4 ms·
> Laws are not the word of God, and just because there is a law, it doesn't mean you stop discussing it. In America, government operates on the rule of law not
by danso 9y ago
> Laws are not the word of God, and just because there is a law, it doesn't mean you stop discussing it.
In America, government operates on the rule of law not the Word of God. Discussing an alternate universe in which America is a theocracy seems a bit off-topic for this particular thread.
> Which is why I think private discrimination laws are ridiculous, because they are effectively unenforceable.
Are you suggesting that the submitted article, to which this discussion thread is attached, is a figment of our imagination? That Google actually is not facing a class-action lawsuit made possible through age-discrimination laws?
> Most prejudiced employers will not print out a rejection letter stating the exact prejudice that led to the decision.
Are you unaware of cases (or unable to currently use Google) in which companies were found in violation of age discrimination laws?
- lend000 9y ago> Discussing an alternate universe in which America is a theocracy seems a bit off-topic for this particular thread. > Are you suggesting that the submitted article, to which this discussion thread is attached, is a figment of our imagination? That Google actually is not facing a class-action lawsuit made possible through age-discrimination laws? I will try to clear up your confusion -- you are taking everything very literally. There have been many private discrimination lawsuits, and in my opinion, all of the legitimate ones were tied in with something other than discrimination (especially harrassment). There is almost never any hard proof of discrimination of the nature that is the focus of the lawsuit, even the ones that win, and I think it's too arbitrary a thing to try to control. Feel free to list examples to the contrary, where the defendant stated "I did not hire Mr/Mrs. Smith because he/she is X." It also raises questions of freedom of association in the private space.
- danso 9y agoSerious question: do you believe that all/most defendants who are convicted of murder have confessed to murder, or committed the murder in full view of a judge? Are you unaware that many convictions, criminal and civil, are built on cases that do not require confessions nor motive? Fortunately for plaintiffs, "hard proof" can come in a variety of ways other than the defendant writing out "Let's break the law" https://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/newsroom/release/8-22-11a.cfm https://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/newsroom/release/8-22-11a.cfm
- lend000 9y agoI didn't see any proof in your linked article, but it succinctly describes what we already know: "The law requires employers to base employment decisions upon each person’s strengths and talents instead of relying upon generalized assumptions calculated around an employee’s age" Also, this is a case of dismissal, which is more often tied to something tangible like a pension, vesting shares, etc., and can therefore be addressed as a contractual breach of faith instead of needing a new legal class to describe. I have mostly been focused on hiring but it applies here, too. Serious answer: the difference is that the crime is what the employer was thinking while making the employment decision, where the action is only a crime contingent on the 'thought crime.' Do you not see the difference between prosecuting an action and a thought? Sure, there are modifications like "premeditation" and "involuntary" but the core crime is an action, not the thought itself. Even with "conspiracy to commit" laws, the conspiracy refers to an action which is unequivocally a crime. In the case of discrimination, it is the goal of the trial to determine whether the action was a crime based on what the "perpetrator" was thinking. Do you not see how that is in its own league? It's almost Orwellian, if not for the good intentions.
- danso 9y ago> Do you not see the difference between prosecuting an action and a thought?...Even with "conspiracy to commit" laws, the conspiracy refers to an action which is unequivocally a crime. Again, it is a crime to discriminate on the basis of age. If you ignore that premise, then this discussion becomes pretty abstract. You could make the case that companies would (and have, in the past) save a lot of money by employing child labor. I agree that prosecuting based on what someone is "thinking" could lead down the slippery slope of Orwellian dystopia. Which is why these prosecutions are not based on thoughts, but on actions. If I were a restaurant owner, I have the right to use Confederate flags and Nazi memorabilia as decor. But as soon as I refuse to serve Jewish and black people -- even if I think such persons aren't a great return on investment because I perceive them to order/tip less than other customers -- I am in violation of federal law.
- lend000 9y ago
- epalmer 9y agoI am aware of a case where employee s performance was criticized in written form because "you are too old". I can't detail specifics because of confidential issues. But there are times that people put their bias in written form.