3 ms·
Yes, the alternative to this is the patent scheme the pharma industry uses. Think about it - a drug may be trivially simple to manufacture, the hard part is dev
by gaius 16y ago
Yes, the alternative to this is the patent scheme the pharma industry uses. Think about it - a drug may be trivially simple to manufacture, the hard part is developing it in the first place then shepherding it through the FDA approval process. So they rely on patents because secrecy at that scale is impossible.
For an example closer to home, did you never wonder how RMS working alone was able to put Symbolics out of business? Because he waited for them to discover what users wanted, the hard part, then he simply copied the implementation and gave it away for free. If they'd gone stealth, maybe we'd all be using LispM's today. Now we'll never know.
- steve19 16y agoIf one guy working from a closet at MIT can destroy your multi-million dollar business, then you are in the wrong business.
- gaius 16y agoYou've completely missed my point. The hard part is NOT the coding. It's knowing what to code, what features your users want. Symbolics did the hard part, RMS merely copied what they (market) researched. Like the way anyone can make a copy of a DVD once a studio has actually made the film.
- rmc 16y agoMovie studios are in the business of making movies, plural. Just cause I can copy DVDs once and set up a DVD burning shop doesn't mean I can make the next movie. Movie studios have the process and equipment (cameras, sets), contacts (directors, actors) to make movies. If the hardest part of your business can be so easily copied by someone else, then you do have a problem. If it can't be copied then you might not have a problem
- gaius 16y agoSimilarly, as demonstrated by the fact that we aren't all using LispM's today, Stallman could copy features from Symbolics but he couldn't compete per se, as he had no way of doing the hard part, which was figuring out what the end users wanted.