9 ms·
I'm dismayed that the very environment we all share somehow got politicized to death. I wonder what would have happened to the Ozone Hole if it too got politici
by pmarreck 9y ago
I'm dismayed that the very environment we all share somehow got politicized to death. I wonder what would have happened to the Ozone Hole if it too got politicized at the time, or the link between smoking and cancer if it got politicized. We trust our doctors; we trust our tech leaders; why don't we trust our scientists and climatologists? (Is this, sort of, Gore's fault, combined with a highly-polarizing media? I have to wonder.)
At this point I have almost no faith that until things get dire enough to cause even the most ignorant layperson to realize there's a serious problem going on, that anything impactful will be done to stop it, and by then it may be too late due to runaway multiplicative effects (such as the thawing of permafrost methane in the Arctic, or the absence of snow cover resulting in less planet-surface reflectivity)
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I wonder what would have happened to the Ozone Hole if it too got politicized at the time, It did, and a large number of people on the Right took attitudes exactly like the Right takes on climate change today. That faction was somewhat weaker within the Right at the time, and the Right somewhat weaker overall, so the political resistance to the science wasn't as successful in preventing federal policy action as it has been in the US on climate change, but the same overall shape of political dispute occurred.
- ckinnan 9y agoAny evidence for your claim? That's not my recollection of the issue. The Reagan Administration implemented the Montreal Protocol to address ozone depletion. It was immediately ratified by the U.S. Senate by a unanimous vote. It's probably the most successful global environmental agreement in history.
- mikeash 9y agoHere's one: https://www.rushlimbaugh.com/daily/2005/08/10/professor_limbaugh_debunks_junk_earth_science2/ https://www.rushlimbaugh.com/daily/2005/08/10/professor_limb... And another: http://www.newsweek.com/ozone-hole-our-heads-194308 http://www.newsweek.com/ozone-hole-our-heads-194308 It precisely matches my recollection, as someone who spent far too long listening to Mr. Limbaugh at the time.
- mobilefriendly 9y agoI dunno, it is hard to argue there was any meaningful political opposition from the Right when Senator Jesse Helms voted for the bill.
- RodericDay 9y ago"People are so polarized... maybe it's Al Gore's fault?" C'mon man. The reason why there's no progress is that destroying the environment makes a lot of people a lot of money. Consumerism lines pockets, not only of manufacturers but also of advertisers like Facebook and Google. Challenging climate change implies challenging capitalism, neoliberalism, and the idea that "free markets" always know best.
- salgernon 9y agoBack around 1980, I remember lots of tv news specials and saturday morning cartoon interruptions with reports about acid rain. Lots of scares about dying fish and melting statues and canada being pissed at the US for spewing stuff into their air. I remember too how it was poo-poo'd by the political establishment of the time and lots of claims that its just the way it is and we're not going to be able to fix it, it would hurt jobs, it would hurt the economy. But regulations were passed, and hard work was done, and we don't really hear much about acid rain (as much!) anymore. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/acid-rains-dirty-legacy/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/acid-rains-dirty-legacy... Science and its-already-gone-too-far not-withstanding, I hope the US in particular will return to sanity and realize that we can make a difference in what is going on, and that doing so raises the quality of life not just for the US but for the entire world. (I've also wondered: with the dismantling of environmental regulations and associated funding of the current administration, we're seeing individual states pick up the gauntlet and fund their own initiatives. Is this some sort of subtle "see, you don't need the feds to intervene when states have the power and ability" ploy? Then they can gut federal regulations and claim their smaller federal government mandate works? The fallacy being that climate doesn't follow state boundaries.)
- ckinnan 9y agoLots of weird half baked recollections today. The U.S. political system moved effectively on acid rain, Congress (not regulators) passed NO2 legislation by a 401-21 vote that was signed by a Republican president. It created a market for pollution that largely solved the issue and is a legislative model for dealing with other pollutants.
- unholythree 9y agoI remember an article not long ago about anti-trust regulation being a victim of it's own success. I think the same is true of many environmental regulations, people vaugely recall an outcry over some environmental concerned and imagine it must have just been overblown since acid rain isn't falling all the time or no canals in their town are currently burning.
- 9y ago
- chasing 9y ago> Is this, sort of, Gore's fault... How in the holy hell would it be Gore's fault? He has tried to be a communicator on this issue for decades. He's "highly polarized" because the great smear machine felt it needed to destroy him for having the temerity to run for President.
- HankB99 9y agoGore is a political figure. He made a convenient target for the "no global warming" crowd. I do not see his actions as political but they were painted that way when "An Inconvenient Truth" came out. I don't see Gore at fault but rather an unintentional result.
- triangleman 9y agoI'll bite. An Inconvenient Truth was so overly political and full of lame folksy rhetoric that it motivated me to investigate the issue further. And now I'm a climate skeptic. I'm sure there are others.
- DiNovi 9y agoyou are a climate skeptic because of a documentary about climate change....? I will forever be amazed at people's ability to blame other people for issues because they raised them. It's amazing.
- purephase 9y agoHow? Could you elaborate on the type of investigation you undertook that led you to become a skeptic? The scientific community is so overwhelmingly on the side of climate change that you'd have to be really selective to see/read it otherwise. The "lame folksy rhetoric" is Gore's way of trying to appeal to the skeptics. The problem with issues like climate change is that they're so large and complex that most people feel powerless to affect change, so they do nothing. An Inconvenient Truth was meant to impart the severity, but also the hope that small changes will make a difference and that, collectively, there's a chance to change course. At the very least, lower our contribution in an effort to change course. Honestly, blaming this on Gore is beyond comprehension. I'm trying to not to be hyperbolic, but this type of knee-jerk reaction and selective bias highlights how this issue is politicized, and will, as evidence suggests, lead to devastation.
- alistproducer2 9y agoI was thinking about the CFC thing the other day. We'd still have that hole there today if it we're for sane politicians willing to do the right thing. I fear we're doomed this time though.
- convolvatron 9y agoits still there, but through reasonable policy that really didn't disrupt the economy much at all, its shrinking
- rsynnott 9y ago> I'm dismayed that the very environment we all share somehow got politicized to death. Largely in the US; the very existence of anthropogenic global warming is not a partisan issue in most of the world. > I wonder what would have happened to the Ozone Hole if it too got politicized at the time It did; there are people who deny it _to this day_, amazingly. > or the link between smoking and cancer It did; tobacco companies lobbied and continue to lobby mightily, and politicians were arguing that tobacco wasn't unsafe for a long time.
- pmarreck 9y ago> and politicians were arguing that tobacco wasn't unsafe for a long time did these politicians suffer any discredit as a result?
- rsynnott 9y agoI don't think so, really. It's surprisingly rare for politicians to face blowback for pushing stuff that later turned out to be obviously terrible. Everyone was pretty much pretending Strom Thurmond wasn't awful right up to his death, say.
- heygrady 9y agoI wonder why? Is the same phenomenon at play with Trump's approval rating? It's been in the high-mid-30s for many weeks now [1]. 80+ consecutive days at the time of this writing. Even outside of Russia-related scandals (like hiring Mike Flynn [3]), he has done some obviously bad things (like the Billy Bush tape [2]). [1] https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/trump-approval-ratings/ https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/trump-approval-ratings/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Trump_and_Billy_Bush_recording https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Trump_and_Billy_Bush_re... [3] http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/features/sally-yates-provided-a-helpful-timeline-of-the-mike-flynn-saga-w481357 http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/features/sally-yates-pr...
- rbg246 9y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20010415085348/http:/mikepence.com/smoke.html https://web.archive.org/web/20010415085348/http:/mikepence.c... Apparently not...
- gvd 9y agoI always have to think about Louis CK's "Indians, White People and God's Earth" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWZkwuILn_s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWZkwuILn_s It's both hilarious and sad at the same time
- snomad 9y ago> why don't we trust our scientists and climatologists? 1) I don't think local news media has helped last few decades. The constant reports of study that say "X" bad, followed by no no "X" is good (all the while both studies were describing tiny results) has led to distrust. 2) Govt funding of stupid studies creates image where researchers are scam artists who provide results by money 3) Lots of research is done by universities. Growing dissatisfaction with university system being projected onto researchers therein. 4) It was always sold wrong. It should have been sold as energy independence (freedom) not a burden (we need to change how we are doing things and limit ourselves).
- mikeash 9y agoI think it's also important to mention 5) decades of political propaganda painting climate science as a political issue, because Republicans found it advantageous to use as a wedge issue. I think just about everyone I've talked to who doesn't believe in climate change arrived at that position from spending lots and lots of time listening to Rush Limbaugh or similar.
- triangleman 9y agoSeriously? This is HN, there are plenty of climate skeptics here, and I would guess that 0-5% of them listen to Rush Limbaugh or similar. Perhaps they are simply people with a scientific mind and came to different conclusions after evaluating the evidence independently?
- polotics 9y agoThe word "simply" sadly does not apply to climate modelling, reaching conclusions simply usually means lots of confirmation bias, and a foregone output. How do you know there are plenty of any opinion on HN?
- DiNovi 9y agoHe's projecting his own skepticism onto others; assuming since he reached his conclusion "many others" must have as well.
- abtinf 9y agoIf you'd like to get a good overview of the case for fossil fuels, check out The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels by Alex Epstein. [1] Here is a video trailer for the book: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vu6637cjk8A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vu6637cjk8A Edit: This interview with Dave Rubin may also be helpful in understanding the other point of view: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJmL9hRrpIQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJmL9hRrpIQ [1] https://www.amazon.com/Moral-Case-Fossil-Fuels/dp/1591847443 https://www.amazon.com/Moral-Case-Fossil-Fuels/dp/1591847443
- polotics 9y agoSorry I am so late, but in case you post links to that nefarious book again, fair warning: https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2016/06/update-of-death-per-terawatt-hour-by.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2016/06/update-of-death-per-te...
- afarrell 9y agoPart of the problem is that it is hard to convince people that 2 degrees farenheight difference would be all that bad. A lot of the talk is around keeping change "under 2 degrees" and a lot of the opposition is in the US. Nobody in the US has an intuition for what a change of 2 degrees celcius feels like.
- Sangermaine 9y agoPlease don't paint all of us with the idiot brush. It's not "opposition in the US", it's opposition from one party in the US. We were ready and willing, and had started under Obama, to combat climate change. It's the Republicans who have made opposition to even acknowledging climate change an article of their faith.
- afarrell 9y ago> Please don't paint all of us with the idiot brush I'm not. I grew up in the US and lived there for 26 years. How is it idiocy to lack an intuitive sense for a unit of measurement that you don't ever use?
- DanBC 9y ago> We trust our doctors; Very many people, even on HN, do not trust doctors. There's a bunch of anti-vax bollocks on HN, and any thread about doctoring includes people saying they can't wait until all doctors are replaced with AI because doctors don't know anything. Everything's ridiculously polarised. :-/
- 23443463453 9y agoThat is a false analogy and also rather symptomatic of the toxic discussion that, ironically, we have the leftists, the primitivists, and the the scientists to thank for, who have allowed themselves to be pulled into the fanatic company of religion like zealot. I used to be on board with the climate change, branded global warming back then, bandwagon. I started actually thinking and looking at things myself though and started realizing that there were massive conflicts and unanswered questions and manipulated interpretations that made all sorts of flags and alarm bells go off in my mind. I am a scientist at heart and in mind, which very little scientists these days seem to be. I say that because most of today's scientists are very much driven by funding and political motivations that saturate and imbue them with biases and even go so far as to totally corrupt their investigations, especially in today's social climate. Do you really think that today, in a world where proto-religious environment zealots will try to destroy your career and life, you are willing to come out publicly as countering or even just questioning inconsistencies, inaccuracies, let alone policies? We see it every day where the peasant mob is whipped up against anyone that even asks legitimate questions about inconsistencies. We are in dangerous territory when science cannot be questioned, the very nature of science it to question held assumptions and beliefs and results. The fact that a lot of research outputs simply cannot even be reproduced in many different disciplines, including climatology, does not bode well for the confidence a rational and reasonable person can put in these results. Let's also be clear about what the consequences of these results are. Some say "worst case we will have moved to renewable energy" or some similar line. The reality though is that it would coast trillions upon trillions of dollars that would be squandered for nothing if this is all just nonsense. It is not at all well established or conclusive that the warming is caused by humans and not just a process that has been going on for hundreds of thousands of years at the tail end of the ice age that used to essentially cover the whole European and North American continent. You exhibit the very kind of ignorance you are immediately accusing others of expressing, but reality is simply that if you want to find the truth, you have to follow the money. When the careers and incomes of scientists and institutions heavily depends on gaining research funding based on the very biased notion that climate change is man made, there is an inherent and fundamentally corrupting incentive at play that will cause self-selection of scientists and researchers and institutions that seek to confirm the results that their funders are looking for. No funded scientific career is shorter than the one that results in non-results. There is simply no money to be made in saying "nope, we don't see any significant impact of man's contribution to climate change". Today you would even be flogged in the streets for saying so. This is all part of what is seemingly a mass mental health disaster where confirmation bias abounds and is even apparently self-perpetuating at this point. As with all these points that divide society, I don't see those pushing for the massive impact and cost of ill conceived interventions to control people's lives making any kinds of efforts to abide by their own decrees. Where are the leftist, primitivist, Liberals that don't fly in planes, live in tiny houses, don't own a car, don't eat out, don't use technology or the internet, etc. Computers and technology and the internet is a massive energy sink and causes massive environmental impact, yet here we are with people demanding intervention while they jet around on planes trying to impose their own authoritarian view on others and demanding things like importing people from low environmental impact societies that have not earned or contributed anything to supposed high environmental impact societies that we have everything to thank for creating.
- 23443463453 9y agoThat is a false analogy and also rather symptomatic of the toxic discussion that, ironically, we have the leftists, the primitivists, and the the scientists to thank for, who have allowed themselves to be pulled into the fanatic company of religion like zealotry. I used to be on board with the climate change, branded global warming back then, bandwagon. I started actually thinking and looking at things myself though and started realizing that there were massive conflicts and unanswered questions and manipulated interpretations that made all sorts of flags and alarm bells go off in my mind. I am a scientist at heart and in mind, which very little scientists these days seem to be. I say that because most of today's scientists are very much driven by funding and political motivations that saturate and imbue them with biases and even go so far as to totally corrupt their investigations, especially in today's social climate. Do you really think that today, in a world where proto-religious environment zealots will try to destroy your career and life, you are willing to come out publicly as countering or even just questioning inconsistencies, inaccuracies, let alone policies? We see it every day where the peasant mob is whipped up against anyone that even asks legitimate questions about inconsistencies. We are in dangerous territory when science cannot be questioned, the very nature of science it to question held assumptions and beliefs and results. The fact that a lot of research outputs simply cannot even be reproduced in many different disciplines, including climatology, does not bode well for the confidence a rational and reasonable person can put in these results. Let's also be clear about what the consequences of these results are. Some say "worst case we will have moved to renewable energy" or some similar line. The reality though is that it would coast trillions upon trillions of dollars that would be squandered for nothing if this is all just nonsense. It is not at all well established or conclusive that the warming is caused by humans and not just a process that has been going on for hundreds of thousands of years at the tail end of the ice age that used to essentially cover the whole European and North American continent. You exhibit the very kind of ignorance you are immediately accusing others of expressing, but reality is simply that if you want to find the truth, you have to follow the money. When the careers and incomes of scientists and institutions heavily depends on gaining research funding based on the very biased notion that climate change is man made, there is an inherent and fundamentally corrupting incentive at play that will cause self-selection of scientists and researchers and institutions that seek to confirm the results that their funders are looking for. No funded scientific career is shorter than the one that results in non-results. There is simply no money to be made in saying "nope, we don't see any significant impact of man's contribution to climate change". Today you would even be flogged in the streets for saying so. This is all part of what is seemingly a mass mental health disaster where confirmation bias abounds and is even apparently self-perpetuating at this point. As with all these points that divide society, I don't see those pushing for the massive impact and cost of ill conceived interventions to control people's lives making any kinds of efforts to abide by their own decrees. Where are the leftist, primitivist, Liberals that don't fly in planes, live in tiny houses, don't own a car, don't eat out, don't use technology or the internet, etc. Computers and technology and the internet is a massive energy sink and causes massive environmental impact, yet here we are with people demanding intervention while they jet around on planes trying to impose their own authoritarian view on others and demanding things like importing people from low environmental impact societies that have not earned or contributed anything to supposed high environmental impact societies that we have everything to thank for creating.
- DiNovi 9y ago>> I wonder what would have happened to the Ozone Hole if it too got politicized at the time, or the link between smoking and cancer if it got politicized. I can't tell if you are being cute because both of those things were very much politicized.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoAction on CFCs and ozone depletion was a lot easier with a lot less economic/industrial impact. Work on CO2 emissions is much more difficult and much more costly. It also is more of a direct challenge to the implicit value assumptions of a huge group of people (that humans have "dominion" over the Earth, and it is theirs to subject rather than theirs to responsibly steward). It's an instance of the "boomerang effect" writ large.
- neuronexmachina 9y agoThere actually were some political attempts by DuPont to stop the Montreal Protocol's anti-CFC measures, but they weren't successful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Protocol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Montreal_Protocol > Also in 1985, 20 nations, including most of the major CFC producers, signed the Vienna Convention, which established a framework for negotiating international regulations on ozone-depleting substances. After the discovery of the ozone hole it only took 18 months to reach a binding agreement in Montreal. But the CFC industry did not give up that easily. As late as 1986, the Alliance for Responsible CFC Policy (an association representing the CFC industry founded by DuPont) was still arguing that the science was too uncertain to justify any action. In 1987, DuPont testified before the US Congress that "We believe there is no imminent crisis that demands unilateral regulation."[21] And even in March 1988, Du Pont Chair Richard E. Heckert would write in a letter to the United States Senate, "we will not produce a product unless it can be made, used, handled and disposed of safely and consistent with appropriate safety, health and environmental quality criteria. At the moment, scientific evidence does not point to the need for dramatic CFC emission reductions. There is no available measure of the contribution of CFCs to any observed ozone change..."
- Sangermaine 9y ago>why don't we trust our scientists and climatologists? "We" do. It's a faction of conservatives in the US who either don't or find it politically useful not to. Unfortunately they're currently in charge. Obama had started to move the US towards working on the problem, but that's hit a wall now. >(Is this, sort of, Gore's fault, combined with a highly-polarizing media? I have to wonder.) This is madness. Gore didn't politicize the issue, the right did by gearing up their ideology media machine to skewer him as part of its anti-climate change crusade.
- tzs 9y ago> I wonder what would have happened to the Ozone Hole if it too got politicized at the time, or the link between smoking and cancer if it got politicized. People have tried to politicize the smoking links. Mike Pence in 2001: pence> Despite the hysteria from the political class and the media, smoking doesn't kill. In fact, 2 out of every three smokers does not die from a smoking related illness and 9 out of ten smokers do not contract lung cancer. This is not to say that smoking is good for you.... news flash: smoking is not good for you. If you are reading this article through the blue haze of cigarette smoke you should quit. The relevant question is, what is more harmful to the nation, second hand smoke or back handed big government disguised in do-gooder healthcare rhetoric. Source: http://web.archive.org/web/20010415085348/http://mikepence.com/smoke.html http://web.archive.org/web/20010415085348/http://mikepence.c...
- abawany 9y agoYep, as recently as 2016, a certain candidate lamented that CFCs were not responsible for the ozone hole: http://www.factcheck.org/2016/05/trump-on-hairspray-and-ozone/ http://www.factcheck.org/2016/05/trump-on-hairspray-and-ozon... .
- gator-io 9y agoI think some of it is that most of the proposed solutions involve social and economic pain. It is easier to deny this problem than accept higher taxes or a lower standard of living for most people. That's human self-interest at work. A renewable that is cheaper than coal is really the only thing that is going to work.
- netsharc 9y agoRegarding your second paragraph, a joke I saw recently is "We won't act until it's too late. Luckily, it's too late now!". The last 2 summers have had heatwaves that killed Indians, Europe just had a big one the last few weeks. Meanwhile, German automakers were caught in a conspiracy about diesel. Their government actually argued to keep lax testing methods a few years ago (https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/sep/24/uk-france-and-germany-lobbied-for-flawed-car-emissions-tests-documents-reveal https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/sep/24/uk-franc...)!