10 ms·
Based on your post I went and looked up that question/answer portion, and I think the back and forth is illuminating in it's lack of either communication or act
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
Based on your post I went and looked up that question/answer portion, and I think the back and forth is illuminating in it's lack of either communication or actual capability:
TL;DR: It's a solution in search of a problem, like so much good, early technology.
Dalton Caldwell [31:07] – What is the burning, and it’s okay if it’s not consumers, but what is the thing that, with Filecoin, that is gonna make, whether it’s business or consumers, people get really excited about using it?
Juan Benet [31:19] – Filecoin is not representative of the entire industry. Filecoin is one example. With Filecoin, the point is being able to, this is a whole different argument that I think makes sense with or without a peer-to-peer winter or summer. The thoughts around Filecoin are about thinking about the massive latent storage that’s out there and putting it to good use. There’s exabytes of storage that are not in use right now, and that if you were to add them to the market, you would drive the price down significantly......That’s, I think, fundamentally different about this type of thing than normal consumer products. They solve a lotta problems for a lotta people.
Dalton Caldwell [33:41] – You said financial, though. Again, they’re doing it for financial reasons. Again, what I’m looking for is what is the incentive for someone to get involved, whether it’s a business or a consumer, the reason you would put a miner on the network?
Juan Benet [33:53] – For Filecoin specifically, the reason why somebody would add storage to the network, the primary motivator will be money....
- onli 9y agoThat's a bit convoluted, but it isn't so bad, is it? Lots of unused storage, bitcoin showed you can use cryptocurrency to create a network of capabilities (there: hashing stuff, here: of storage), additional uses are possible when getting the mechanism right.
- beaconstudios 9y agoI don't see how a new blockchain is necessary in order to utilise unused storage space. Protocols like this work just fine without them, especially if having a centralised orchestrator (filecoin themselves) isn't an issue. Which in this case, I can't see why it would be.
- jtmarmon 9y agoI think the idea is the blockchain part allows people to be compensated at a price determined by the market for opening up their storage
- onli 9y agoOnly that you do not need a blockchain for that. All you need is a market place, and that works perfectly fine without a blockchain. It's a needless complication imho.
- beaconstudios 9y agoexactly my point. Market dynamics existed long before blockchains.
- onli 9y agoBut maybe we both miss a thing here. Maybe this is less about file storage and market place, but more about having an alternative way to mine cryptocurrency, which has its own value as long as speculation is ongoing. Well, maybe that's a bit obvious given the hype around the IPO. That would mean filecoin is less about the use of decentral file storage, but more about giving people a different way to create something that looks like bitcoin that does not involve buying sold-out gpus, unlike ethereum, and storing files is more comfortable than having a gpu make noise all the time anyway.
- beaconstudios 9y agoso it's yet another way for people to play pretend-stock-market but using a different model of wasting computational resources? That's about what I expect from cryptocoins at this point.
- onli 9y agoNot really wasting in this case. There is at least that.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI don't think it's good or bad, but it shows that there isn't a slam dunk product-market fit here and they are searching for what the value is. I think by the way, that's absolutely vital to progress, and I am glad someone has convinced VC/Money to fund something potentially breakthrough (whether I think it is or not).
- sharemywin 9y agoIs it me or is the elephant in the room like "get paid to put pirated movies, games, music, software on the network" Obviously, no one is going to admit it because then your network is tainted but every file sharing outfit ultimately ends up do pirated. I've been mining lbry and it seems lot more ahead of these others. https://lbry.io/ https://lbry.io/
- onli 9y agoYou can't create a business out of pirated content (anymore). You can maybe create such a network, but not gain money or stay out of prison. Filecoin to my knowledge has or will have no capabilities of sharing files. It's dumb end-to-end encrypted decentral storage (which is a good thing!).
- sharemywin 9y agoso you have file storage and a currency. you need a dao to manage the index/search.
- onli 9y agodao=data access object? You can't implement indexing and search over end to end encrypted data file chunks. You would have to work with the hash of complete files and a localizer, and you want that in the initial design.
- sharemywin 9y agoDistributed org creates account rents massive file store builds index and use contracts to enforce rental fees.
- mpfundstein 9y agoThats auper nice
- tylersmith 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mbesto 9y ago> It's a solution in search of a problem, like so much good, early technology. Care to elaborate and share examples of other "good, earl technology"? Typically when I hear "solution in search of a problem", I start thinking "this is going nowhere".
- pfarrell 9y agoGoogle Wave comes to mind. Great tech, but marketed to the wrong group (developers) and didn't solve any problems I had at the time.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoPretty much any technology you use now was a solution in need of a problem. PDAs and Touchscreen tablets are the most fitting examples.
- mbesto 9y agoSorry, maybe I didn't get your original point - I thought you were insinuating that ICO was a technology in search a problem and that all super successful (i.e. good) technologies starts this way (which I would disagree).
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI thought you were insinuating that ICO was a technology in search a problem and that all super successful technologies starts this way. Not insinuating, that's my claim - nearly every big technology was too early (eg. a solution looking for a problem - whether in form or scale) before it blew up years or decades later. I don't think that's controversial. It's also true that a lot of trash that never makes it are also solutions in search of problems.
- mbesto 9y agoI think you're confusing their adoption curve with a problem they solve. For example - PDA's certainly solved a problem (having a mobile/digital calendar), they just didn't solve enough problems when they were introduced.
- loceng 9y agoThere's so much unused storage because it's so cheap and people have the money to buy it and not use it. If you add another profit layer of people looking to make money, that simply increases costs.