6 ms·
When I worked at IBM I expressed concern that the television commercials depicting a HAL9000 level interactive dialog system were dangerously overselling what W
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
When I worked at IBM I expressed concern that the television commercials depicting a HAL9000 level interactive dialog system were dangerously overselling what Watson could do.
The challenge, as I saw it, was that no matter how good the tools and products that were used to help companies with data analysis to improve their operations were, when they realize they can't talk to a cube and joke with it about misusing colloquial phrases their disappointment overshadows all the 'good' stuff it was doing for them.
No relationship works well if it starts with a lie and as this article shows, people do take those ads at face value and assume there really is a talking AI inside of IBM. Then they are hugely disappointed when they find out it doesn't exist.
- ethbro 9y agoOver-promising has killed AI progress before (expert systems). So history's just repeating itself. People want to believe. They'll pay for their belief. Then when projects start to fail (~5 years after commercialization) they form the opinion that it was never going to work and they'll never do it again. ... then we wait another decade, repeat.
- olewhalehunter 9y agoThere's this trend of Expert Systems being commented on as a failure and starting some sort of AI winter, yet to my knowledge they were among the first commercially viable digital animation tools, the first high speed trading platforms, and are still being used successfully in military planning. Where's the evidence that they were a failure or that they were oversold?
- sgt101 9y agoWell, there was this place called "The Turing Institute" which was in Glasgow. It was run by a very nice man called Don Michie. I met Don a handful of times, and he was extremely kind and generous to me. He worked at Bletchley Park and died aged 91 having hit a bridge at 120mph going the wrong way up the M11 at 2am sitting next to his wife who had defected to Russia thirty years before. Don was driving, at the time he had been blind for six months. Anyway, The Turing Institute existed because of Don's drive to commercialise Expert Systems. Don was a driver in the Alvey project which was a grand project to solve issues around Expert Systems in response to the Japanese Fifth Generation project. A man called Lighthill then rumbled the Expert System movement. If you want to watch a demolition of it see the following video : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yReDbeY7ZMU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yReDbeY7ZMU and the other 5 of them (you will find them in the sidebar!) Fun fact. In video 6 you can watch Christopher Strachey have a pop at AI. Christopher didn't work at Bletchley, he was too young, but he did work at Manchester with Alan Turing and they created computer music and love poetry in collaboration before Turing killed himself. Strachey went on to be the first Professor of Computer Science at Oxford, he was a scion of a great family of artists and poets. But enough of this. The Turing Institute was an attempt to say "we are right, look", but in fact it failed. Don was clear why, when you hit 40k rules knowledge bases became completely intractable. It was impossible to make improvements or changes. This was christened the Knowledge Acquisition bottleneck, and Don and others turned to Machine Learning (he liked to call it Behavioral Cloning) to solve it. So : 1. It was done to death by peer review. 2. It died commercially. 3. It's main protagonists decided to do something diffferent.
- taneq 9y ago> I met Don a handful of times, and he was extremely kind and generous to me. He worked at Bletchley Park and died aged 91 having hit a bridge at 120mph going the wrong way up the M11 at 2am sitting next to his wife who had defected to Russia thirty years before. Don was driving, at the time he had been blind for six months. Wow, what a rollercoaster of a paragraph! Thanks for the story. :)
- yvhhjbb 9y agoClearly that's his way of saying something dodgy happened. Note the mention of Russia.
- mlvljr 9y agoWhat's wrong with Russia, green characters? :)
- nl 9y agoNo, I think the poster is mis-remembering things which were based on facts. Donald Michie did work (with Turing!) at Bletchley Park, and he did die in a motor vehicle accident. He was 83 when he died (not 91)[1]. His ex-wife[2] (they had remained friends) was in the car with him and also died. She had never defected to Russia, but she was (or had been) a member of the communist party[2]. [1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obituaries/1556846/Professor-Donald-Michie.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obituaries/1556846/Professor... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne_McLaren https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anne_McLaren
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- icc97 9y agoThat's eerily similar to how John Nash died [0] [0]: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/john-f-nash-jr-dies-nobel-laureate-was-subject-of-a-beautiful-mind/2015/05/24/61463418-0219-11e5-bc72-f3e16bf50bb6_story.html?utm_term=.ebbf273931ce https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/john-f-nash-jr-dies-... > ... died May 23 in a two-car accident on the New Jersey Turnpike. He was 86. His wife, Alicia, who was 82, also died.
- ethbro 9y agoDon't think you deserve to be down voted for asking a reasonable question. A) Most of the documentation is on the other side of the digital event horizon (so pre-1995). B) I break apart knowledge about AI (that is, the mathematical and systems discoveries) and AI as a product. The assertion is not that the knowledge failed, but that the product failed. As you pointed out, the math behind expert systems was solid and functional for certain problems. But the collapse of the product (aided by the popular science press researcher-hunting for whoever would promise the most outlandish things for them) broke the funding channel for anything labelled AI. As a result, methods used by expert systems lived on and solved problems, but nobody could call it AI because conventional wisdom knew that "AI was a failure."
- kobeya 9y agoAnd also the wealth of venture capital that existed in the 1980's to fund AI dried up and from ~90 to ten years ago it was nearly impossible to get significant startup funding for an AI play, despite the epic influx of capital in the 90's. AI missed out entirely on the dotcom years.
- ghaff 9y agoOne of the big things that eventually changed was data--the availability of lots of data and the capability to transmit, store, and process it relatively economically. As I remember a lot of the late-80s, early-90s AI efforts, there was a lot of focus on encoding the world and the rules associated with it manually. Effectively, scaling out the knowledge of experts by embedding it in computers. I actually wonder if we're swinging too far in the opposite direction of data vs. "understanding" the world. It may turn out that we can make some things pretty good using ML but not the last 5% needed to make them truly usable.
- yourapostasy 9y ago> I actually wonder if we're swinging too far in the opposite direction of data vs. "understanding" the world. It may turn out that we can make some things pretty good using ML but not the last 5% needed to make them truly usable. Interesting hypothesis, care to expand your thoughts? Are you saying something along the lines that our current ML techniques builds an initial raw decision with statistically-based reasoning, that usually works 95% of the time (Metzinger's "sentience"), but to solve the remaining 5% of edge cases, we need to build more reasoning-style decision-making (Metzinger's "intelligence")? Metzinger is covered by Peter Watts [1], jump to the "Sentience/Intelligence" section. [1] http://www.rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm#Notes http://www.rifters.com/real/Blindsight.htm#Notes
- throwaway7645 9y agoJust like the "Lisp AI Winter" when the defense department stopped spending big on AI in the 80's.
- protomyth 9y agoWasn’t that the same type of conflict that doomed the Newton? The engineers didn’t want marketing to talk about the handwriting recognition (nice extra, look what other things we do) but marketing ignored them. The Newton never recovered.
- Angostura 9y agoThe engineers didn't want marketing to talk about the primary method of data entry and one of the most superficially innovative thing about it? I can only imagine the look on marketing's face when they heard that one.
- protomyth 9y agoIt wouldn't have been the primary. The Newton had an on screen keyboard like products today. Innovation is only innovation if it works, and the Newton had a lot of amazing things going on, some of which the iPhone doesn't even attempt. The emphasis on handwriting recognition killed the product (along with a healthy does of hatred from Steve Jobs).
- Angostura 9y agoIt really didn't kill the product - Jobs did. Yes, the Newton OS had some great stuff in it - I loved the soup model, but in terms of a newspaper or billboard ad? The handwriting was a no-brainer. Yes it was mocked - in much the same way that Siri is mocked today, but with small adjustyto your native handwriting written input became fast Nd accurate
- protomyth 9y agoIt was mocked before on national tv when national tv was still a thing. It killed any hope for that product. It was mocked on tv, comics, and everyone who did a review. Heck, the Simpsons mocked it long after. It had plenty of billboard quality features (the intelligent stuff was practically built for ads) much more than its simpler, limited competition.
- erdle 9y agoThe funny thing about that ... is that IBM's long time ad agency is Ogilvy & Mather. It was founded by David Ogilvy. One of his big things was "nothing kills a bad product faster than great advertising"... he would be so ashamed of these ads.
- thinnerlizzy 9y agoI worked there for a time and can tell you that many of the creatives I worked with assumed that if Watson won Jeopardy, then it could do literally anything (indeed talking to you like a human), so a lot of the creative concepts were pretty far fetched.
- JimsWonderWorld 9y agoI'm still there :-( I was amazed and I could hardly wait to integrate this incredible service into my apps I was writing at the time. Then I took a look into the services and realized that they were too primitive to build any type of AI. How did watson win Jeopardy? The world may never know....<cough>fraud</cough>
- pryelluw 9y agoI do think it was positioned wrong. Which is amazing given how clear their actual positioning was. Big data and ML are big business opportunities. IBM's marketing just jumped the shark and could lose a lot of market share due to it.
- raverbashing 9y agoNot a surprising position coming from IBM