3 ms·
WIRED's take: https://www.wired.com/story/google-manifesto-author-just-might-have-a-legal-case/ https://www.wired.com/story/google-manifesto-author-just-mig...
by danso 9y ago
WIRED's take: https://www.wired.com/story/google-manifesto-author-just-might-have-a-legal-case/ https://www.wired.com/story/google-manifesto-author-just-mig...
> The labor-relations law usually applies to union organizing, says Wagner. But over the years the act has been more broadly interpreted to protect employees who discuss their working conditions with each other. That might include Damore's memo, Wagner says.
> Damore says he also plans to invoke a California law that bars employers from retaliating against workers who complain about illegal working conditions. He doesn't have to prove that his working conditions were illegal, Wagner says. Instead, she says Damore's lawyer might argue that his memo was protected under California law, because it related to allegedly unequal treatment of employees.
Citing a law that was put in place to protect union organizers seemed weird, but I guess it makes sense if there is precedent for interpreting it in speech not explicitly related to union organizing.
Arguing that Google retaliated because he made allegations about unethical/illegal corporate behavior seems like a much stronger case, since he literally did make those claims in the memo.
- zimpenfish 9y agoIt sounds like he might already have made a filing with the NLRB well before he was fired (going off the first 5 minutes of his interview with Molyneux) - that might bolster his case for anti-retaliation (depending on their response, I guess - if they sent it straight back with "LOL" on page 1, it'll probably hurt his case instead.)
- richmarr 9y ago(Not a lawyer) I would have thought Google would be able to argue other causes. Damore said Google policies "lower[ed] the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate" That statement is (a) factually inaccurate, you can't lower the bar by descreasing the false negative rate, and (b) slanders his colleagues hired through that policy by saying the bar had been lowered to allow them in. You could argue that the word "effectively" means he actually meant something slightly different in point (a), but he still made the claim in point(b).
- imron 9y ago> That statement is (a) factually inaccurate, In fact, depending on the circumstances, it's mathematically accurate. See for example, my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14987168 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14987168 In the original memo, that statement also linked to an internal Google discussion to back up his claim - which presumably detailed what he meant. That's context that we are all missing. It would be interesting to see what that discussion was about. > (b) slanders his colleagues hired through that policy by saying the bar had been lowered to allow them in. No he didn't. He talked about reducing false negatives, not increasing false positives.
- richmarr 9y ago> No he didn't. He talked about reducing false negatives, not increasing false positives. It seems we have a different interpretation of "lowering the bar"
- imron 9y agoYou're leaving off half the sentence. I'm interested to hear your interpretation of how 'decreasing the false negative rate' plays in to this. If he had said 'hiring practices which lower the bar for “diversity” candidates', then I would agree with your interpretation. But he didn't say that, he said 'hiring practices which can effectively lower the bar for “diversity” candidates by decreasing the false negative rate'. It's an inaccurate interpretation of his comments to leave off the last half of that sentence, and I'm not sure what other way you can interpret 'by decreasing the false negative rate'.
- richmarr 9y agoTo reply to your linked comment: The "bar" is an approximated objective assessment of ability, not an assessment of someone's ability percentile... as demonstrated by the fact that Google policy hires 'people that pass' rather than 'top x% of candidates' or 'top y% of the population according to some measure' To reframe the "bar" as being a percentile is inaccurate and excuses Damore's misleading and inflammatory terminology.