2 ms·
> Do you think that diversity programs necessarily result in lower quality candidates filling some roles, Not all diversity programs, ... > even if the progra
by yorwba 9y ago
> Do you think that diversity programs necessarily result in lower quality candidates filling some roles,
Not all diversity programs, ...
> even if the program only forces a quota into the interview process?
... but if the "program" only amounts to setting a minimum quota, without any concrete plan for action on achieving the quota.
Say you believe the proportion of women in programming, given a fair hiring process, would be at least 30%, so you set that as a minimum quota all your interviewers have to fulfill. If you are right about the average, by pure randomness some interviewers will make their quota easily. But what about those who are unlucky and don't have enough qualified candidates to choose from? They will have to lower their standards to make the quota.
Fixed limits are just too blunt, they focus on the results a fair process would achieve, but fail to enforce that they actually come about due to a fair process.
> Do you think that's a bad thing, that it has tangible negative outcomes for businesses?
It depends on the concrete program in question and how much it misfires (or not), but the negative outcomes for the business will probably be relatively small. They might have to spend more money on training and get a higher turnover of employees, but Google is probably more selective than they have to, so they can afford to hire some slightly less qualified candidates.
> How do you propose to address the issues around this stuff,
I'm partial to blinded tests and outreach programs, since the combination can address both hiring bias and lack of interest.
> or is diversity something you don't think is worth having?
I think in terms of business value, gender diversity is overrated (as opposed to diversity of thought). Nonetheless, discrimination and harassment don't just affect aggregates like diversity, they also hurt individuals, so I think fighting them is important.