4 ms·
>The nature and source of sex differences are also of practical importance. Most of us agree that there are aspects of the world, including gender disparities,
by Barrin92 9y ago
>The nature and source of sex differences are also of practical importance. Most of us agree that there are aspects of the world, including gender disparities, that we want to change. But if we want to change the world we must first understand it, and that includes understanding the sources of sex differences. "
completely agree with Pinker's sentiment but it is very important to note that for him understanding nature is emancipatory.
For him understanding our natural limitations is a means to figure out how to overcome them. For people preoccupied in this debate scientific discovery about differences seems to be used in the way some mad 19th century eugenistics used it, as a quasi religious justification of the status quo.
This is exactly the wrong way to approach the topic, and precisely how the googler attempted to portray the existing evidence. This produced the outlash.
- mpweiher 9y agoExcept that the author of the memo used it exactly in the Pinker sense: "We want more diversity. I want more diversity" "What we're doing, it's not working" "Maybe we're doing it wrong. Maybe we're missing something" "Here are things [well-supported by the science] that we might be missing" "Here's how we might use this knowledge to make things better"
- Barrin92 9y agoIf that truly was or is his intention I don't think he has found the best way to express this. Pointing towards female neuroticism, criticising 'politically correctness' and vague allusions to 'Marxism', he managed to make himself sound like a real jerk with exactly the agenda in mind women do not want to experience any more. If you want to have a cool-headed discussion don't style yourself as a martyr and accuse other people of silencing you. This is not the way to have that discussion.
- mpweiher 9y ago> female neuroticism While he used the technically correct term, its use without explaining the term was definitely unwise. I explain here: http://blog.metaobject.com/2017/08/the-science-behind-manifesto.html http://blog.metaobject.com/2017/08/the-science-behind-manife... > accuse other people of silencing you Considering they fired him, not exactly a baseless accusation.
- jxramos 9y agoThis is a fascinating thought about the emancipatory aspect to this, but I also recognize it presupposes obstacles at the current boundaries that are capable of being pushed as opposed to some fixed upper limit constraint. I think the area where we could all benefit from much thought is just what sort of effort would be involved in this boundary enlarging in order to weigh the cost of such an endeavor. I think its always fair to presume yielding boundaries and is probably my optimism that speaks, but it seems to me a lot of the outrage spans from someone declaring ultimate constraints and fixed boundaries. More thought should go to harnessing the potential energy if you will for doing work in a certain force field to draw a physical analogy and understanding the friction experienced in the motions of both bodies. If one presents less effort, that is a key fact to consider.