know, it's still there.
- wonderbear 9y ago> Most mountains are the children of lusty continental plates, birthed from scandalous collisions between landmasses too attracted to each other for their own good. I laughed. That was a fun read.
- maze-le 9y agoDwarf Fortress seems to do a really good job at creating plausible fantasy maps. Mountains are created as blobs near the edges of a continent, without 90° directional changes. Rivers flow from mountain ranges to basins. Vegetation is dependent on the overall climate of a region. Settlements are created according to race-specific traits (dwarfs in the mountains, humans at rivers, elves in forests). Volcanoes are an exception, as the seem to be randomly dotted all over the map. All in all, Zach, the Dwarf Fortress creator seems to have put some thought into the (game-wise) mundane task of world-creation.
- QuantumYeti 9y agoTarn Adams has a pretty interesting talk about procedural myth generation (starts at about 9:00): http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1023372/Practices-in-Procedural http://www.gdcvault.com/play/1023372/Practices-in-Procedural
- shanusmagnus 9y agoThere used to be software called Mojoworld that would allow you to do this, using scientific modeling of various things (geology, botany, climate stuff, etc.) to make the generation realistic: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MojoWorld_Generator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MojoWorld_Generator It hasn't existed for a long time, which is sad. Anyone know good (or even not so good) alternatives?
- trynewideas 9y agoFree or open-source: Tectonics.js: http://davidson16807.github.io/tectonics.js/ http://davidson16807.github.io/tectonics.js/ Torben's Planet Map Generator: http://topps.diku.dk/torbenm/maps.msp http://topps.diku.dk/torbenm/maps.msp donjon World Generators: https://donjon.bin.sh/scifi/world/ https://donjon.bin.sh/scifi/world/, https://donjon.bin.sh/fantasy/world/ https://donjon.bin.sh/fantasy/world/ VPPlanetGenerator: https://toolslib.net/downloads/viewdownload/73-vpplanetgenerator/ https://toolslib.net/downloads/viewdownload/73-vpplanetgener... TerraJ: http://terraj.sourceforge.net/ http://terraj.sourceforge.net/ Wilbur: http://www.fracterra.com/wilbur.html http://www.fracterra.com/wilbur.html Platec: https://sourceforge.net/projects/platec/ https://sourceforge.net/projects/platec/ - Commercial/paid: Experilous Worldbuilder ($8): https://experilous.com/1/store/offer/worldbuilder https://experilous.com/1/store/offer/worldbuilder (previously linked to on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8681899 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8681899 ) Space Engine: http://spaceengine.org/ http://spaceengine.org/ - Theory, code, and links: Red Blob Games: http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~amitp/game-programming/polygon-map-generation/ http://www-cs-students.stanford.edu/~amitp/game-programming/..., http://www.redblobgames.com/x/1728-elevation-control/ http://www.redblobgames.com/x/1728-elevation-control/ (previously on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14793809 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14793809 ) Procedural Content Generation Wiki: http://pcg.wikidot.com/pcg-algorithm:map-generation http://pcg.wikidot.com/pcg-algorithm:map-generation
- panglott 9y agoThe single best resource for fantasy cartographers is the Cartographer's Guild forum. https://cartographersguild.com https://cartographersguild.com Mark Rosenfelder's site is an amazing rabbithole of world-building. http://www.zompist.com/howto2.htm http://www.zompist.com/howto2.htm http://www.zompist.com/virtuver.htm http://www.zompist.com/virtuver.htm He's also written The Language Construction Kit and The Planet Construction Kit. There's some great Google Plus communities around fantasy cartography, like Map-Making in Games https://plus.google.com/communities/105897774940532146183 https://plus.google.com/communities/105897774940532146183
- danschumann 9y agoOshkosh was built because of the lumber industry (they would fill up Lake Winnebago, which has access to Lake Michigan via the Fox River). I think cities scale to the number of natural resources near them, and synergies as well.
- chippy 9y agoIf you want to actually create you own fictional map you can checkout what I consider my favourite geospatial project of all time: OpenGeoFiction http://opengeofiction.net/ http://opengeofiction.net/ Imagine an OpenStreetMap (it actually uses the same stack) where you can create your own fictional land - and where you can potentially interact with other people's creations too. From their FAQ: " OpenGeofiction (OGF) is based on the OpenStreetMap software platform, which means that all map editors and other tools suitable for OpenStreetMap can be used to build OGF's fictional world. This world is set in modern times, so it doesn't have orcs or elves, but rather power plants, motorways and housing projects. But also picturesque old towns, beautiful national parks and lonely beaches. Different users view OGF in different ways. For some, it's an exciting creative adventure, a challenging construction puzzle, or an epic tapestry of interwoven stories. For others, it's a relaxing meditation, an immersion in imagination, or perhaps the largest piece of artwork ever created — equal in size to the Earth itself. " edits - It's not that immediately easy to find the good mapping - http://opengeofiction.net/#map=11/36.4055/119.2868 http://opengeofiction.net/#map=11/36.4055/119.2868 or http://opengeofiction.net/#map=15/1.6975/42.5115 http://opengeofiction.net/#map=15/1.6975/42.5115 is one example, and I find http://opengeofiction.net/history http://opengeofiction.net/history could be useful to see where people are working on.
- trynewideas 9y agoNot a similar project, but also on the geodata front, someone converted and georeferenced the canon maps for the Pathfinder campaign setting into Shapefiles and KML: http://dungeonetics.com/golarion-geography/index.html http://dungeonetics.com/golarion-geography/index.html And someone else used that data with Leaflet to make a tiled map and a globe: http://oznogon.com/golarion-tile/#6/35.642/0.000 http://oznogon.com/golarion-tile/#6/35.642/0.000
- DanAndersen 9y agoFascinating! This makes me wonder: has anyone tried using machine learning to generate satellite views of a fictional map like this? It seems like something that could be done -- because we have both the ground truth satellite data from Earth, and also a good representation of Earth's roads/map data from OSM, one should be able to infer, given an input OSM map (and some other data like lat/lon or proximity to coastlines), what a plausible satellite image would look like for that map.
- elcapitan 9y agoReminds me of this great GDC talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVGonAUUQ8c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVGonAUUQ8c (which is more about plausible game worlds in general).
- trynewideas 9y agoAlso check out Jonathan Roberts, the artist of (among other fantasy maps) the official map folio for the Lands of Ice and Fire/Game of Thrones. His blog is full of both granular and general advice: http://www.fantasticmaps.com/ http://www.fantasticmaps.com/ And his article in the Kobold Guide to Worldbuilding is my go-to reference for using cartography as a worldbuilding device: https://www.amazon.com/Kobold-Guide-Worldbuilding-Wolfgang-Baur/dp/1936781115 https://www.amazon.com/Kobold-Guide-Worldbuilding-Wolfgang-B...
- rurounijones 9y agoAll of my fantasy maps start with drawing the Giant Star Turtle
- tripletmass 9y agoAn ADnD 3.5 world (or its lusty +7 tectonic plates) should attempt to ascend independently of life on it. Developmental SEMATEMS-oriented maps should emphasize multithreaded geocrust processes focused on quarterly/annual reporting that makes sense to owners of spherical viewing apparatus, and that makes rewards in a twisty maze of lunch spots (subject to crafting schema.)
- sjezewski 9y agoThis reminds me of the odd property that bends in a river are separated by about 6 times the width of a river. And this seems to happen pretty often in nature. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alluvial_river#Meander_wavelength https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alluvial_river#Meander_wavelen... Way back in school they'd issue this in the form of a question to undergrads just to see how they'd model it / try and answer. I'm not sure if it's understood why the number is '6'