4 ms·
> He explicitely did not say (nor mean) that a woman can't be a good software engineer. > Just that on average, more men than women will show the features need
by zimpenfish 9y ago
> He explicitely did not say (nor mean) that a woman can't be a good software engineer.
> Just that on average, more men than women will show the features needed for software engineers.
Read those two sentences you wrote again. You'll be shocked when you see it.
- throwaway257157 9y agoI'm not seeing it. Help me out? It's not a contradiction, if that's what you're implying. Have you ever taken a statistics class?
- zimpenfish 9y agoOh, throwaway257157, if I thought you were posting in good faith, I'd certainly engage with you but using a newly created account means you aren't.
- anon_d 9y agoThey are publically defending an argument that got someone fired, so using a throwaway account is totally reasonable here.
- jshevek 9y agoNo. Assuming someone is posting in bad faith for this reason is an act of bad faith. Your statement reveals hypocrisy.
- zimpenfish 9y agoA throwaway account created specifically to post one comment is a sign of bad faith. It's entirely possible that I am wrong but the lack of subsequent engagement suggests otherwise.
- jshevek 9y ago"using a newly created account means you aren't." This is wrong. Using a newly created account does not mean the communicator is approaching this in bad faith. That's a complete non sequitor. "lack of subsequent engagement suggests otherwise." Not at all. There are numerous reason they might not engage further within this time frame - or ever.
- zimpenfish 9y ago> Using a newly created account does not mean [...] bad faith Specifically to post one (1) comment strongly implies it though. You disagree, fine; we'll agree to differ on this.
- hhhsdfnn888 9y agoWow you post a seemingly legit email address and other details, then act like a douche. Personally, I don't want to be signed up for spam, or have it found in some AshleyMadison like leak. I don't care about fake points. I don't care about community rep. So I don't curate an online persona. But you know what, zimpenfish, you're right. The first conclusion that crosses the mind if zimpenfish is of course the right answer.
- depressedpanda 9y agoThe point the throwaway raises is valid, though. Where is the contradiction?
- zimpenfish 9y agoIf you can't see it already, I doubt anything I could say to you would help that.
- depressedpanda 9y agoWhat I see is that you don't understand statistics. And, rather than offer a snide comment, I will try to show you why. Here are the two statements you quoted: > He explicitely did not say (nor mean) that a woman can't be a good software engineer. > Just that on average, more men than women will show the features needed for software engineers. Rephrased: a) a woman can be a good software engineer b) on average, more men possess the skill set required for a software engineer There is no contradiction between a) and b) whatsoever, since a) is about an individual and b) is about average features of different groups. Of course, one may argue about the veracity of either a) or b). But, regardless of their factual accuracy, you did not make the point you think you did.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jcims 9y agoI took the liberty of labeling one of the diagrams in the document with two points labeled A and B. How would you interpret the relationship of these points if A was a man and B was a woman? http://imgur.com/a/kWyTi http://imgur.com/a/kWyTi
- zimpenfish 9y agoI would definitely agree that A was to the left of B. I would also concede that B is to the right of A. But since the only label on the graph is an unidentified "Trait", I couldn't really comment any further. What point are you trying to make?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThat the value on the y axis, for those two points taken from presented distributions, is the fucking same... It's hard to make that point even more obvious.
- jshevek 9y agoIt's pretty clear from the totality of this person's comments that they are here to obfuscate and troll. Not sure why this is allowed on HN.
- zimpenfish 9y agoWould you care to revise your statement given https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14981300 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14981300 ?
- depressedpanda 9y agoWhat? It's a normal distribution graph. The height of the curve denotes how many of a particular group (group is denoted by the blue and green curves) score with regard to some trait x. The y-values for A and B on the graph are irrelevant.