6 ms·
EDIT: I'll just post a bunch of quotes from the memo, and let you judge if that sounds left-wing. > the Left tends to deny science concerning biological differ
by kuschku 9y ago
EDIT: I'll just post a bunch of quotes from the memo, and let you judge if that sounds left-wing.
> the Left tends to deny science concerning biological differences between people (e.g., IQ and sex differences)
> Stop alienating conservatives: Viewpoint diversity is arguably the most important type of diversity and political orientation is one of the most fundamental and significant ways in which people view things differently.
> conservatives tend to be higher in conscientiousness, which is require for much of the drudgery and maintenance work characteristic of a mature company.
> I would start by breaking down Googlegeist scores by political orientation
> Google’s left bias has created a politically correct monoculture
> which makes it clear why it’s a phenomenon of the Left and a tool of authoritarians
> Considering that the overwhelming majority of the social sciences, media, and Google lean left, we should critically examine these prejudices
> Google’s left leaning
- leifaffles 9y agoNo he doesn't. Please read the memo.
- kuschku 9y agoYes he does. He argues that political diversity is most important > Viewpoint diversity is arguably the most important type of diversity and political orientation is one of the most fundamental and significant ways in which people view things differently. and that Google should change its hiring practices to improve this, instead of ethnical or national diversity. And he makes up more pseudo-scientific arguments for why Google should hire more conservatives: > conservatives tend to be higher in conscientiousness, which is require for much of the drudgery and maintenance work characteristic of a mature company. In the context of his memo - where he states that Google is too far left-wing - the recommended changes are obvious: Hire more conservative. He also recommends to track the political affiliation of all existing employees to track the diversity gap there: > I would start by breaking down Googlegeist scores by political orientation This is the same kind of affirmative action that he criticizes just a few paragraphs before.
- WatchDog 9y agoIs it affirmative action if they are hiring with the belief that they the hiring decision they are making will best improve the performance of the company? If you have evidence that diversity has a positive impact on company performance and you have two candidates who other otherwise exact equals except one is a woman/conservative. Is it affirmative action to choose the under represented option? I don't think it's affirmative action rather its just good business sense. I consider affirmative action to be the hiring of a group who is perceived to be discriminated against, simply because of that discrimination.
- kuschku 9y agoWe could look at the legal definition of affirmative action that German courts considered illegal: Affirmative Action, or illegal discrimination, is given when a company bases its hiring decisions in any way on anything but the employees merit. If age/gender/race/political beliefs/religious beliefs/etc have any influence on the hiring decision, it is illegal discrimination. And he argues similarly, that affirmative action in any way is bad, and Google shouldn't do it - then he argues again that Google should do it, but only for the benefit of conservatives.
- mpweiher 9y agoLet's compare what he writes to the German definition: "treat people as individuals, not as just another member of their group" Check. "Stop restricting programs and classes to certain genders or races." Check. "[Our programs] can easily backfire since they incentivize illegal discrimination." Check. So he is 100% on-board with the German definition. Google's existing programs, OTOH, are not. They would be illegal in Germany if the definition you've given is correct. The only thing I can find in his "Suggestions" for the "benefit" of conservatives is the following: "Stop alienating conservatives" "We should empower those with different ideologies to be able to express themselves." Wow, stop alienating a group of people and allow them to speak. That's just horrific. Off with his head!
- pyroinferno 9y ago
- DarkKomunalec 9y agoI was able to find no such suggestion. Perhaps you can point it out? Here's the full text of the memo: https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/3914586/Googles-Ideological-Echo-Chamber.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/3914586/Googles-I... It starts with "I value diversity and inclusion, am not denying that sexism exists, and don’t endorse using stereotypes.", and has many suggestions on how to increase diversity (not just viewpoint diversity), all ideas attributed to the left†. †I feel compelled to mention I find that left/right are woefully inadequate labels, and serve better as a tool to divide and conquer people so they don't unite on common interests. But they work well-ish enough in this case, and a discussion on this would be long and orthogonal to the topic at hand. Edit: Reading your other reply, it seems you think any action at all done to increase diversity is affirmative action. That's not what's usually meant by the term.
- kuschku 9y agoRead the comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14988905 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14988905 I quote several paragraphs from the memo where he argues specifically for that.
- mpweiher 9y agoHe has a very specifically and explicitly centrist position: "Neither side is 100% correct and both viewpoints are necessary for a functioning society or, in this case, company. A company too far to the right may be slow to react, overly hierarchical, and untrusting of others. In contrast, a company too far to the left will constantly be changing (deprecating much loved services), over diversify its interests (ignoring or being ashamed of its core business), and overly trust its employees and competitors." When he, in a centrist document, puts up arguments for and against both side, you only selectively quote the ones for the right and against the left. That is dishonest and so incredibly transparent that I wonder why you bother. Even if your goal were to discredit him with your dishonesty, it should be obvious that you won't achieve your goal, only damaging yourself in the process. [EDIT: I don't know his personal political views, so edited to say that the document is centrist]