3 ms·
> I'm curious what practical applications there are None. It's totally pointless actually. Very cool, but pointless. All those solar cells and batteries cost
by ars 16y ago
> I'm curious what practical applications there are
None. It's totally pointless actually.
Very cool, but pointless.
All those solar cells and batteries cost more than just fueling it with regular fuel, and leaving the solar cells on the ground to power other things.
> Cheap, quick-to-setup communications relay
> Small datacenter
> Long-term airborne
Not cheap at all, and a blimp (zeppelin) would do a much better job for all of those.
(The batteries alone cost more than $20,000, and the solar cells probably in the $100,000 range, and the carbon fiber around $50,000 for the raw materials. I would estimate half a million each if mass produced.)
It might possibly be interesting for continuous surveillance, if you have no ground station where you can land. (But it flies so slow (43 mph) that it would take a very very long time to get anywhere.)
For regular constant surveying it's cheaper to have two planes and use them in relays.
I'm all for reducing hydrocarbon usage, but lets reduce it for fixed installations, and save the hydrocarbons for the mobile ones (planes, cars).
If you look at the specs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HB-SIA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HB-SIA it can just barely fly, it's not even strong enough to hold two people.
- gaius 16y agoLOL! I suppose you would say the Wright Brothers were wasting their time, "it's not even strong enough to hold two people" indeed! All exciting new technologies start out too feeble for practical use, just like human babies...
- ars 16y agoNot exactly. They said: "Once improved battery efficiency makes it possible to reduce the weight, a two-seater is envisaged to make a non-stop circumnavigation." Uh hu. We've been waiting for improved battery technology for decades. This is cool, but utterly impractical. Solar power plus batteries simply are not physically capable of doing a better job. They are going for high profile, but low impact projects. High profile - what's cooler than a perpetual plane? But low impact - if they actually wanted to help reduce hydrocarbon usage this is not good way to do it. I totally see the coolness. But my response was about the practicality.
- gaius 16y agoBut battery technology is improving and that should be easy to prove: these weren't lead-acid batteries after all.
- hugh3 16y agoI'm thinking the best application would be maritime surveillance. It takes a long time to get to the loiter zone, but once it's there it can circle indefinitely (I'm assuming it can be made unmanned). If you're ~1000 miles from the nearest airbase that's probably a lot cheaper than swapping planes out every N hours, and the $0.5 million cost is virtually nothing on a military budget. I can't think of any good civilian uses, though.
- borism 16y agonot only navies use oceans - there are magnitude more commercial vessels that are currently forced to either use very unreliable low bandwidth or very expensive satellite communications.
- hugh3 16y agoI was suggesting it for surveillance, like the detection of smugglers, illegal fishing, et cetera. I can't imagine that it would be in any way cheaper than satellite communications if all you need is a communications relay.