4 ms·
FTA: > Damore said: "I went to a diversity programme at Google, it was ... not recorded, totally secretive. I heard things that I definitely disagreed with in
by ajross 9y ago
FTA:
> Damore said: "I went to a diversity programme at Google, it was ... not recorded, totally secretive. I heard things that I definitely disagreed with in some of our programmes. I had some discussions there, there was lots of just shaming, and 'No you can’t say that, that's sexist' and 'You can't do this.'
That is, he took a bland corporate diversity training class and tried starting fights. The tell here is "you can't say that" with no antecedent for "that". Yeah: if you tell your diversity class that women aren't cut out for work at Google, you're going to cause a fight.
- vanattab 9y ago>if you tell your diversity class that women aren't cut out for work at Google, you're going to cause a fight When did he ever say that?
- ajross 9y agoIt was the thesis of his viral letter[1]. I'm simply supposing that he tried out the same argument in an informal context first, and that's what he's complaining about here. [1] Yes, it was. Don't pretend that it wasn't. If he genuinely felt that women and minorities were just as valuable candidates why did he write 10 pages about why efforts to ensure their inclusion were hurting google? The fact that he framed the argument creatively doesn't change the fact that fundamentally he feels Google is hiring too many women, thus the diatribe.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- howdydutty 9y agoBut he wasn't insinuating that diversity was hurting google.. he was suggesting reasons for why he thought there wasn't enough diversity and how it could be beneficial.
- camperman 9y ago> I'm simply supposing that he tried out the same argument in an informal context first, and that's what he's complaining about here. Right, so you made that up. You're objecting strongly to something you THINK he MAY have done. Maybe. > [1] Yes, it was. Don't pretend that it wasn't. His thesis speaks for itself. Your objection to it is really your objection to what you THINK he means, instead of what he said. I think you may have just proved a few of his points.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xapata 9y agoPeople say that hiding behind pronouns is a cardinal sin.
- 3princip 9y agoWhat an absurd interpretation. If anything the guy appears to be very quiet and shy. Having said nothing sexist at all up till now, in the memo or otherwise, insinuating that this guy picked a fight and had some sort of outburst in front of the thought police, all based on the use of the word "that"?! Hah!
- Torwald 9y agoIt is indeed absurd. If you watch his interview on YouTube, how this guy acts and talks, it is very hard to imagine him picking fights. I can't see anybody who is sincere doing this.
- camperman 9y ago> bland corporate diversity training class Not bland if it offended him enough to prompt his memo. > The tell here is "you can't say that" with no antecedent for "that". Yeah: if you tell your diversity class that women aren't cut out for work at Google, you're going to cause a fight. There is no evidence at all that he said anything like that during a diversity class. The only evidence we have is his memo. Which doesn't say women aren't cut out for work at Google. Thanks for playing.
- mikeash 9y agoThis whole thing has been a wonderful example of trolling, in the old-school sense where you say something superficially calm and reasoned but which will inflame passions and start a big argument. We are so prone to evaluating messages based on their form. If someone is ranting and cursing and shouting, we fundamentally assume that they're irrational. If someone speaks calmly and clearly and uses objective wording we assume that they're rational. We read this statement, see "there was lots of just shaming," and our immediate natural reaction is to think, "Well that sucks, Google shouldn't shame people, this guy is being persecuted." But that's not the information actually presented here. All this statement tells us is that this guy felt shamed. Was that because the people were actually shaming him? Or was it because they stated facts that this guy feels shamed by? Or something else? We have no idea.
- ajross 9y agoExactly. Really, this is the strongest, best-constructed and best-applied "anti-SJW screed" we've seen yet. Gamergate sucked young-white-male-techies in, but made no sense to anyone else. This is the spin they should have taken from the beginning. "Guy got fired by Google for making perfectly reasonable points about why women aren't good at tech" is something every conservative can get behind. Clearly Google messed up here and walked into a trap.
- josteink 9y agoHe never said women are not good at tech. He said on average, as a group, they are less interested in tech, but that we should treat everyone as individuals. That's not very controversial, now is it?
- ajross 9y agoSemantics. He said that the women Google was hiring were not as good as the men that Google is hiring. The point of his thesis was that Google was hiring too many women (and minorities, since the programs he was attacking target both, though he avoided getting into specifics on this one). That's, yeah, rather controversial. How would you feel if your coworker and all his friends (c.f. all you guys posting here) felt that you were sub-par? Would you tell your female coworkers this to their face? "I don't think your gender is not good at tech per se, but you personally were hired from a too-large pool of candidates and that makes you not as good at your job as I am. You probably shouldn't have been hired".
- ZeroGravitas 9y ago> 'No you can’t say that, that's sexist' and 'You can't do this.' Well, that's certainly an accurate description of a corporate diversity seminar. I just completed a corporate training about bribery, just lots of "No you can't accept that gift", "No, you can't give the contract to someone who's family works for the government in return". If I'd been accepting bribes I'd probably feel shamed.