6 ms·
Is it me or is the elephant in the room like "get paid to put pirated movies, games, music, software on the network" Obviously, no one is going to admit it bec
by sharemywin 9y ago
Is it me or is the elephant in the room like "get paid to put pirated movies, games, music, software on the network"
Obviously, no one is going to admit it because then your network is tainted but every file sharing outfit ultimately ends up do pirated.
I've been mining lbry and it seems lot more ahead of these others.
https://lbry.io/ https://lbry.io/
- onli 9y agoYou can't create a business out of pirated content (anymore). You can maybe create such a network, but not gain money or stay out of prison. Filecoin to my knowledge has or will have no capabilities of sharing files. It's dumb end-to-end encrypted decentral storage (which is a good thing!).
- sharemywin 9y agoso you have file storage and a currency. you need a dao to manage the index/search.
- onli 9y agodao=data access object? You can't implement indexing and search over end to end encrypted data file chunks. You would have to work with the hash of complete files and a localizer, and you want that in the initial design.
- sharemywin 9y agoDistributed org creates account rents massive file store builds index and use contracts to enforce rental fees.
- mpfundstein 9y agoThats auper nice
- tylersmith 9y agoFor OpenBazaar, built on IPFS, we've gone the route of federated search with an open API. A DAO could be interesting but a lot more work for little gain. Eventually I'd like to open source code that lets any user create their own index/search server and potentially charge for usage if they want.
- rmorey 9y agoFilecoin is being built on top of IPFS (ipfs.io) which, in principle, could be used as a really robust network for sharing pirated content. However, the IPFS team is aware of this problem, and is building in measures to allow nodes to opt out of storing globally available blacklists of known bad objects (i.e. pirated content or illegal content) In practice, this is definitely a really hard problem to solve, and very important. But I think doable.
- opportune 9y agoIf you're hosting something such as a movie, and it's blacklisted, couldn't you just add a small amount of noise to the video file to make it unblacklistable?
- knicholes 9y agoI guess that depends on how things are being blacklisted.
- azinman2 9y agoExactly. YouTube has the same problem and does all kinds of things to detect this. They have the benefit of already having the media on all their own storage which they can run a map-reduce on, however.
- scottLobster 9y agoFor now, but this sounds like a problem machine learning was built to solve. Youtube has issues because with the sheer volume of video they don't have the silicon to transcode/examine every frame, but on a more limited network with less traffic such analysis might be doable. The more "variations" people introduce in response, the larger the training set for the algorithm.
- opportune 9y agoYes, this is an adversarial machine learning problem. I highly doubt those kind of measures would be implemented by file coin though, considering the cost of scanning files for such at scale. I'm sure, at least in the short term, it will likely be some time of hash or edit distance measure (or an equally naive and easy to fool approach).
- acjohnson55 9y agoSo basically, Pied Piper plus a coin?
- mpfundstein 9y agoAnd without compression. And precisely what sia and storj do
- wcummings 9y agoIt's not, the real business model here probably looks a lot like rapidshare.
- tylersmith 9y agoIt's more about enabling applications with decentralized data storage than it is a new type of object storage.
- aw3c2 9y agoThe https://lbry.io/faq/what-is-lbry https://lbry.io/faq/what-is-lbry is just as empty buzzword bingo as the Filecoin docs.
- hosh 9y agoWe're building the basic building blocks of autonomous software. If Ethereum is universal compute, Filecoin will provide the storage backing for it. The beneficiary will be AIs, not humans. Right now, we're just now thinking of clouds, containers, and "serverless" (functions-as-a-service). If we take those ideas and iterate them forward, we converge closer to a real "serverless" paradigm -- what Ethereum already provides today in principle, if not at scale. This will require storage that can keep up with it, and that is where FileCoin comes in. While human consumers may benefit from this, it enables autonomous software that can live on its own and manage its own matabolism (resources accounted for through the blockchain). What those autonomous software will do? I don't really know.
- wmf 9y agoAFAIK the uploader has to pay in this type of system; it's basically just S3 but cheaper and "decentralized". You can upload pirated content to a public S3 bucket if you want and I don't think AWS really cares because they're getting paid and they are covered by the DMCA safe harbor.
- int_19h 9y agoIf the society is collectively willing to pay for storage mostly to host pirated content, that tells you a lot about what the real (rather than publicly expressed) social consensus is wrt piracy.
- mpfundstein 9y agoLast time i checked my local usenet, it was alive and thriving