7 ms·
He never criticizes the right. Quote me a single argument from the document that criticizes the right, at all. I've given a dozen quotes criticizing or ridicu
by kuschku 9y ago
He never criticizes the right.
Quote me a single argument from the document that criticizes the right, at all.
I've given a dozen quotes criticizing or ridiculing the left from the memo.
> That is dishonest and so incredibly transparent that I wonder why you bother. Even if your goal were to discredit him with your dishonesty, it should be obvious that you won't achieve your goal, only damaging yourself in the process.
It's dishonest of you to claim he has a position when he only criticizes one side, and always defends and supports the other.
- mpweiher 9y agoFrom the section I quoted in the very comment your responded to: "A company too far to the right may be slow to react, overly hierarchical, and untrusting of others." Just above that he has a table of "left biases" and "right biases", and both are equal in length. But yes, as a centrist who thinks that Google has too many left biases, he criticizes those left biases more. Which is something else that he states explicitly: "Only facts and reason can shed light on these biases, but when it comes to diversity and inclusion, Google’s left bias has created a politically correct monoculture that maintains its hold by shaming dissenters into silence. This silence removes any checks against encroaching extremist and authoritarian policies. For the rest of this document, I’ll concentrate on the extreme stance that all differences in outcome are due to differential treatment and the authoritarian element that’s required to actually discriminate to create equal representation."
- kuschku 9y agoGoogle has basically no left biases. Most of the biases he mentions are authoritarian ones, which are on an entirely different axis. Many people can't visualize this concept, so we can take the political compass as a helpful tool: https://www.politicalcompass.org/images/us2016.png https://www.politicalcompass.org/images/us2016.png
- mpweiher 9y agoSo you disagree with his analysis. That's OK. I think you're wrong, but reasonably people can disagree. What's not OK is simply dismissing and ignoring his analysis, treating it as if it didn't exist, and then misinterpreting the rest based on that. I'll try to illustrate it for you: I say "I love books so much that I have my entire apartment covered in bookshelves, with books three levels deep and it's still not enough, books are littering the floor so I can't walk and can't clean up any longer. I think I need to get rid of some books". So say you disagree with the first part. Say even that you are correct, that I had made some fundamental mistake and there were actually bookshelves I hadn't considered and if I only cleaned up and used them I wouldn't need to get rid of any books. Is it then OK to just remove that first part, only cite "I think I need to get rid of some books" and then conclude that I must hate books because I want to get rid of them? I think not. (And no, he didn't argue that he wanted to get rid of anyone, just to clip that potential willful misinterpretation)
- kuschku 9y agoThis is not a disagreement on analysis, but on axioms. One of the axioms of free society is one of fairness and equality. Any argument that suggests a treatment should be applied to group X, but not to group Y, is therefore automatically invalid. Any argument that suggests that a group should be treated differently because of a group tendency is automatically invalid. Anyone who disagrees with this disagrees with the most fundamental axioms of modern society. Yes, I realize there is an ongoing revolution happening of people that feel that this axiom is wrong, and they should get an advantage over other groups, but I disagree with that fundamentally. This is an axiom held even higher than the constitutional rights any country grants, as all those derive from this axiom. The reason so many people are angered by actions of both the left and the right is that they feel that this axiom is being attacked.
- mpweiher 9y ago> Any argument that suggests a treatment should be applied to group X, but not to group Y, is therefore automatically invalid. Exactly. So you are 100% in agreement with James. >Anyone who disagrees with this disagrees with the most fundamental axioms of modern society. Yes, I realize there is an ongoing revolution happening of people that feel that this axiom is wrong, and they should get an advantage over other groups, but I disagree with that fundamentally. Again, that is exactly what James is saying, and I have quoted him a number of times now whereas you have not provided a single instance of him saying the opposite. If you think he is not saying that, then what we have is disagreement in analysis. On a more meta level, you seem to think that because you profess adherence the correct beliefs, the right "Axioms", you are freed from the burdens of proper analysis. I remember that very vividly from my classes at Uni in Germany, for example an essay writing class where a significant number of my fellow students thought that they would be graded on the "correctness" of the opinion they had penned, rather than the quality of the essay. So they handed in essays that were absolutely embarrassing. "Gesinnungsästhetik" I would suggest the following exercise for you: take an opinion you absolutely disagree with. Then write an essay supporting that idea. Make it as good as you can. Then write another one tearing it up. Then another one tearing that one up.
- dragonwriter 9y agoBeing able to list potential problems with being too far to either political extreme doesn't make you a centrist. Someone to the left of the center of the left, or the right of the center of the right, much less either side of the overall center, can easily do that. You can be pretty far out and still see the guy two steps farther out as dangerously deluded.
- mpweiher 9y agoSure. He could be a raving lunatic right wing whacko for all we know. But that's not in his document, and not in his interviews.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> But that's not in his document Neither is anything that would support him being described as a “centrist”.
- mpweiher 9y agoTo repeat the quote from the top of the thread: "Neither side is 100% correct and both viewpoints are necessary for a functioning society or, in this case, company. A company too far to the right may be slow to react, overly hierarchical, and untrusting of others. In contrast, a company too far to the left will constantly be changing (deprecating much loved services), over diversify its interests (ignoring or being ashamed of its core business), and overly trust its employees and competitors." This is exactly a centrist position. Now you can reasonably argue that on balance the document isn't centrist. I think you're wrong, but reasonable people can disagree. That there isn't anything in there that would support a description of centrism is trivially false.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIts not centrist position, unless "centrist" is so broad as to include every position not at the farthest extreme of either the left or right, as anyone not at a far polar extreme could agree with it.