4 ms·
It's really a testament to nature and Darwin's theories that after all the time, effort and money we've been spending on AIDS research, the most successful anti
by sliverstorm 16y ago
It's really a testament to nature and Darwin's theories that after all the time, effort and money we've been spending on AIDS research, the most successful antibody so far was not created by man, but by his DNA.
- bkudria 16y agoBut it was created by a man! Seriously: Is the distinction that relevant?
- hugh3 16y agoWell, on one hand, the antibody would have been created whether or not we'd been spending all this money on research. On the other hand, the antibody would never have been noticed if we hadn't been spending all this money on research.
- sliverstorm 16y ago> On the other hand, the antibody would never have been noticed if we hadn't been spending all this money on research. Indeed. But, even though he is a homosexual man, the gene would likely be passed along eventually, and run its course through the human race (if we believe Darwin). We just don't want to wait that long. note: it would be passed one of a few ways: 1) his ancestors also had the gene, and he's not the only one to get it. He has heterosexual relatives who will pass it along, and they simply weren't found for one reason or another. 2) he wavers in his homosexuality, and passes his gene along to a few women OR he is bisexual 3) he donates sperm 4) it happens again in a heterosexual person. This gene arose in something like 30-40 years (I'm not really sure just how many) since the beginning of AIDS, which is an evolutionary blink. I think it's not unreasonable to figure it would arise again, and that it wouldn't take a bajillion years
- earl 16y agoI don't think the gene arose in 40 years. Obviously it didn't, since the man is more than 40 years old. Instead, I think it's a gene that arose via happenstance and is suddenly much more useful.
- sliverstorm 16y agoYou... you are a shrewd man. (or woman). Still, the fact that it was already floating around I feel proves my point even more. If the disease ravaged us for hundreds of centuries before this cropped up, THEN it'd be pretty reasonable to say it's highly unlikely to develop again anytime soon.
- MikeCapone 16y agoThis antibody, however it was created, will now be a good starting point for tweaking and improvement. Hopefully, it can be made to be effective against 100% (or as close as possible) of the HIV variants.
- stcredzero 16y agoThe Nazgul would think so.
- gcheong 16y agoI think we're making good progress when you look at how long we've been at it vs. how long nature has. I mean we at least knew where to look for the solution!
- aphyr 16y agoI Am Not An Immunologist, but antibodies are usually produced by plasma cells, after their predecessor B cells are triggered with the appropriate antigens, right? I'm pretty sure that mechanism and its memory is acquired, not innate. In other words, it's not coded for by DNA, and you can't inherit that immunity from the father. Some maternal antibodies are heritable, but I think that's through shared blood.
- bhickey 16y agoFor 'Not An Immunologist' you seem to have a pretty good handle on this stuff. You're mostly right about the heritability stuff, but it's a bit more subtle than that. Antibodies are built from heavy and light chains, which are in turn produced by a combinatorial recombination process: subunits get spliced together. While paternal B cells aren't going anywhere with regards to heritability, the heavy/light chain subunit repertoire is heritable! If Donor 45 is a mutant for one of those subunits, then the effect could very well be heritable. edit: grammar.
- aphyr 16y agoAre any antibodies entirely genetically determined--"off the rack", so to speak? One would think that having an innate immune response to extraordinarily dangerous yet infrequently-mutating pathogens (polio, for example) would be worthwhile. Haha, maybe I should get go get an immunology text. I think I'm pushing the limits of Wikipedia.
- bhickey 16y agoImmunobiology by Janeway has come highly recommended to me. I still need to pick up a copy.
- carbocation 16y agoYou are partially on the right track. There is an innate response to pathogens exhibiting particular molecular profiles. But this innate recognition is not by antibodies, which are part of the adaptive response. To my knowledge, there is not a repertoire of antibodies that are automatically produced, per se.