4 ms·
> I have not yet made a decision about how to respond to James Damore's memo about diversity at Google. I am going to wait for the outrage to subside, for the
by danso 9y ago
> I have not yet made a decision about how to respond to James Damore's memo about diversity at Google. I am going to wait for the outrage to subside, for the various members of the Twitter mob to lay down their metaphorical pitchforks and return to their homes...And this little bit of extra time will allow for hurt feelings and outrage to subside, and that will in turn allow us all to approach the issue with cooler heads and sounder judgment.
That last part in particular seems patronizing. It implies that people who wanted Damore to be punished did/could not reach that conclusion if they had exercised rational thinking and reasonable judgment. So the OP seems to be begging the question here, because the memo he believes Google's CEO should have written is the kind of memo the CEO would write if he thought the anti-Damore crowd to be irrational and over-emotional.
- flukus 9y ago> It implies that people who wanted Damore to be punished did/could not reach that conclusion if they had exercised rational thinking and reasonable judgment. If one thing has become painfully obvious it's that most people calling for his head did not read the memo at all (the evidence is in this thread). Others only read it after the media had framed it how they want. Others misinterpreted it, possibly intentionally. Others still think he deserved to be fired because he CC'd it to the whole company. That is not acting in a calm and rational manner.
- danso 9y agoOn what empirical basis is it "painfully obvious", without using circular reasoning or omniscient mind-reading, that the people who support Damore did read and properly interpret his memo, and did so without being irrationally affected by preconditioned biases about the state or importance of workplace diversity? More importantly, why should we assume the Google folks at which "the buck stops" made their punitive decision out of the same hysteria that purportedly infects the anti-Damore crowd? Correlation does not equal causation.
- yorwba 9y agoIt also painfully obvious that most people who support Damore also didn't read and properly interpret the memo. This is all the more reason to not fire him during the ongoing shouting match. It signals that an outraged mob can force Google to terminate an employee, even if this isn't what happened and Google just calmly evaluated their options.
- flukus 9y ago> On what empirical basis is it "painfully obvious", without using circular reasoning or omniscient mind-reading, that the people who support Damore did read and properly interpret his memo, and did so without being irrationally affected by preconditioned biases about the state or importance of workplace diversity? I never said they did, but they aren't calling for anyone's head either. > More importantly, why should we assume the Google folks at which "the buck stops" made their punitive decision out of the same hysteria that purportedly infects the anti-Damore crowd? Because their statements indicate that, here is what Sundar Pichai wrote: > “To suggest a group of our colleagues have traits that make them less biologically suited to that work is offensive and not OK.” The memo does not contain any such suggestion, so the CEO either didn't read it or read his own (or someone elses) interpretations into it.
- yorwba 9y ago> I never said they did, but they aren't calling for anyone's head either. https://basicgestalt.wordpress.com/2017/08/06/press-f-for-james-damore-the-only-set-of-balls-left-at-google/ https://basicgestalt.wordpress.com/2017/08/06/press-f-for-ja... does seem to try very hard to get a meme going that displays Danielle Brown as pure evil. > The memo does not contain any such suggestion, so the CEO either didn't read it or read his own (or someone elses) interpretations into it. Actually, it does. Women on average are more prone to anxiety Make tech and leadership less stressful. Google already partly does this with its many stress reduction courses and benefits. which suggests that women are less able to handle stressful jobs. Of course Damore's suggestion is to make jobs at Google less stressful, but if someone wants to feel outraged at that, they absolutely can.
- aslkdjaslkdj 9y agoDo you assume that the people who disagree with the memo don't have the capacity or will to read through a mere 10 pages? How patronizing can you be?
- flukus 9y ago> Do you assume that the people who disagree with the memo don't have the capacity or will to read through a mere 10 pages? No, I assume that people making completely unfounded claims about the contents of the memo (we've seen them in every single thread about it) have not read the memo.
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y agoThe point is, many people - even here, on HN - didn't read the full memo themselves. Instead, many of them depend on summaries from journalists (or, should I say, clickabiters), grossly representing the original document. Honestly, when you read articles like "Shocking quotes from the anti-diversity manifesto", I perfectly understand why some people decide they have absolutely no intention to read the whole thing. And I'm not sure the blame is completely on them.
- yorwba 9y ago> It implies that people who wanted Damore to be punished did/could not reach that conclusion if they had exercised rational thinking and reasonable judgment. Maybe it just means that they wouldn't have jumped directly to "punching Nazis", name-calling and other forms of uncivil discourse. There is a wide gulf between disagreeing with someone, thinking they violated the Code of Code and deserve to be fired, and openly calling for violence. I think disengaging the immediate emotional response to the (real and perceived) implications of the memo would have shifted the response more to the former end of the spectrum.
- danso 9y agoSo what about the people who think that Damore was out of line, that firing him was an acceptable response, but that Damore shouldn't be punched nor lynched (digitally or physically)?
- yorwba 9y agoI'm sure they could have waited a while for him to be fired.
- AstralStorm 9y agoThe stupid question is: why should he be fired by pointing out authoritarianism in "diversity" practices? (The quotes do not mean sarcasm, but the practices are probably misnamed. Minority preferentialism?) Isn't this essentially saying that groups get privileged by being perceived as minority, as opposed to majority, making it the flip side of the same originally problematic practice? And the most important part is actually about treating people as individuals not statistics. And if using statistics, do not use a general statistic where a specific one should be used. (Which is some fancy named logical fallacy.) What's more firing that guy means actually leaning into his argument that dissent is silenced. While his opinion is apparently unpopular at least with media, that is not a good argument. If everyone got fired for doing something unpopular we'd have something worse - fanaticism combined with hypocrisy.