29 ms·
> In court documents, Fillelkes claimed that a recruiter told her she needed to put her dates of graduation on her resume so the company could view how old she
by danso 9y ago
> In court documents, Fillelkes claimed that a recruiter told her she needed to put her dates of graduation on her resume so the company could view how old she was.
That is one (allegedly) dumb recruiter.
- kafkaesq 9y agoPar for the course for recruiters, actually.
- orbitingpluto 9y ago"I'm sorry, I need someone with 8 years experience with Server 2016. 2008 and 2012 are not what the client specified."
- kafkaesq 9y agoI've seriously started to wonder if many of these people wouldn't just starve (or take to begging in the streets) if there wasn't such a profession as "recruiting" laid out for them. Given the alarming cognitive deficits as they are routinely observed to have.
- flukus 9y agoYou know how users never read error messages? I suspect they never read period, they just copy and paste various things and have no real idea of what they're doing, no awareness. The recruiters just know the process of "get this JD, add our generic stuff, remove their generic stuff, post it on a job board". Just last week we had the CFO complain that the kept being notified about something despite having clicked on the button that "makes it go away". The button was grayed out and disabled. They didn't seem worried that the were unable to perform their job duty, just that they couldn't get rid of the reminder.
- rspeer 9y agoI mean, we can snark about recruiters being bad at what they do and not understanding people's qualifications, but this is different. Recruiters being merely bad isn't illegal. Until the point where they ask "hey, before we proceed, can you tell us if you're a member of a protected class?"
- toomanybeersies 9y agoNitpick: You can't /be/ a member of a protected class. Protected classes are attributes that you can't discriminate against. Being black doesn't make you in a protected class, ethnicity is a protected class.
- rspeer 9y agoTrue, that is an important clarification. I hope nobody's reading what I said as "there are certain people you are not allowed to not hire", but given the last few days on HN, of course someone's reading it that way. Oh well. My point was that the recruiter could not make it any more obvious that they are discriminating. One of the first things I learned about interviewing is that you just don't ask questions related to protected classes, because you could not possibly benefit from getting the answer. How could someone whose entire job is about hiring not know this?
- itg 9y agoFilling out online job applications, I noticed they often require graduation dates and won't let you proceed if you leave it blank. Allows them to quickly estimate your age.
- drdeadringer 9y agoI haven't encountered this yet. What systems are you applying through?
- ubernostrum 9y agoFully-automated forms for gathering that kind of data are common outside tech and starting to show up in tech at some larger companies, especially those not seen as "startup" (either current or former). I know someone who tried to apply to a position at a large tech company and could not complete their initial forms; this person has a master's degree from a top-25 university, is soon to have a Ph.D., has studied at the London School of Economics... but left high school early to go straight to college. Date of high-school graduation was a mandatory field in their online form, and nobody at the company could come up with a way to bypass the use of that form (and entering false information, of course, is not permitted). This person may literally have to go back and get a GED after obtaining a Ph.D. in order to be able to fill out a job application.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- devrandomguy 9y ago> nobody at the company could come up with a way to bypass the use of that form Yeah, that's a big red flag. Sounds like the system is programming the people.
- ubernostrum 9y agoSounds like the system is programming the people. Welcome to big tech companies.