9 ms·
A pilot explains turbulence
- eric_h 9y agoPersonally, I love turbulence. I'm thoroughly disappointed when the pilot announces they'll be changing altitude to avoid it. It's literally the most interesting thing that can happen while flying.
- lisper 9y agoYou have an, um, interesting definition of "interesting".
- marvin 9y agoWell, you have people flying aerobatics for fun, which provide much greater negative G forces than quite extreme turbulence. It's just a matter of personal preference; turbulence is completely harmless if you're strapped in reasonably tight :)
- lisper 9y agoI'm actually one of those people who (occasionally) flies aerobatics for fun. It's a lot more fun if you can see out the front, which you typically can't in a commercial airliner.
- schoen 9y agoI remember a conversation where a group of people considered whether we like turbulence or roller coasters. We managed to find represented all four combinations of liking neither, liking one but not the other, or liking both. I don't like turbulence, but I became more comfortable with it by listening to the "From the Flight Deck" on channel 9 of United's in-flight entertainment (with live ATC audio). Unfortunately, I don't fly United that much anymore and it also appears that this is offered on fewer flights over time. But it was quite comforting to hear the pilot talking to an ARTCC about the turbulence we were experiencing, especially to learn that it was only "light chop" and the captain saw no need to change routes.
- sixothree 9y agoI like fun, tall, fast, soaring roller coasters. I hate jerky, upending coasters.
- elygre 9y agoI flew from New York to London once, listening in to the ATC channel. Lots of fun. We passed Newfoundland, things got quiet. Then one aircraft came on line, saying "we are at such position and height, it's a bit bumpy, anyone got any advice?". Somebody answered that they were 10 minutes ahead, bumpy, too. Somebody said they were 2000 feet higher, very bumpy. The radio chatter died away with a final pilot saying the only thing to do was to "strap'em up and ride it through". Me? I spent the next few hours preparing for turbulence that never arrived.
- bonzini 9y agoTwo airplanes flying the North Atlantic Tracks [1] can be hundred of miles away. While you can adjust your altitude, you cannot move from one "lane" to another. [1] https://youtube.com/watch?v=-aQ2E0mlRQI https://youtube.com/watch?v=-aQ2E0mlRQI
- yardie 9y agoThere is nothing humorous about being thrown against the cabin ceiling and breaking your back, or neck, or getting a concussion. Do you equally enjoy being thrown from the 5th floor of a building? That temporary loss of gravity is almost exactly what a plane experiences in mild to severe turbulence.
- dahart 9y agoI am so jealous! I hate turbulence, and I can't even explain why. I have a USPA C license - I've flown in enough rickety planes to get certified to skydive into public venues - and turbulence still causes my blood to boil. You would love this: one time I flew from Chicago to Ithaca on a small commuter plane, and the pilot told us it'd be bumpy due to area storms. It got pretty bumpy, and the girl sitting next to me was a lot worse off than I was, I didn't know her but she grabbed my hand and was squeezing so hard it hurt. Maybe ten minutes into one of the turbulent spells, the cockpit door flew open and the pilot and co-pilot were going "YEE-HAW" and doing the rodeo rope. My chin hit the floor, and so did everyone else's when we all realized they'd been hitting the roughest parts of the storms they could find on purpose.
- chrischen 9y agoHilarious but sounds mildly illegal.
- eric_h 9y agoFairly certain it wasn't even remotely illegal before 9/11/2001, after which it probably did become pretty illegal (for the opening of the cockpit door).
- dahart 9y agoIt'd be pretty hard to ever prove anything, it's not like they can really go hundreds of miles off the flight path. In my case, the cockpit door opened completely on accident, or at least because of what the pilots were doing, the turbulence is what bumped the door open. Now that the doors are locked, it wouldn't happen again. They blushed and shut it as quickly as they could, and later offered an apology that didn't openly admit to doing it intentionally, but reading between the lines was as close as they could go. It wasn't particularly enjoyable at that moment, but it is really funny, and I'm glad it happened.
- WalterBright 9y agoA friend of mine was on a flight that hit turbulence and suddenly dropped a few hundred feet. People were basically panicky until some texan towards the front waved his hat in the air yelling "yee-haw", which sucked all the tension out of the air.
- adrr 9y agoMaybe a little bit turbulence. I had a flight from LA to SEA that they couldn't serve drinks on the whole flight and the overhead bins kept opening up.
- WalterBright 9y agoI was on a cruise ship once where they announced they were changing course to avoid a storm (not a hurricane by any stretch). I was pretty disappointed. :-)
- eric_h 9y agoThat's another experience I'd love to live, open ocean storm, giant waves. Unfortunately I can't seem to come up with a way of doing it that doesn't statistically shorten my life expectancy considerably (unlike turbulence in an airplane ;)
- willyt 9y agoThis is why they do that https://youtu.be/jup-5Xu1OOU https://youtu.be/jup-5Xu1OOU
- PopsiclePete 9y agoYes, I love having someone who's 270lbs fall into my lap while I'm holding a drink. What's not to love about that. Or smelling vomit or listening to a hysterical woman screaming or a child crying. Sounds awesome.
- eric_h 9y agoYes, my enjoyment is entirely conditional upon not being immediately in the company of people who don't enjoy it all, like most other activities.
- LoSboccacc 9y agoAm not worried about mid flight turbolence having flown myself I kinda know it all works, but we had strong guts on approach to Dublin once and that was extremely stressful
- ddoran 9y agoPatrick Smith, the author and eponymous "pilot" in the title, has been writing interesting articles about flying and a pilot's life for years. He is as much a traveler as he is a pilot and loves what he does. If you have any interest in flying or travel but have somehow not come across Patrick Smith before, check out his archive [1] and his book [2] Pilot Confidential, an update of his earlier book, Ask The Pilot, named for his now-defunct column at Salon.com iirc. [1] http://www.askthepilot.com/archives/ http://www.askthepilot.com/archives/ [2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16235130-cockpit-confidential https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16235130-cockpit-confide...
- huhtenberg 9y agoAnd here's the exact source of the businessinsider.com article - http://www.askthepilot.com/questionanswers/turbulence/ http://www.askthepilot.com/questionanswers/turbulence/
- ethomson 9y agoI can't recommend Patrick Smith's writing highly enough. I used to be somewhat uncomfortable when flying: the lack of control was extremely unsettling. But after reading Ask the Pilot for a while, I came to understand and respect the role of the pilot. I would also strongly recommend his books, _Ask The Pilot_ and _Cockpit Confidential_ for anybody who travels (and especially for nervous fliers). Now I fly quite regularly, and love it.
- anarchitect 9y agoSame experience here. The day after finishing Cockpit Confidential I experienced my first go-around landing in bad weather. I wasn't nervous because I had some idea why it occurred and what was happening in the cockpit.
- sleavey 9y agoI also find the Aviation StackExchange site [1] interesting. The weekly newsletter [2] contains just enough interesting stuff for a mildly interested occasional flier like myself. [1] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/ https://aviation.stackexchange.com/ [2] https://stackexchange.com/newsletters/newsletter?site=aviation.stackexchange.com https://stackexchange.com/newsletters/newsletter?site=aviati...
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoHere's one of the best pictures illustrating the wake of an aircraft in flight I've seen: https://s00.yaplakal.com/pics/pics_original/7/3/7/4872737.jpg https://s00.yaplakal.com/pics/pics_original/7/3/7/4872737.jp...
- 0xfeba 9y agoLooks like a Tu-95 bear or variant.
- BuffaloBagel 9y agoSometimes you eat the bear, and sometimes the bear eats you.
- 4ad 9y agoAnother fun fact, 99% of what people consider bad turbulence is less bumpy than the average bus ride. It's just that being in the air messes with the subjective importance people assign to turbulence.
- dahart 9y agoThis. I know it, and you're right, flying makes it feel worse. It helps me a little when I'm in flight turbulence to close my eyes and pretend I'm in a bus on a dirt road. But I can't figure out how to ignore it or just feel calm and rational, like I want to.
- WalterBright 9y agoIt's well known that gripping the armrests provides lift to the airplane - the tighter the grip, the more lift. So next time you experience turbulence, you know what to do!
- idlewords 9y agoThis is a common belief, but it's not correct. You have to both grip and pull upwards, otherwise the net lift is zero and you will die.
- tritium 9y agoIt gets even more complicated. If the plane suffers and inversion, as during barrel rolls and loops, you have to coordinate pushes and pulls with the orientation of the plane. Otherwise, the maneuver may suffer a distortion and fail to recove properly!
- acjohnson55 9y agoI hear it works better if you soil yourself. It helps smooth out the boundary layer.
- markdown 9y agoAm I on reddit?
- Animats 9y agoIf he could explain turbulence, that would be good for a Nobel Prize.
- ridgeguy 9y agoYep. Supposedly, Heisenberg thought the explanation of turbulence worthy of putting the question to God. And didn't expect an answer to be forthcoming. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbulence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbulence
- bfrog 9y agoI've been on a smaller jet where on approach to O'Hare, banking left over the lake, we must've hit a aircraft vortex. We went from maybe 20-30deg bank to something close to 80 in an instant while simultaneously getting that lovely zero g feeling if falling. Lasted like the article says maybe only a few seconds but I'd be lying if it didn't get my adrenaline going and a few expletives out of me.
- cmurf 9y agoI like a bit of "chop" (light to moderate and rhythmic turbulence). I really really do not like phugoid oscillations on an international night flight over the north pole. That was pretty creepy.
- cmurf 9y agoThis is bad ass. 777 wing test. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rak2HldVp9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rak2HldVp9M That amount of deflection is insane, you'd never see that in normal flight. (Pilot here.) The article mentions “turbulence penetration speed” or Vb and "maneuvering speed" or Va. Simplistically these are speeds below which the wing will stall before it breaks. The wing is designed to gradually stall in these conditions not abruptly. You really won't feel it unless you know what you're looking for and you're reasonably experienced as a pilot. The wing just kinda gradually craps out rather than being over stressed, and just as quickly starts to fly normally again. Seriously the plane can structurally take extreme turbulence when flown at or below the proper safety speed, even though by definition at extreme turbulence the pilot is just along for the ride (the plane is not considered controllable with extreme turbulence, you get to pick a speed and kinda sorta a general direction, you don't get to control the altitude or the attitude). I've not experienced extreme turbulence and have no desire to, but have been in severe turbulence and don't need to do that again. But the plane is alright.
- dkbrk 9y agoMicrobursts (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microburst https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microburst) can be very dangerous. I'm not sure if these would be correctly classified as "turbulence", though.
- peteretep 9y agoI was on a wide body a few months ago and we had a very sudden burst of pretty intense turbulence -- we'd apparently hit the wake of an A380
- mannykannot 9y agoIn a glider, turbulence is often the first indication that you are flying into a thermal that will lift you up, while the sinking or neutral air between thermals is often smooth. After having experienced this for a while, the onset of turbulence triggers positive emotions, even when you are in an airliner.
- clueless123 9y agoYea! when the beep of the vario kicks in, is like: free fuel!
- averagewall 9y agoA bit of a tangent, but a comforting thought is that unusually strong turbulence counterintuitively has a beneficial effect on fatigue crack propagation. Aluminium always has cracks and they're keep growing but a heavy load that opens up a crack plastically deforms the material around the crack tip so that its natural state is for the crack to stay open. But the rest of the structure forces it closed. Once it's in this state, subsequent smaller higher frequency loads don't apply the usual damaging tensile stress to the crack tip so it doesn't grow like it otherwise would have. Not going to stop the wings falling off on your flight though, but it might help the next guy if it's some South American airline that never maintains its planes :P
- gerbilly 9y agoTurbulence in flight might not crash the plane, but do sit down and wear your seatbelt when advised to. A sudden drop of 40 feet can propel you upward toward the ceiling and break your neck.
- geff82 9y agoAs someone very much interested in flying, I find this article perfect.
- bigdubs 9y agoMy favorite explanation (though not comprehensive) was in The Hunt For Red October: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htTLYO-zOww https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=htTLYO-zOww
- nunez 9y agoThis is a straight rip from Cockpiy Confidential, which was a really great book